Clan hopper revenge option or new member waiting period

So I read the stickies and didn't see anything similar. How about an option to perform a revenge style attack on members who leave clans. Perhaps only available for 24hours, and only able to be performed once, by a clan elder. Another option would be to have an approx 30-60min wait period after joining a clan to be able to request troops.
Either option would discourage the common practice of players joining, requesting, and immediately leaving.

people could abuse it. a townhall 3 joins north 44 leaves and then you get some free trophies. then it keeps happening again and again

Good point, however it would also encourage players to choose clans wisely, and if implemented how i envision it, it would only apply to those who leave a clan, not those kicked.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Fmrracer

Good point, however it would also encourage players to choose clans wisely, and if implemented how i envision it, it would only apply to those who leave a clan, not those kicked.

---

if you changed it to perhaps people in the same trophy league will be able to attack it but that still will be abused

Like everyone above me said,it coukd be easily abused.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by penguin1853

if you changed it to perhaps people in the same trophy league will be able to attack it but that still will be abused

---

The trophy league is a good idea. Again you are right it can be abused, but no less then the act of hopping itself. Another suggestion is treating it as a (if, and, or) loop. Basically if a member leaves, the action arrives in the leaders inbox. The leader would then have a time-frame of 24hrs to approve/deny revenge. If approved, the option would be made available to the clan (within initial time constraints) and be limited by all shields and current constraints.

you could also add that once you revenge someone they will not be able to join the clan for 30 days unless invited back

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by penguin1853

you could also add that once you revenge someone they will not be able to join the clan for 30 days unless invited back

---

That would be good too. In my clan members come and go to recruit so having the ability to activate the revenge action would be preferable to minimize abuse

Um... I think all the data it would require would kill the game and take a few thousand years to load...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by penguin1853

you could also add that once you revenge someone they will not be able to join the clan for 30 days unless invited back

---

Easy work around for this would be to keep creating new clans. I'm fine with the request wait period but only if it is a configurable option.

You could get a friend in the clan to leave, then revenge him and take resources or trophies. Then they join back. It can be easily abused to be able to donate resources/trophies

If you can join back after 30 days when revenged - what dahimi said