Leagues for Clans

Printable View

January 3rd, 2014
Reid

Leagues for Clans PLEASE READ

I think there should be leagues for clans. I know that there is the top 200 and 1st place clan gets 20,000 gems, 2nd place gets 10,000 gems, and third place gets 6,000 gems. But this only includes the top clans what about all the other clan don't they deserve to have a chance too. Leagues for clans would be like the leagues for individual players. The amount of leagues could be anywhere from 10-100 and the amount of clans in a league would have to be locked 100-500 this would be locked until the end of the season. The top three clans of that league get three prizes of gold and elixir (dark elixir if the league is higher) depending on what league your clan is. Also there would be a bonus to the top 10 players when they got to the next league (This would also be a gold and elixir prize (dark elixir if league is higher)). This would promote clan pushing. A clan couldn't go to the next league until the season was over because if you went above the level you lost likely wouldn't get a gem prize. I think that it would be cool if there were clan achievements these would give a reward to the members of the clan and there could be a badge in the clan info page showing that the clan has completed that achievement. This would show that your clan was better than others. This could easily be used for clan wars. You could attack other clans in your league.
Thoughts/Ideas?
January 3rd, 2014
mountaindrew

I disagree. Giving someone a prize for being the best then a prize for being the 500,000th best. Think about what it would be like to be the 4th best clan.
January 3rd, 2014
Reid

Quote:

Originally Posted by mountaindrew

I disagree. Giving someone a prize for being the best then a prize for being the 500,000th best. Think about what it would be like to be the 4th best clan.

It would be like a league bonus the prize would be much lower and as you go up the prizes go up for each league.
January 3rd, 2014
mountaindrew

I simply don't like the idea.
January 3rd, 2014
Vortex64

I feel this is a good idea there needs to be more reasons for clans.
January 3rd, 2014
mountaindrew

Quote:

Originally Posted by Vortex64

I feel this is a good idea there needs to be more reasons for clans.

More reasons? Wow you obiviously aren't in a good clan if you said that.
January 3rd, 2014
Vortex64

Quote:

Originally Posted by mountaindrew

More reasons? Wow you obiviously aren't in a good clan if you said that.

I meant that clans need to be a bigger part of the game. Yes you can receive troops from your clan and chat with your clan. But there needs to be something bigger.
January 3rd, 2014
mountaindrew

Quote:

Originally Posted by Vortex64

I meant that clans need to be a bigger part of the game. Yes you can receive troops from your clan and chat with your clan. But there needs to be something bigger.

It's called Clan Wars
January 3rd, 2014
Reid

Quote:

Originally Posted by mountaindrew

It's called Clan Wars

This is something different from clan wars.
January 3rd, 2014
mountaindrew

Quote:

Originally Posted by Reid

This is something different from clan wars.

Giving an award for nothing?
January 3rd, 2014
Jjs709

Seems good maybe the clans of the lowest league get for first "top ten players each get 10000 gold and elixer" for second 5000 and for third 2500 then double that for each league you go up. Between 10-100 leagues. Second best league prize is for first top ten members get 100 gems second top ten members get 10 gems then third top ten members get 5 gems. Only the top two leagues get gems. Hows this?
January 3rd, 2014
Jjs709

Quote:

Originally Posted by mountaindrew

Giving an award for nothing?

Giving an award based on rank
January 3rd, 2014
mountaindrew

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jjs709

Seems good maybe the clans of the lowest league get for first "top ten players each get 10000 gold and elixer" for second 5000 and for third 2500 then double that for each league you go up. Between 10-100 leagues. Second best league prize is for first top ten members get 100 gems second top ten members get 10 gems then third top ten members get 5 gems. Only the top two leagues get gems. Hows this?

This is better, but I still don't think people should get rewarded for no reason.
January 3rd, 2014
Reid

Quote:

Originally Posted by mountaindrew

Giving an award for nothing?

It would basically reward pushing.
January 3rd, 2014
mountaindrew

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jjs709

Giving an award based on rank

For being 250,000+ in the world? Doesn't make sense.
January 3rd, 2014
Reid

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jjs709

Seems good maybe the clans of the lowest league get for first "top ten players each get 10000 gold and elixer" for second 5000 and for third 2500 then double that for each league you go up. Between 10-100 leagues. Second best league prize is for first top ten members get 100 gems second top ten members get 10 gems then third top ten members get 5 gems. Only the top two leagues get gems. Hows this?

It sounds good at least some reward would be nice.
January 3rd, 2014
Jjs709

Quote:

Originally Posted by Reid

It sounds good at least some reward would be nice.

Yep you got it. Only the gemmers are in the top clans.
January 3rd, 2014
Jjs709

Quote:

Originally Posted by mountaindrew

For being 250,000+ in the world? Doesn't make sense.

It might work we will work on it. So why don't you? What's wrong? how can we fix it? Are you too lazy to do anything but criticize?
January 3rd, 2014
FrankoRc

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jjs709

Seems good maybe the clans of the lowest league get for first "top ten players each get 10000 gold and elixer" for second 5000 and for third 2500 then double that for each league you go up. Between 10-100 leagues. Second best league prize is for first top ten members get 100 gems second top ten members get 10 gems then third top ten members get 5 gems. Only the top two leagues get gems. Hows this?

I like the overall idea but I really really like jjs709's idea instead of gems use recourses

And to Mountain these are not gem rewards to make the top players feel bad on rewards...
January 3rd, 2014
Reid

Yeah resources might be better than gems.
January 3rd, 2014
Jjs709

Quote:

Originally Posted by FrankoRc

I like the overall idea but I really really like jjs709's idea instead of gems use recourses

And to Mountain these are not gem rewards to make the top players feel bad on rewards...

Maybe a resource award to the top ten people in each clan just for getting into that league? Like now with player leagues it doesn't matter your rank, you still get the reward. Then the top 3 players each are in there own league. Hows this?
January 3rd, 2014
Reid

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jjs709

Maybe a resource award to the top ten people in each clan just for getting into that league? Like now with player leagues it doesn't matter your rank, you still get the reward. Then the top 3 players each are in there own league. Hows this?

Maybe you get a bonus for getting into the league and being the top clan in the league.
January 3rd, 2014
Jjs709

Quote:

Originally Posted by Reid

Maybe you get a bonus for getting into the league and being the top clan in the league.

Sure that sounds great! Update your first post with these new ideas
January 3rd, 2014
FrankoRc

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jjs709

Maybe a resource award to the top ten people in each clan just for getting into that league? Like now with player leagues it doesn't matter your rank, you still get the reward. Then the top 3 players each are in there own league. Hows this?

Yes only recourse awards and let's say leagues 75-100 get dark elixir bonuses? I think we're onto something...also probably more that 100 leagues?
January 3rd, 2014
Jjs709

Quote:

Originally Posted by FrankoRc

Yes only recourse awards and let's say leagues 75-100 get dark elixir bonuses? I think we're onto something...also probably more that 100 leagues?

How about there can only be 500-1000 clans in a league. So once your placed and the league fills you have to go down a league. I like the de part too. The filling thing would make people want to get there clan placed asap so they can get a high lvl league.
January 3rd, 2014
bearsnake

That sounds like a good idea. It would make clans more competitive.
January 3rd, 2014
Jessnutt

Clan wars simply wouldn't work as levels aren't even within clans e.g. In my clan I am lvl 107 but there are lvl 40's so unless you wanted to change how clans work so that say like lvl 40+\-10 can only be in a clan together, however I think this defeats the objective of having clans because I like to give my higher level troops to lower levels to help them progress faster.

Beagle Bo 107 (Clan Leader of Brutal Spartans)
January 3rd, 2014
Jjs709

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jessnutt

Clan wars simply wouldn't work as levels aren't even within clans e.g. In my clan I am lvl 107 but there are lvl 40's so unless you wanted to change how clans work so that say like lvl 40+\-10 can only be in a clan together, however I think this defeats the objective of having clans because I like to give my higher level troops to lower levels to help them progress faster.

Beagle Bo 107 (Clan Leader of Brutal Spartans)

Um did you read? THIS ISNT CLAN WARS. Also if you want to go to a clan that cant get you your optimal reward.....that was your choice.
January 3rd, 2014
FrankoRc

So here's how much we have so far:

Idea: Leagues for clans

Awards: recources NOT gems, 1,2,3 place clans get awards top 10 players of clan get the awards. The higher the league the more recources given. 75-100 leagues get DE.

Leagues: Around 100, 500 clans can get into 1 league
January 3rd, 2014
Reid

Quote:

Originally Posted by FrankoRc

So here's how much we have so far:

Idea: Leagues for clans

Awards: recources NOT gems, 1,2,3 place clans get awards top 10 players of clan get the awards. The higher the league the more recources given. 75-100 leagues get DE.

Leagues: Around 100, 500 clans can get into 1 league

Yeah this is different than clan wars and it would make clans work together to be the best in their league this is basically a way to reward clan pushing.
January 3rd, 2014
Vortex64

I hope this gets added to the game.
January 3rd, 2014
Jjs709

Quote:

Originally Posted by FrankoRc

So here's how much we have so far:

Idea: Leagues for clans

Awards: recources NOT gems, all clans get awards top 10 players of clan get the awards. The higher the league the more recources give.top 1000 leagues get DE. (Top 1000 or 500 as there would be many many leagues as there are soooooo many clans.)

Leagues: Around 100, 500 clans can get into 1 league

Ill bold my changes
January 3rd, 2014
FrankoRc

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jjs709

Ill bold my changes

Good changes cant really think if anything else at the moment though....
January 3rd, 2014
Reid

Thanks for all the ideas be sure to post more in the thread if you think of more. I'd like to get some more opinions. Thanks.
January 3rd, 2014
Vortex64

Maybe clan wars could be integrated into the leagues like the clans could attack the other clans in the league.
January 3rd, 2014
FrankoRc

Quote:

Originally Posted by Vortex64

Maybe clan wars could be integrated into the leagues like the clans could attack the other clans in the league.

That's exactly what I was thinking earlier...
January 4th, 2014
Reid

Quote:

Originally Posted by Vortex64

Maybe clan wars could be integrated into the leagues like the clans could attack the other clans in the league.

Great idea this could make clan wars very simple.
January 4th, 2014
bearsnake

That would make clash if clans more fun.
January 4th, 2014
bearsnake

Clash of Clans has to have more clan in it. Right now is is more like clash of players. This would help make clash of clans live up to its name.
January 4th, 2014
Reid

Thanks for your opinions
January 4th, 2014
Reid

Any other thoughts ideas/feedback
January 4th, 2014
ManuelShield

Reid

Reid,
I created a league for clans to participate called Major League Clashing.If you want you can get your clan to participate.Click the link in my signature or send me a pm if you want to participate in the league.
January 4th, 2014
teesee1

The league idea, I like, however I think a prize should be given to every clan in the league. As for who in a certain clan gets the prize, I'm unsure of the optimal way to distribute the loot.
January 4th, 2014
Reid

Yeah I think top 15-25 members maybe??
January 4th, 2014
bearsnake

Quote:

Originally Posted by Reid

Yeah I think top 15-25 members maybe??

I think that the loot should be like league bonuses. Start out small for the lower clan leagues and increase with each level. Each clan member should get a prize because it'a the whole clan who won not just one person.
January 4th, 2014
FrankoRc

Quote:

Originally Posted by bearsnake

Each clan member should get a prize because it'a the whole clan who won not just one
person.

No wrong some clan mates could work harder if we would use the top 10 players that get the awards instead it would encourage an even stronger push... also I have already suggested loot goes up in increments...To Reid ill work on a where we are post right now...
January 4th, 2014
Reid

Quote:

To Reid ill work on a where we are post right now...

Ok sounds good.
January 4th, 2014
FrankoRc

So here's how much we have so far: New one

Idea: Leagues for clans

Awards: resources NOT gems, all clans get awards top 10 players of clan get the awards. The award will be split among the top ten players evenly. The lower the clan in the league the less award they will get. The higher the league the more resources are awarded. Top 250 out of 1000 leagues get DE. (Top 250 or 500 as there would be many many leagues as there are soooooo many clans.)

Leagues: Around 1000, 100 clans can get into 1 league.

This could also be implement in clan wars, how?

Well the way I look at it could be very similar as to regular player leagues but with awards...The clan would be like a player in the league and to get to the top they would have to fight for it....just like regular players do.

ALSO I think clans SHOULD have a choice weather the want to compete in that season or not. So possibly a button to join a league, but once your in you can leave until season is over.
January 4th, 2014
Reid

Yeah they shouldn't have to compete but I think instead of badges it could be like lvl's so the worst would be like a lvl 1 clan to a lvl I don't know 100 maybe.
January 4th, 2014
Vortex64

Yeah but I think we could just make more league names instead of lvls.
January 4th, 2014
TomasCOC

good idea :D
I propose for the competition of clans some seasons/leagues...how its work? easy,there is 10 seasons/leagues,one of this 10 seasons is composed by this clans,the first season is season 10 where the new entry join the competition! how to pass to next season? the win of the war between clans gaves some points that need to get between the clans that arrived at some points ( ex. "50 points" is neeeded to pass to next season) so who arrived to this 50 point can join the next season.

IMPORTANT "every win is 10 points and every lose is decreased by 10 points in the season/league"

Points to need to pass the season/league

season/league 10
point needed to pass: 50
Gift to members: 10.000 gold or elixir Per player

Season/league 9 :
point needed to pass :100
Gift to members : 50.000 gold or elixir per player

Season/league 8 :
point needed to pass :......
Gift to members :......

season/league 7
point needed to pass :......
Gift to members :.....

season/league 6
point needed to pass :......
Gift to members :.....

season/league 5
point needed to pass :......
Gift to members :.....

season/league 4
point needed to pass :......
Gift to members :.....

season/league 3
point needed to pass :......
Gift to members :.....

season/league 2
point needed to pass :......
Gift to members :.....

season/league 1
point needed to pass :......
Gift to members :.....

This is just an Idea... I know somebody dislike my idea but this is balanced because the clans that have hight level players such as for an example "kings Landing" is right that they have stayed in season/league 1/2 because they have most good player than a clan that have 10.000 trophies and it season/league could be 7/8 because they have not good players .
January 4th, 2014
Reid

The clans already have clan points so the leagues could be based on clan points.
January 4th, 2014
FrankoRc

Quote:

Originally Posted by TomasCOC

good idea :D
I propose for the competition of clans some seasons...how its work? easy,there is 10 seasons,one of this 10 seasons is composed by this clans,the first season is season 10 where the new entry join the competition! how to pass to next season? the win of the war between clans gaves some points that need to get between the clans that arrived at some points ( ex. "50 points" is neeeded to pass to next season) so who arrived to this 50 point can join the next season.

IMPORTANT "every win is 10 points and every lose is decreased by 10 points in the season"

Points to need to pass the season

season 10
point needed to pass: 50
Gift to members: 10.000 gold or elixir Per player

Season 9 :
point needed to pass :100
Gift to members : 50.000 gold or elixir per player

Season 8 :
point needed to pass :......
Gift to members :......

season 7
point needed to pass :......
Gift to members :.....

season 6
point needed to pass :......
Gift to members :.....

season 5
point needed to pass :......
Gift to members :.....

season 4
point needed to pass :......
Gift to members :.....

season 3
point needed to pass :......
Gift to members :.....

season 2
point needed to pass :......
Gift to members :.....

season 1
point needed to pass :......
Gift to members :.....

This is just an Idea... I know somebody dislike my idea but this is balanced because the clans that have hight level players such as for an example "kings Landing" is right that they have stayed in season 1/2 because they have most good player than a clan that have 10.000 trophies and it season could be 7/8 because they have not good players .

The whole point of this idea is to not revolve a single person or few that get many attack wins...The idea is to get the clans trophies up instead and therefore get an award. I'd rather stick to the old idea than this...also think all the th's picked off that would result in an outrage because most people get trophy a legitly by going full on with the base to get that magic 3 star...Higher level players deserve a higher reward due to loot penalties. Think of it should high level player be compared to a th5, no...
January 4th, 2014
TomasCOC

...:eek::eek::eek:
January 4th, 2014
Reid

Sounds good
January 4th, 2014
FrankoRc

Quote:

Originally Posted by Reid

The clans already have clan points so the leagues could be based on clan points.

I'd like to add that clan points or also known as clan trophies are not earned off of attacks they are earned off of trophies...So this idea would not coincide to work with Tomas's idea..
January 4th, 2014
TomasCOC

Quote:

Originally Posted by FrankoRc

I'd like to add that clan points or also known as clan trophies are not earned off of attacks they are earned off of trophies...So this idea would not coincide to work with Tomas's idea..

my idea would be applicated to "clan vs clan" ,i know that there is a championship with clans that during 2 week ,but this is the leagues championship where the clans are fighting for the leagues!

The championship that during 2 week is for trophy, my idea is for the battle of clans and not trophy!

if you were right, by any chance there could be two leagues clan? one of the trophies and one clan against clan?

"the game would be much more beautiful and fascinating"
January 4th, 2014
Reid

Ok I understand
January 4th, 2014
Courtii7501

Would be alright, but you would have to be a very strong clan to be in the top.

i have an idea of my own for clan profiles. Check it out http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...-Clan-profiles
January 5th, 2014
bearsnake

Quote:

Originally Posted by Courtii7501

Would be alright, but you would have to be a very strong clan to be in the top.

i have an idea of my own for clan profiles. Check it out http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...-Clan-profiles

There are multiple leagues so you have to be at the top of your league. Meaning you just have to be good for you leagues.
January 5th, 2014
FrankoRc

Quote:

Originally Posted by TomasCOC

my idea would be applicated to "clan vs clan" ,i know that there is a championship with clans that during 2 week ,but this is the leagues championship where the clans are fighting for the leagues!

The championship that during 2 week is for trophy, my idea is for the battle of clans and not trophy!

if you were right, by any chance there could be two leagues clan? one of the trophies and one clan against clan?

"the game would be much more beautiful and fascinating"

Im all for the idea except no points...Should only be based off of clan trophies. Adding points to winning attacks could be much more complicated and aggravating to higher ranked player that the cant pick off th's, while when we have something else to work on or much more solid ground(clan trophies)...The idea of clan wars is simple clan vs clan but you cant truly have a league between 2 clans..either ones winning or ones not...So I believe this could only be implemented into clan-wars leagues of which clan is doing best in its league...similar to player leagues but clan, not player...
January 5th, 2014
Alweert

This is an interesting idea...I wanna see it in game with a few more tweaks and stats
January 5th, 2014
Reid

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alweert

This is an interesting idea...I wanna see it in game with a few more tweaks and stats

What kind of tweaks/stats?
January 11th, 2014
Reid

Hey guys i would really like to get some more feedback on this topic.
January 18th, 2014
derpymonkey

Like the idea. Maybe instead of having more trophy count, they could have individual points for clan leagues such as "war points". When raiding, you could get/lose trophies and war points to get your clan higher in the clan leagues.

All times are GMT. The time now is 04:37 AM.