Printable View
As we all know , the investigation time in all League is 30s. Below or at Titan, you can choose either pass of loot the one you think the easiest or richest. Also given that in BH, you have 60s to switch your troop and analyze the base.
However, you have no choice in Legend League but to use the fixed troop and come up with the attack route in 30s only.
Do anyone think this is enough or just fine as it is? And what are your opinions? Let's discuss it ~
An addition of 15 more seconds to scout the base would go a long way now that we have a more "surgical" hero at th13. But not just in legends.
IMO ,this is just fine .It makes the legends challenging...only skilled players can do this in the legends in the present time and i think this is what we want for our leaderboards to be like ??Quote:
Originally Posted by kkgame
In old legends it was practically identical...
Unless you wanted to hit next and wait another 2hrs!
Leave as is I think.
From the OBS FAQ:
- Can I scout the 8 bases I've been given to attack?
- No. We thought about scouting in the early development of the feature. But we did want to differentiate it from Clan Wars. Part of what allures players to the multiplayer matchmaking is that improvisational skill required to attack the base you're given. It's what makes the feature different from Clan Wars and requires a different set of skills to be good at.
Although there was no Supercell response, this issue and others in Legends were extensively discussed by players: https://forum.supercell.com/showthre...g+time+legends.
tl;dr (although this isn't the only point made): The advantage the average Legends player would get with a longer scouting time would also be granted to the more-skilled players.
While one can argue a skilled player's advantage would cap at 100% destruction, as an average Legends player, I don't see extra time helping my spray-and-pray army get more stars/destruction.
Fully understand your point. There is no doubt that only skilled players can stay Legend League.Quote:
Originally Posted by TH9clasherIND
We may think from the other side, why we don't do the same in Clan War? We have 24 hrs (more exactly 23 hrs 54 mins) to scout the enemy base, because we want the attack to have a more comprehensive route rather than a rushed one. As for Titan or below, players has opportunity to choose enemy. But in Legend, neither opponents nor troops can be switched. That makes Legend League extraordinarily difficult. If we force the players to make decision in 30s, they may not give a nice and wonderful attack. Then our mindset changed from enjoying the game to rushing for the trophies. For me, enjoy the game and perform a good , nice show (attack) is the most important part in CoC.
If Legend is designed to push a player to his limit, I agree with the current setting. But if we want CoC to be an enjoyable game , then a longer scouting time may be suggested.
Quote:
Originally Posted by DoritosSk
Can I draw your conclusion as below ?
The scouting time should be increased because the base size is bigger and things are more in higher TH level. The increased scouting time is not because it's in Legend League.
Mostly true. You can switch the siege engine and toggle the Warden to air or ground.Quote:
Originally Posted by kkgame
Sure, we do have more things to think about while attacking.Quote:
Originally Posted by kkgame
For example, I was trying this hog and miner hybrid attack, planning their path, plus planning a qw, plus where to drop a blimp with yetis
When I was ready I noticed my attack timer had already started and was "2:50" already.
Of course it happened since it's a new attack for me and I'm not used to it, but nobody would hurt for more scout time.
Another QoL improvement could be to add a sound cue when the scout time runs out without dropping anything.
Something like additional 30 second for scout
You can rush your attack or use a full of one minute to prepare
QoL
IMO 30 seconds is perfect to test the specific skill in legends, as well as to allow the proper time for a raid scout in other leagues.
No need to change it.
I'm totally fine with the time right nowQuote:
Originally Posted by Trinacria
But it's (30+) don't change anything... You can rush or
You can use full of scout time before attack
It's optional ...
Quote:
Originally Posted by Trinacria
What if, the scouting time increased to 45s or 60s, do you feel it's fair / not good ? Will it damage the balance or other reasons ?
Thank you for providing the reference.Quote:
Originally Posted by toofinedog
I have actually read through the post last year when Legend League first came out. At the time, people also complaint that the flexibility of attack is very low. They suggested giving players two or more troop choices, which can compensate the fixity.
IMO, this suggestion makes things complicated, there are many things to be changed which makes SC unwilling to adapt it.
On the other side, we can increase the flexibility by increasing the scout time. That would enable players to analyze the base with fixed troops more thoroughly. I think it helps players to have higher 3-star rate.
I think CoC is a kind of enjoyment, not a job duty. I don't wanna see people rushing bases with Edrag every time just for finishing the daily tasks. I wanna see people love and try their best to perform a good show !
I would not be opposed to an extra 30 seconds in legend league. I really don't see the harm this would cause and the benefits for some players would be huge.