Paying a fee to join a clan

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Julezwatts

Doing this would negate the entire purpose of introducing it in th
e first place. It was suggested as an attempt to stop hoppers, and therefore an 'every time you join' fee.

---

We can have a permant ban on certain players for clans set by the clan leader so this would not be a problem. Also the money should not go to anybody and I think it would deter hopper. It should be based on town hall level also so a town hall ten will pay 50k maybe and a townhall 5 would pay 10k or something . A possible way to add on to this is that the money you spend to join is out into a banks account if some sort and no body but you can get it but a elder has to aprove of you taking it out. So let's say jimmy joins a clan then one week later -clan elder- Johnny decides he can take it back because he has stayed so jimmy gets his 10k back.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by bobhuckins

We can have a permant ban on certain players for clans set by the clan leader so this would not be a problem. Also the money should not go to anybody and I think it would deter hopper. It should be based on town hall level also so a town hall ten will pay 50k maybe and a townhall 5 would pay 10k or something . A possible way to add on to this is that the money you spend to join is out into a banks account if some sort and no body but you can get it but a elder has to aprove of you taking it out. So let's say jimmy joins a clan then one week later -clan elder- Johnny decides he can take it back because he has stayed so jimmy gets his 10k back.

---

No. This could also be abused by a stupid leader who just bans people for no reason.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Julezwatts

No. This could also be abused by a stupid leader who just bans people for no reason.

---

If the leader does that then

a. He probaly dosent have a good clan anyway

b. Find a differnt clan

c. (Alternative way to ban) It could be a vote by elders and clan leader

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by bobhuckins

If the leader does that then

a. He probaly dosent have a good clan anyway

b. Find a differnt clan

c. (Alternative way to ban) It could be a vote by elders and clan leader

---

At this point it seems like it would just be too much trouble to ban someone from your clan forever. Just kick him and don't let him back in.

The clan leader could set a fee and his/her friend keeps leaving and joining to give the leader gold. People with multiple accounts would do this too

This would cause griefing where people are enticed to join the clan, pay the fee, and are then kicked.