My idea for clan wars! (With pictures for a better guide) (Please read)

What about ally's!

Maybe when they introduce clan wars they'll put in the whole thing! What I mean is, not just have enemies, but alliances/allies! Maybe this could put 2,3 or 4 clans together and all could donate together and fight each other's wars! I think this would be an awesome idea, but we'll have to wait for the next update :p:p

your idea its a mess , i didn't understand at all

Best clan wars idea yet!! (I've seen a ton!) ;)

I as considering just not responding to this thread but it seams you took so much time and effort im gonna give so e feedback.

1.farming clans could destroy full in pushing low lvl clans other possibility the accept/decline and deny switch could be usefull

2.50 gems is apropriate

3.overall well tough out you got my thumbs up

How quickly would an average war last? also, what if someone lost a defense while offline? they wouldnt have a chance, so maybe double elimination?

Quote:

Originally Posted by jeremy88

One thing I might add is instead of finding the clan by trophies, do it the total level of all the players(If Possible). Many clans farm and they would just destroy every low level clan. You would count up each person's level and find wars like that. FOR EXAMPLE:

Clan:Mega Clan:North 44
Level 135-Player 1 Level 143-Player 1
Level 131-Player 2 Level 123-Player 2
Level 128-Player 3 Level 134-Player 3
Level 119-Player 4 Level 169-Player 4
Level 147-Player 5 Level 120-Player 5
TOTAL: 660 Levels TOTAL: 689 Levels
*There would be more members(I'm too lazy)
Maybe a range of 500 trophies. I think this would help lower level clans find clans that they could have a fair war with. Thanks for reading and post any comments!

Thanks for this suggestion, I will change my current one:)

Quote:

Originally Posted by jeremy88

Thinking back to it,500 would be too much. Maybe 15-30 levels since there are so many clans too choose from.

Okay, That be good too, thanks!

Quote:

Originally Posted by aTh

nice idea, although i don't think SC will be happy to give gems for free... even if they are 50 for every player in the clan, but overall i really like the concept!

P.S: Quantam's / Quantom's but never Quantum's Web... if you use their name at least make sure it's the correct one... obviously this is an example but it's always nice to be as professional when you propose a new idea in public, as possible!

lol sorry for getting your clan name wrong, but thanks for the feedback.
I might look over and lower the award for gems

Quote:

Originally Posted by Drich7177

Interesting idea, I think it would be fun! However 50 gems is probaly too much for supercell to give, but I wouldn't mind!

Yeah, I will lower it then :)
[QUOTE=Geogalaxy;1271628]You are giving way to many gems per clan members! What if some of them don't even help in the war? I think gems should only be given the top 3 people (In the clan that won) that best helped in the war(Got the most points). This way, people who didn't help out with the war couldn't get free gems :D. Other than that, this is the same idea that I was thinking of(and most of the people I know.) Great work explaining though.[/QUOTE

Thank you, will be changing these :)

Quote:

Originally Posted by STorMzZ

Very good idea

Thanks!

Quote:

Originally Posted by penguin1853

you should be only able to challenge clans near your points like maybe 3000 over of under your points since then maybe 10000 poeple would just declare war on north44 and they would not want spma

Yeah I'll lower it

Quote:

Originally Posted by ClashinZach

If you are going to base clans that you can attack off of trophys that will be abused instantly. All the clans have to do is drop lower and boom your gonna be starting war against extremely easy clans. Therefore gem farming easily.

I'll lower the clan point difference

Quote:

Originally Posted by cmanos1

Im not sure if i read it all correctly, but if there is a max of 50 people in a clan, with everyone or even a few people attacking, it would be over quickly. Also, if you are offline while your clan does this, and you lose a defence, you would be out before you started. If im wrong please correct me.:)

Yes, you have to have 40 people at least in your clan to join a war
Also, I can season lasts two weeks, BUT can be shorter depending on how fast a clan loses.

Anyways, Thanks for the feedback :)

Quote:

Originally Posted by cmanos1

i think we could just have the clans be able to attack any clan within 500 trophies of the total clan's cups, and remember, clans can always refuse to battle, so farming/preying on low levels shouldnt be an issue.

Yeah I'll be changing that

Quote:

Originally Posted by boghertz

No sky fam in the pictures i'ma so sad ;-;

MUHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
lol jk

Quote:

Originally Posted by AgentJasper

Maybe when they introduce clan wars they'll put in the whole thing! What I mean is, not just have enemies, but alliances/allies! Maybe this could put 2,3 or 4 clans together and all could donate together and fight each other's wars! I think this would be an awesome idea, but we'll have to wait for the next update :p:p

Quote:

Originally Posted by Zangetsu

your idea its a mess , i didn't understand at all

Thats why you read the text, not skim it.
You're being lazy

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nellybelly

Best clan wars idea yet!! (I've seen a ton!) ;)

Thanks lol:)

LOVE THE IDEA- only problem is that it's EXTREMELY difficult to win on defense at high trophies! Everyone would be "Out" very fast, as many attacking players would gem troops! Any other way to eliminate people/clans? Maybe like "Most battles won between 'X' clan and 'Y' clan, goes to clan 'X,' with 150 wins, (all the players' wins added up against clan 'y' over an undetermined period of time) winning over clan 'Y,' who had 120 wins!

Sorry if the above takes a read or two to understand lol, not to much of an easier way to write it :X

Quote:

Originally Posted by cmanos1

How quickly would an average war last? also, what if someone lost a defense while offline? they wouldnt have a chance, so maybe double elimination?

I think the average would be less than A week at least, but if they don't finish in two weeks
Than the system automatically picks who has the least people out

Quote:

Originally Posted by Thomas20247

I as considering just not responding to this thread but it seams you took so much time and effort im gonna give so e feedback.

1.farming clans could destroy full in pushing low lvl clans other possibility the accept/decline and deny switch could be usefull

And this is why I don't think this idea will ever work unless SC makes trophies more valuable than resources.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Thomas20247

I as considering just not responding to this thread but it seams you took so much time and effort im gonna give so e feedback.

1.farming clans could destroy full in pushing low lvl clans other possibility the accept/decline and deny switch could be usefull

2.50 gems is apropriate

3.overall well tough out you got my thumbs up

Quote:

Originally Posted by REDWALL

LOVE THE IDEA- only problem is that it's EXTREMELY difficult to win on defense at high trophies! Everyone would be "Out" very fast, as many attacking players would gem troops! Any other way to eliminate people/clans? Maybe like "Most battles won between 'X' clan and 'Y' clan, goes to clan 'X,' with 150 wins, (all the players' wins added up against clan 'y' over an undetermined period of time) winning over clan 'Y,' who had 120 wins!

Sorry if the above takes a read or two to understand lol, not to much of an easier way to write it :X

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gunnermatt

And this is why I don't think this idea will ever work unless SC makes trophies more valuable than resources.

I will be changing the trophy difference to only 250 trophies apart, that way clans wars can be fair and not unbalanced