Need some constructive criticism!On my new th8 farming base!

Ok so ive designed a new base,ive taken some really good elements from pingfaos tesla theme park (thanks pingfao) and even a lil bit of junliangs pokeball,so far my name for it is "jungfao's love child" LOL!anyway I'm not the best base designer and would really like some constructive criticism on it and some thought on what could make it better or even if u like it all?!?any thoughts are welcomed...thanks guys n girls http://i.imgur.com/PltZ0sM.png one thing i didnt like about the tesla theme park is the CC wasnt fully centralised so this is a lil bit more although not perfectly http://i.imgur.com/ANcpj7m.png hope u guys like it!

You've basically taken a great defense and moved it all about and taken away the best aspects of it....

All storages in 1 compartment is a big no no, you really need to separate them.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by scanners107

You've basically taken a great defense and moved it all about and taken away the best aspects of it....

All storages in 1 compartment is a big no no, you really need to separate them.

---

Do u think i should do some construction work and make some compartments instead of having them in the middle ?When i used the tesla theme park before they rarely got into the middle at gold 3 so thats why ive put them inside like that

And also pingfao has 2 gold storages in the middle too and one off to the side? http://i.imgur.com/RUnbXMY.png or do u think this would be a better way to have the storages?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jazzathegreat

And also pingfao has 2 gold storages in the middle too and one off to the side? or do u think this would be a better way to have the storages?

---

The gold really needs to be seperated as you did after. But the splash buildings need to overlap each other and the wiz towers are so close that you diminish their potential.

maybe put your BK in the middle too, it's what I do.

you can take ifeas of my base if you want : ign conan, clan: ottawa goonz

edit: you should put the spring trap before the bomb too.

One min ill go look now

I would not have both the mortar and wizard tower next to eachother, they could get taken out by lightning spells, and that entire side of your base is weak

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by JosephTheJew

I would not have both the mortar and wizard tower next to eachother, they could get taken out by lightning spells, and that entire side of your base is weak

---

Ok so with the advice given by you great folk ive now changed it to this....which is best?http://i.imgur.com/PAsgiOw.png

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by scanners107

You've basically taken a great defense and moved it all about and taken away the best aspects of it....

All storages in 1 compartment is a big no no, you really need to separate them.

---

You are totally wrong on this point. I've been experimenting with different types of bases at th8 since this latest debacle of an update and a good vault base outperforms a segmented base over the long run. The Completely centralized cc really makes a huge difference for th8.

You have a nice design here but I would recommend a few changes as I'm using a similar base right now. The first is to move the builder huts and one of the giant bombs out and put your teslas in there so you have tesla coverage in your core. Against lvl 6 giants they are the only hope you have of stopping them and they are wasted out on the edge. Also, if gobs happen to make it to your core, lvl 6 teslas will mow down those gobs quick. Next is to get rid of those x junctions on the outside of your base. You have enough extra walls to extend the outer edges to make t junctions instead. This also gives you some space behind your first layer of walls to better utilize your bombs.

other than that I think your design is great.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Smalls

You are totally wrong on this point. I've been experimenting with different types of bases at th8 since this latest debacle of an update and a good vault base outperforms a segmented base over the long run. The Completely centralized cc really makes a huge difference for th8.

You have a nice design here but I would recommend a few changes as I'm using a similar base right now. The first is to move the builder huts and one of the giant bombs out and put your teslas in there so you have tesla coverage in your core. Against lvl 6 giants they are the only hope you have of stopping them and they are wasted out on the edge. Also, if gobs happen to make it to your core, lvl 6 teslas will mow down those gobs quick. Next is to get rid of those x junctions on the outside of your base. You have enough extra walls to extend the outer edges to make t junctions instead. This also gives you some space behind your first layer of walls to better utilize your bombs.

other than that I think your design is great.

---

Yeah see thats why i went with the vault cause i used the tesla theme park and attackers rarely got into the core,now im confused lol,

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Smalls

You are totally wrong on this point. I've been experimenting with different types of bases at th8 since this latest debacle of an update and a good vault base outperforms a segmented base over the long run. The Completely centralized cc really makes a huge difference for th8.

You have a nice design here but I would recommend a few changes as I'm using a similar base right now. The first is to move the builder huts and one of the giant bombs out and put your teslas in there so you have tesla coverage in your core. Against lvl 6 giants they are the only hope you have of stopping them and they are wasted out on the edge. Also, if gobs happen to make it to your core, lvl 6 teslas will mow down those gobs quick. Next is to get rid of those x junctions on the outside of your base. You have enough extra walls to extend the outer edges to make t junctions instead. This also gives you some space behind your first layer of walls to better utilize your bombs.

other than that I think your design is great.

---

Spwhich junctions are u talking about changing?Sorry im not the best designer and am only just learning these finer points

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jazzathegreat

Yeah see thats why i went with the vault cause i used the tesla theme park and attackers rarely got into the core,now im confused lol,

---

Keep it the way it was and just move your teslas and fix the x junctions. The main reason why a vault without any defenses in the core is more effective is because those lvl 6 giants won't go in it. So they merry-go-round around the core and your defenses can take care of them. Heres the current base I'm using (credit to W33ls for the design). It's similar to yours but with the teslas covering the core.

http://i39.tinypic.com/23shmck.jpg

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jazzathegreat

Spwhich junctions are u talking about changing?Sorry im not the best designer and am only just learning these finer points

---

http://i39.tinypic.com/11s154l.jpg

Heres the junctions I'm talking about. You can easily extend the wall around that cannon/elixer storage out 2 spaces and make a nice t junction instead of the x. Hopefully that makes sense

Ok so ive changed the T Junction in that area and it looks better now i think,its by no means finished ill test it over the next week and see how it goes,hopefully I'll learn how to tweak it better and get it right...thanks for ur help guys i really do appreciate it http://i.imgur.com/L7Hfeeg.png