Printable View
It is very sad for me when my button Clan War is off for Me so I really don't want to clan war
Why should my leader can choice me in clan war ?
please respect supercell to privacy player...when i button off clan war nobody Should not be able to choice me in clan war
please respect the choice player SuperCell
supercell can disabled for leader this item...This problem is easily solved by supercell
This is an issue with your clan, not SuperCell.
That button shows your mind that you wanna participate or not.....if they still choose you so that's their problem....talk with your clan properly and clear them your state of mind....it's not the problem of supercellQuote:
Originally Posted by benyaminj
supercell can disabled for leader this item...This problem is easily solved by supercell.Quote:
Originally Posted by IceBird1
what if the same condition is in a new clan....the leader wants to do the war with 10 members but one or two has opted out....he/she will know that they won't attack.....but at least they'd be able to do war and maybe manage it.....Quote:
Originally Posted by benyaminj
otherwise there will be ideas of leader demanding this...
Maybe the leader wants to put the person in to be the 5th or 10th or whatever person just so war can be declared and doesn’t care if you can or cannot attack? Maybe the person chatted with the leader through another method like discord or in real life and asked the leader to put him in war even though the button was off? There are reasons for the leader to put someone in war with the war turned off. If your leader put you in war when you didn’t want in AND is harassing you for not doing your attacks, go to a different clan. If your leader doesn’t care that you aren’t attacking, why do you care?Quote:
Originally Posted by benyaminj
all the problem can solved very easily by Supercell.Quote:
Originally Posted by Kiddo0305
I expect Supercell to respect select player
What is the problem, though?Quote:
Originally Posted by benyaminj
As a clan leader, if we're short players for war, I'll opt somebody in to fill the group. I don't expect them to attack, because they've already signaled thir intent. No one loses out.Quote:
Originally Posted by benyaminj
However, if I could not opt players in to fill out the war roster, then I'd take a much harder look on why I've allowed opted out players to remain in the clan. The end result here, is that you'd likely get booted from the clan.
when Leader Clan selected me for clan war I consider myself committed to participating in the war....But if I don't attack And lose the game all my team angry why don't attack...Nobody cares It was Clan War Button already off button...And no one blames the leader...Because he is the leaderQuote:
Originally Posted by SharkyFinn
Then ask yourself why the clan leader expects people who are marked as “out” to be in and attacking. And why your clan leader isn’t standing up for you when he knows you were red. That’s a clan issue, not a SC issue.Quote:
Originally Posted by benyaminj
Yes. This^^^^Quote:
Originally Posted by Quali
Sounds like you have clan problem. Not a war problem. If your leader treats you in a way you don’t approve of then you should start looking for another clan.
I gave up the leadership of my clan, but I still organise CW/CWL. I really wouldn't want to drop up to 4 players, to do a smaller war, because I couldn't opt in a red toggled player.
The problem is "solvable" only by creati g a much bigger problem.Quote:
Originally Posted by benyaminj
Because you can only war with a multiple of 5, many clans would not be able to war if member preferences could not be overridden if necessary.
That is a much bigger problem than somebody occasionally being put in when they didn't want to.
You need to change clan, as your are clearly totally unreasonable.Quote:
Originally Posted by benyaminj
We sometimes put people in who are marked out, but when we do, we consider it a bonus if they make their atracks, and nobody blames them if they don't. Which s as it should be.
What you are describing is a dysfunctional clan. If they can't/won't understand then my recommendation is to move to a clan where they are more familiar with how it actually works and where they don't behave foolishly. Get out quick buddy.Quote:
Originally Posted by benyaminj
It is not so easy to leave clanQuote:
Originally Posted by Ajax
When you have made many friends over the years
Can you really leave Clan?
Such are life decisions .... I love my job, yet hate my boss. I love my hometown, yet need to move to a new location if I want to keep my job. I want to attend a university in California, yet the one in North Dakota offered me a full scholarship. Etc., etc., etc..Quote:
Originally Posted by benyaminj
You have to weigh the good with the bad, and decide for yourself what is the most tolerable action. Keep in mind another truism in life, in most situations (but not all) people are taken advatage of only because they allow (enable) it to happen. If you feel the clan is taking advantage of you, by not respecting your wishes, and yet you stay, then you are enabling them to.
Speak up! Tell them that if you did not opt in (show green) then you cannot guarantee that you will participate (do any attacks), they then included you at their own risk. Then, abide by that, don't allow them to control you. If you then skip one or two, they will learn you meant what you said.
for any problem There will be a solutionQuote:
Originally Posted by rowman
supercell for solving this problem Says leave Clan...That's not really a convincing answer....they should one solution Find appropriate
supercell have made this option " Whether you want to be at Clan War or not " I don't want to participate right now
Leader can do anything no matter the option...supercell says Leave Clan...This is not a convincing answer...They should be looking for the right solution
You should be looking for the right solution, not SC. Stop expecting SC to run your clan for you. It's your leaders clan, not SC's, they can do what they want.Quote:
Originally Posted by benyaminj
You don't seem to want to hear that your leader or your clanmates are behaving badly when in fact, they are being horrid to you. If YOU choose to stay in that environment that is a choice you make. Horrid people are everywhere and you need to learn how to manage them rather than expecting someone else to manage them for you. Just to add clarity to the title of your post, SC doesn't need to respect the choice of players, they already do and built that in...It is your clanmates and your leader who need to respect player's choices.
You mean ... SC will give you 3 options.
"In-Busy-Out"
QOL Add to this, you can.
What you are saying cannot be undone.
It will be your job to make a request to the SC but this may or may not happen in the next update.
I don't know anything or I don't know much about it.
So much this^^^^Quote:
Originally Posted by Tosti111
If you are opted out and the leader puts you in war... fine. No worries. If the leader and your clan mates then are mad at you for not attacking that is their fault, not yours. What kind of “friends” treat you that way? If it’s that much of a problem for you then leave the clan. You want SC to change the game because your clan mates are jerks. That’s not how this works. There are tens of thousands of clans out there. Go find one with nicer members.
Friends don't yell at you for not attacking in war when the leader put you in with your war turned off. Friends yell at the leader and tell the leader if he does it again you and your friends are going to start a new clan without that leader.Quote:
Originally Posted by benyaminj
Some times the líder most fill some places to start the war if that's happen you affect more players than just one. You are not obligated to participate.
Correct !Quote:
Originally Posted by Ajax
I will not hear all the complaints from members who were on green, but needed to be excluded only because of this "multiple-of-5" restriction and the inability to opt someone in.
It is quite often necessary to use fillers.
And as others already said:
It is a problem of the clan leaders if they would blame you afterwards for not attacking.
Agreeing with all the replies in this discussions, but also understanding OP, either this discussion should be moved to ‘Clan Talk’ (because there is actually no new feature, really), or the feature should be that the status of the player when the war search was started should be present on the war result windows/tables, or a mail be sent automatically listing the players opted in when red (similar to the chat post for cwl bonus medals giveaway, but since it would likely disappear 2 days later...).
I have had the case, as presented by other replies, to opt in ‘red’ players, to make up an adequate war ‘size’: in that case, as a respectful leader, I send a mail listing who is opted in against their choice, and reminding them that their results are not expected, they are just fillers.. But that’s me.
Other way, far more annoying, I’ve had discussions after the war ended, with players that turned to red after the search was started, and complained of being in war :facepalm:...
There’s always people looking for drama in wars. My solution is not to keep them in the clan. (But sometimes it can be the leader/ship).
TL;DR- QoL idea: add war status from start on clan list/result at end of war.