Anyone else think clan elders should be able to challenge their clan leader for the leadership? If you get two or more stars you become the leader?
Printable View
Anyone else think clan elders should be able to challenge their clan leader for the leadership? If you get two or more stars you become the leader?
That is a terrible idea. If you want to be leader, start your own clan instead of trying to steal something that somebody has worked hard to build.
And for the record, if you were a member of my clan and I saw this post, I'd probably kick you out.
That sounds a little harsh, he is just voicing an idea.Quote:
Originally Posted by Spacecake
However sounds like you may not be happy with your leader. If there are more clan members who feel the same you giys could just leave and make a new clan where you can be leader.
Normally leaders work very hard on the clan to make it a success and you shouldn't be able to coupe d'etat them. If you are really unhappy ...just leave that clan.
So I start a clan, build it up, take this guy into the fold, donate troops to his cause, give him a position as clan elder and then... He stirs up a mutinity, assumes leadership and then potentially (and most likely) kicks me out of my own clan before I can attempt to wrest control back from him?Quote:
Originally Posted by fette
I stand by my word! I'd kick him out. Mutinous thoughts are bad.
:)
This is a great idea. A level 100 troll couldn't possibly destroy hundreds of clans in a day.:rolleyes:
I've heard worse ideas... just not many of them, clan leaders would just stop giving people elder and would have to run their clan completely solo, this would be a huge leap backwards for the game.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Spacecake
Lol well I don't endorse his idea either, and I would certainly talk to him if I was his clan leader as there are some issues it seems ...
but unless you actually GIVE him leader he cannot 'assume' leader and kick everyone. He could however leave and take everyone with. Boom there goes all your hard work as well.
Best thing is to address the issue I think and work it out before it poisons the members!!
No, this would start into an extreme troll faze of COC and harassment would be unbearable.
Terrible idea.
To be fair I didn't think about the Troll thing, I forgot how serious people take this game. My clan's is just friends and friends of friends. I just like the idea of abit of clan infighting, it would create some good banter being able to destroy your mates. In my experience most clan leaders do ♥♥♥♥ all other than create the clan which takes about 10 seconds
maybe you should have to fight the leader to win your elder status
What?! You're suggesting a battle arena where the mutinous clan members pit their troops against the leader in an attempt to take control of the clan?! Too much work for supercell, and too much work just to try and get leader. You're suggesting all this work be done to make possible.... (Drumroll please)Quote:
Originally Posted by bakeryman
MUTINY. That's what it is plain and simple. Mutiny.
As a member of FCCCCoCIS I dont approve of this idea.
The idea itself is in the world of CoC if we place the game to a historical or mediaval time. In the old time the strongest had the leadership of the tribe.
However in the modern world of online gaming the idea is open to terrible abuse and in the offers very little positive additions to the game or clan management while bringing some quite big negative additions.
I agree 101% with u.Quote:
Originally Posted by Spacecake
@OP for both posts:
This just won't work, this is completely unfair. It just won't work... nothing new to say everyone else proved my point.
I made the clan for myself to be the leader, not somebody I don't know. If you want to be the clan leader you can make you own clan. I just don't think that my clan should be at constant risk, especially from the people I trust. This idea makes it not a clan... Just a few people trying to steal leader.
There's more to being a leader than just creating a clan. I tried to create a clan and it takes ages to get a sustainable and reliable team of people behind you. It sounds as though you are underestimating the role of leader and you must have problems with your leader. Terrible, terrible idea. Clan leaders have a heck of role to play in a clan. -1Quote:
Originally Posted by bakeryman
This is one of the worst ideas anyone has come up with. I've spent so much time building my clan up, if this was implemented then all of my work would be gone. What does this do to help the game? Horrible idea. No.
Well if you are an elder you can elder everybody else and tell them to rate the leader horribly terrible idea.
I disagree with this idea, it wouldn't be fair for the leader who spent a lot of time building their clan!
What a terrible idea. I might get an infraction, but that was the worst idea ever posted on forums. Like ever.Quote:
Originally Posted by bakeryman
ayum... maybe ur kinda overreacting ya know...Quote:
Originally Posted by agr1014
yes its not a good idea, but bolding it the second time, dats like overreaction.
Comment on your own threads, don't follow my posts and comment. Thanks.Quote:
Originally Posted by Pranav
i think that this is a good idea
Horrible idea. Building a good clan is very difficult, particularly with the limited recruitment tools available. Loosing your clan to some kid who doesn't have the leadership skills to make one himself is the worst idea on the forum.Quote:
Originally Posted by bakeryman
What a little troll,necroing old threads and supporting stupid ideas.Quote:
Originally Posted by mlpzaq123
Terrible idea