Clan Donation Exp to Clan Exp

Hi. Im new here in forum. I created this acct in forum to suggest a very helpful topic that should be imply ASAP in COC. Most of the new clans dont have a strong donator for example. Th10 needs a siege machine but because of the low level clan, who is willing to stay in a clan level like 3 or 4. So i think about instead of player exp why not the clan donation exp goes to clan? So it will help neither low level clan or low TH players to help each other even they are not too strong.

What do you think?...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rhn4023

Hi. Im new here in forum. I created this acct in forum to suggest a very helpful topic that should be imply ASAP in COC. Most of the new clans dont have a strong donator for example. Th10 needs a siege machine but because of the low level clan, who is willing to stay in a clan level like 3 or 4. So i think about instead of player exp why not the clan donation exp goes to clan? So it will help neither low level clan or low TH players to help each other even they are not too strong.

What do you think?...

---

It needs to be imply ASAP.

There is clan XP, and individual XP. Clan XP stays with the clan even if individual leaves; individual XP stays with the individual even if they leave the clan. Donations, in my own view, is strictly an individual achievement.

A clan of low level players can work together to heighten the clan XP: fully participate in Clan Games, hold wars regularly. The only hurdle is that they need to find 14 or so willing members. Now one can indeed counter "But with less than 15, how do we even attrack players to get there?". The answer is that clans, are by fact, cooperative efforts. No, the game should not guarantee survival of all clans, have the game prolifferated by clans of only 2 or 5.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by rowman

There is clan XP, and individual XP. Clan XP stays with the clan even if individual leaves; individual XP stays with the individual even if they leave the clan. Donations, in my own view, is strictly an individual achievement.

---

Individual achivement as you says the benefit goes only for individual. How about double benefit? Clan and individual? Or I must say that SC is supporting only the strong accts? How may the new one enjoy the game if just only they begin playing it was so hard. What Im pointing out is to help the new ones by the strong ones by the fast leveling clan system so the donations have a level up when they received troops.

Occasionally there are bonus xp clan points events that can help newer clans.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rhn4023

Individual achivement as you says the benefit goes only for individual. How about double benefit? Clan and individual? Or I must say that SC is supporting only the strong accts? How may the new one enjoy the game if just only they begin playing it was so hard. What Im pointing out is to help the new ones by the strong ones by the fast leveling clan system so the donations have a level up when they received troops.

---

SC doesnt just support higher level clans, it supports them all equally, we all have the same opportunities to level up. I have to reiterate that not all clans survive, nor should they, it is part of the clash of clans circle of life, only the strong, persistent and well run that survive.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rhn4023

Individual achivement as you says the benefit goes only for individual. How about double benefit? Clan and individual? Or I must say that SC is supporting only the strong accts? How may the new one enjoy the game if just only they begin playing it was so hard. What Im pointing out is to help the new ones by the strong ones by the fast leveling clan system so the donations have a level up when they received troops.

---

I start a Req and Leave clan, myself as the only permanent member. Players drop in all day, I donate, they leave. My clan reaches Level 10 eventually while there was never, not once, any cooperative team based undertaking.

Clan XP = Team XP. One account alone cannot reach the Clan Game rewards tiers (beyond 1st) for Clan XP. One account alone cannot War.

So hard??? SC only supporting strong accts??? Sorry you lost me when you started making blatantly untrue statements like that. The game has never been easier to progress than it is now. Not that it is bad thing, but to say otherwise is simply untrue.

There are plenty of ways for new players to gain high troops, but if you want the experience of growing a clan from scratch then in my opinion you should experience growing a clan from scratch. It's not easy work and nor should it be. Part of that work is working together to level up the clan through wars and now clan games. Donations are way too easily manipulated and should definitely not be included in leveling up a clan.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tosti111

SC doesnt just support higher level clans, it supports them all equally, we all have the same opportunities to level up. I have to reiterate that not all clans survive, nor should they, it is part of the clash of clans circle of life, only the strong, persistent and well run that survive.

---

So you will enjoy the game if you are strong? In my clan we help to raise each other and not competing who is the strongest. Im a clan leader even if have a few members they are still staying at my clan beacuse of that thought. What I think that wrong was; what is the use of player exp?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rhn4023

what is the use of player exp?

---

Other than unlocking the Pekka statue in the shop, there is no real value of xp. It's mostly just for show.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SumoSloth

So hard??? SC only supporting strong accts??? Sorry you lost me when you started making blatantly untrue statements like that. The game has never been easier to progress than it is now. Not that it is bad thing, but to say otherwise is simply untrue.

There are plenty of ways for new players to gain high troops, but if you want the experience of growing a clan from scratch then in my opinion you should experience growing a clan from scratch. It's not easy work and nor should it be. Part of that work is working together to level up the clan through wars and now clan games. Donations are way too easily manipulated and should definitely not be included in leveling up a clan.

---

Sorry for that term bro.

Its easy to say that because your not experiencing it. Most of the strong ones choose a high level clans because of the benefits or we called "clan perks". What about a TH10 siege machine if you dont have a TH12 member?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by IceBird1

Other than unlocking the Pekka statue in the shop, there is no real value of xp. It's mostly just for show.

---

So why the donations exp goes to player if it only just for the show? 😂😂😂 So what do you think if the donation exp goes to clan? It was not a bad idea do you think?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by rowman

I start a Req and Leave clan, myself as the only permanent member. Players drop in all day, I donate, they leave. My clan reaches Level 10 eventually while there was never, not once, any cooperative team based undertaking.

Clan XP = Team XP. One account alone cannot reach the Clan Game rewards tiers (beyond 1st) for Clan XP. One account alone cannot War.

---

How did you do that even if your clan was a req and leave?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rhn4023

Sorry for that term bro.

Its easy to say that because your not experiencing it. Most of the strong ones choose a high level clans because of the benefits or we called "clan perks". What about a TH10 siege machine if you dont have a TH12 member?

---

Recruit a th12 or rush an account to th12 just to donate.

Many players here, myself included, were playing when there were no clan perks. We all had to work equally hard to level out clans up. Anyone who played before perks has definitely experienced it. Clan experience is earned through things the clan does together. That’s how it should be.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rhn4023

How did you do that even if your clan was a req and leave?

---

He is saying that, if your idea were implemented, that this is what he would do. He would start a clan by himself and level it up, by himself, by using only player xp. It was meant as an example to show you how easily it could be abused.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bigdome757

He is saying that, if your idea were implemented, that this is what he would do. He would start a clan by himself and level it up, by himself, by using only player xp. It was meant as an example to show you how easily it could be abused.

---

Ohhh I see, but if you voluntarily make a clan thats for only req and leave. What im pointing out there was no use for player exp. Clan exp was the most important here in COC.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bigdome757

Recruit a th12 or rush an account to th12 just to donate.

Many players here, myself included, were playing when there were no clan perks. We all had to work equally hard to level out clans up. Anyone who played before perks has definitely experienced it. Clan experience is earned through things the clan does together. That’s how it should be.

---

Easy to say but hard to do if your focusing only on one acct.

Starting a new clan isn't for kids, at least not for kids looking for hand outs and entitlements instead of putting in the extraordinary effort it takes to build a successful clan. Thousands of people have done it before now, and thousands more will do it again. It isn't suppose to be the easiest thing in the World to do, which is why many choose to join a successful clan instead of making a new one.