Clash of Clans - Announcing Clan War Leagues - October Update!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zaper93

The incentive to play CWL are the rewards. If you discount that from your argument claiming what incentive is there (besides rewards) then your whole point is moot.

There will be rewards for winning your league. There will be rewards if you hold your league.

If you currently come up against a full engineered clan, or a bad mismatch in a war do you stop playing? There is basically no incentive in clan wars outside a few resources if you know you will lose and yet i've never seen a clan just not bother attacking because they know they've lost

---

You have no idea how the rewards are structured, or what the rewards will be, so there is no point arguing about them or even discussing them in the context of the discussion. People complain when one th is different than theirs in regular wars, they complain that engineers have them beat before the war starts. They complain that the war mm is bad and puts them against opponents they can’t beat. From everything I’ve read about the clan war leagues this is going to do way more of that with potentially much higher stakes. You think that people are going to just accept that and be happy with it?

As as for the stop playing in wars because you are beat aspect, have I ever done that? Not a chance, have I seen it happen? Many times, as a matter of fact there are at least 5 wars on my warlog where the clan we were facing gave up when they knew they couldn’t win, 1 war where they didn’t attack at all, I’ve been in clans where some of the members wanted to give up and some individuals did. So does that happen? Of course it does, you’re being naive if you think otherwise. That being said, those are not the people I’m concerned about, the ones who do slog away, but see no success because they are doomed before they begin are ones who will become the most frustrated.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SumoSloth

You have no idea how the rewards are structured, or what the rewards will be, so there is no point arguing about them or even discussing them in the context of the discussion. [...]

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TullSadum

My final word for today:
Rewards !
What are they, who gets them...
Before we know more about this any further speculation is futile.
Good Night, see you all tomorrow.

Have Fun
TS

---

well, sumo, it seems you are finally getting to the point I made 14 hrs ago.
I‘m glad you’re starting to see the light. :thumbsup:

Have Fun
TS

My clan is constantly 40 KV 40 in the Tournament will only be used 15. The rest will not fight for 8 days. This is a bad thing. Make both the KV and the Tournament.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Darian[Supercell]

For example, if you sign up 30 Clanmates to the League FOR THE VERY FIRST TIME YOU'RE ENTERING THE LEAGUE. Putting 15 TH7's in your starting lineup won't put you in a bottom tier League if you have a bunch of TH12's on the sidelines. Those TH12's will be what counts for your INITIAL placement with 7 other Clans.

---

Hi Darian. (forgive me for my english, I'm french)

To avoid those funny people already trying to cheat the system by selecting the "best" initial rooster (and at the same time protesting against the engineering people, those people who cheat but not the way I cheat, because in my mind, I can cheat but other ones shouldn't), why don't you simply for the first round randomly create pools of 8 clans, then create final 18 leagues according to stars earned at the end of the week ?

By the way, can you give use more information about the league rewards please ?
To know how valuable is the effort beeing in top league.
And to know if "war participating players" will have a reward of playing the game vs "war non-participating players"

It's already a source of tension within clan during the clan games, when some players do the job (completing as much events as they can), and some players just complete an event and benefit of the implication of regular players.

I'm so much excited for that update. Just tell me when is it coming ? After CG or before CG ?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SumoSloth

You have no idea how the rewards are structured, or what the rewards will be, so there is no point arguing about them or even discussing them in the context of the discussion. People complain when one th is different than theirs in regular wars, they complain that engineers have them beat before the war starts. They complain that the war mm is bad and puts them against opponents they can’t beat. From everything I’ve read about the clan war leagues this is going to do way more of that with potentially much higher stakes. You think that people are going to just accept that and be happy with it?

As as for the stop playing in wars because you are beat aspect, have I ever done that? Not a chance, have I seen it happen? Many times, as a matter of fact there are at least 5 wars on my warlog where the clan we were facing gave up when they knew they couldn’t win, 1 war where they didn’t attack at all, I’ve been in clans where some of the members wanted to give up and some individuals did. So does that happen? Of course it does, you’re being naive if you think otherwise. That being said, those are not the people I’m concerned about, the ones who do slog away, but see no success because they are doomed before they begin are ones who will become the most frustrated.

---

Again you're vastly off on your definition of 'success'.

You are stuck in the clan war mindset where winning is success and losing is failure. This is absolutely not the case. In a week there are 315 stars across 7 wars to fight for.

What are the odds that each and every war is stacked against you? Each tier will have thousands of clans with many BD's. You will get some easier matchups, some harder matchups and some even ones.

And thats OKAY. Say you finish 4th in tier 6 for a month. You collect your rewards go back to regular warring. By next month your clan as a whole would have stronger bases. Maybe even a few th upgrades here and there. So you go at it again on tier 6 with a stronger lineup this time around.

Chances that a clan will be doomed before they begin will be very low considering you dont fight the same opponent over and over but rather fight many different ones.

At the risk of beating my head against a wall, I will leave tonight with this.

My biggest concerns are the perceptions of mismatches within the tiers, which shouldn’t be that bad in season one, but are inevitable moving beyond that in the way the tiering is structured based on the info that we have so far. This can and likely will have a seriously negative effect on the overall gameplay for a majority of players if not addressed.

The second concern is the is the constant flow of misinformation from people who do not have any official status or information, but comment on others as though they do. People are entitled to their opinions, but for the sake of all the readers who are coming into this thread late, please stop making stuff up as though it was factual.

The last concern is how this is going to affect clans going forward. Forcing clans to choose their top 15 players can and will be problematic for many clans on both sides of the spectrum, whereby some don’t have enough quality players and some have too many. The rotating in idea sounds like a bad compromise which is doomed to lead to bad blood within many a clans makeup.

I’m out for tonight, as I’ve already pushed this way past where I should have stayed up for.

As TS said rewards are irrelevant until we know the details of them, but that doesn’t make the rest of the conversation any less valid.

If in 1 clan having all th9 players in clan war leagues then other 7 clan also all th9 players in clan war leagues?????
Please give me correct answer i am confused 😫

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ashok80590

If in 1 clan having all th9 players in clan war leagues then other 7 clan also all th9 players in clan war leagues?????
Please give me correct answer i am confused 😫

---

the very first cwl you sign in the matchmaking is based on your strongest signed in th levels.
i dont know if all other matchings in the ongoing cwl weeks are based on that or if they are completely random so that missmatch happense.

Q1. Can we take engineer or rushed base in clan war league ?