Star count to second attacker

One suggestion I would like to give - so far in clan wars, if a player gets 2 stars on a base and another guy brought the third star , you are awarding only 1 star extra to count for the second player in his achievements . opinion is to award all the 3 stars to the second player , making first player stars uncountable , then most people try for 3 stars rather than going to higher bases for loot with just 50 percent with townhall down

The true warrior who got the best attack on that opponent (100% or max destruction) making his clan proud doesn't get any stars countable under his name . If you can do this ! True star holders and we can tell how strong he is by looking at the stars.
Right now , he is a unsung hero? 🤔🤔 Like many of us . Game's biggest interest is clan war and the true heroes were not treated well . Please do this happen

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Electroname

One suggestion I would like to give - so far in clan wars, if a player gets 2 stars on a base and another guy brought the third star , you are awarding only 1 star extra to count for the second player in his achievements . opinion is to award all the 3 stars to the second player , making first player stars uncountable , then most people try for 3 stars rather than going to higher bases for loot with just 50 percent with townhall down

The true warrior who got the best attack on that opponent (100% or max destruction) making his clan proud doesn't get any stars countable under his name . If you can do this ! True star holders and we can tell how strong he is by looking at the stars.
Right now , he is a unsung hero? 樂樂 Like many of us . Game's biggest interest is clan war and the true heroes were not treated well . Please do this happen

---

This is incorrect. It already is how you would like it to be. If someone gets the third star after someone else had either one or two starred all three stars get counted toward the second player in achievements.

Wow .. You want to take away stars from someone who earned it (ya know , like a TH10 vs a TH10) who gets 2 stars but a max 11 comes along and wipes out that 10 .. and you want that first attacker to lose his stars??? You might as well just say "lets kill clans and any clan chemistry here's how we do it".

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Electroname

One suggestion I would like to give - so far in clan wars, if a player gets 2 stars on a base and another guy brought the third star , you are awarding only 1 star extra to count for the second player in his achievements . opinion is to award all the 3 stars to the second player , making first player stars uncountable , then most people try for 3 stars rather than going to higher bases for loot with just 50 percent with townhall down

The true warrior who got the best attack on that opponent (100% or max destruction) making his clan proud doesn't get any stars countable under his name . If you can do this ! True star holders and we can tell how strong he is by looking at the stars.
Right now , he is a unsung hero? ���� Like many of us . Game's biggest interest is clan war and the true heroes were not treated well . Please do this happen

---

Respectably disagree. The true "unsung hero" is the person attacking a base higher than themselves, one which they have little or no chance, that action captured eloquently in The Charge of the Light Brigrade. Anyone can easily bottom feed, go for a lower TH just for the stars. In my own clan, during CWL, our #15, a TH 9, wanted to try the #1 base, a max TH 12. We said sure, why not (the war was already decided at that point). He then 1 starred that base, an heroic effort indeed!

In my own view, a TH9 gaining 1 star on a 12 is heroic, while a 12 getting three stars on a T H 9 is not. Your logic promotes bottom feeding, not heroics.

A th9 clearing a th12 doesn't win the war , just gives a OMG expression . I have seen many 2 starred th9s
in oppopents list and still rest of the th9s (in our clan) trying for th10s to star something . ( Because they are counting stars under their own name than the for the clan) It's not the way to max the stars in my opinion . Moreover no th12s usually goes on th9 just for already 3 starred base by another th9. If you follow a winning clan , you can understand the logic better . In my version , cleaning of the bottom bases will be done with a better discipline

Attacking a base on 2nd hit is much easier than fresh hit. You would be creating a problem, no one would want to be the first hitter if someone else would use them as scout to get the stars

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MystClash

Attacking a base on 2nd hit is much easier than fresh hit. You would be creating a problem, no one would want to be the first hitter if someone else would use them as scout to get the stars

---

First point - When you are sure of 3 starring before the attack starts , why the need of scouting .
Second point - true clan war lovers don't fear to use their attack as a scout (when circumstances are urging them) to help the clanmates
Third point - only these x mod players do such scouting things , so we can get rid of them too (if they do as per words )

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Electroname

First point - When you are sure of 3 starring before the attack starts , why the need of scouting .
Second point - true clan war lovers don't fear to use their attack as a scout (when circumstances are urging them) to help the clanmates
Third point - only these x mod players do such scouting things , so we can get rid of them too (if they do as per words )

---

All your points are false except the second, which does not bring much to the discussion.

Lets say I attack the first base, 95% 2 stars. Now someone who know where all the traps are, use loons to activate air mines, ignore that lava hound and baloon on the clan castle because they chose a laloon, gets 100%.

Me, who got an almost perfect attack on the oponent full th12, lose 2 stars

Try seeing yourself in that situation

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MystClash

All your points are false except the second, which does not bring much to the discussion.

Lets say I attack the first base, 95% 2 stars. Now someone who know where all the traps are, use loons to activate air mines, ignore that lava hound and baloon on the clan castle because they chose a laloon, gets 100%.

Me, who got an almost perfect attack on the oponent full th12, lose 2 stars

Try seeing yourself in that situation

---

Such trap based attacks are done only by x mod players or who copied their bases from internet .
Coming to your point, I'm happy to give away my stars to the second player because I can agree ( that's where team spirit comes from) he outplayed me . There is nothing wrong to agree when someone played smarter 🤔
We seldom do 98% destructive attacks but point is who did the best to the clan .
Second point is - the ones who attack truly doesn't mind giving away his stars to a better attacker , only the ones who does 50% destruction with th down, fear for taking away their stars .
Btw, thanks for noting all my points

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Electroname

Such trap based attacks are done only by x mod players or who copied their bases from internet .
Coming to your point, I'm happy to give away my stars to the second player because I can agree ( that's where team spirit comes from) he outplayed me . There is nothing wrong to agree when someone played smarter 🤔
We seldom do 98% destructive attacks but point is who did the best to the clan .
Second point is - the ones who attack truly doesn't mind giving away his stars to a better attacker , only the ones who does 50% destruction with th down, fear for taking away their stars .
Btw, thanks for noting all my points

---

First I want say congratulations and thank you, you are very polite and it is a pleasure discussing something with you, even disagreeing with you completely

You seem to be missing the point that just because someone got a 3 star on a second hit it does not mean that the second attacker was more competent or better than the first, on many second hits the 3 stars were only possible because the first attack revealed a lot of information on the base