Clans Sizes are too large. 25 man Clans would spread the wealth of the more active players and promote a more competitive community. I disagree. I'd like it if clan sizes were 60 so that we could have a few guys out of war with upgrades and still run 50 man wars.
Clan Perks should be based on what tier of Clan Games a clan completes the previous games. Having the bonuses locked to only old and established clans goes against promoting new clans. As it is now you feel gimped if you are not in a level 10 and above clan. A clan who spent two years getting to level ten should have their perks taken away if they don't get max clan games? It is starting to seem like you just want to start your own clan but nobody is joining you...
In game officer chat. Many things should be said among the clan leaders that sensitive ears should hear. As it now members who are less skilled get blasted in open chat. I'm not opposed to this. My clans use Discord and Line but it would be nice for discussing someone who just requested to join. Then if we accept the recruit wouldn't be able to read what we were saying about him (particularly proposed reasons why he shouldn't join)
Arena Teams. You Q up with a 3 man team. These battles only last 30 minutes. The three man team has a team base they all have been working on to upgrade which is done by items they receive in arena battles. It’s a much larger base then their personal base. Each player has 1 attack on the enemy base and they hope to 100% the base with their combined attacks. I believe this is ruled out. Go play Boom Beach if you want something like that.
Speed up the upgrade times for TH1-TH9. The curve to be competitive in this game is way too steep in 2018 for new players. I know they have in the past but they need to do it again for lower TH’s. They have already done this...by a lot. Just reduced hero upgrade times and the time required for most things in the lab and buildings by up to 50% if I recall correctly. Every town hall level 1-11 was affected.
Fix ClaN wars .. Give it purpose. A leaderboard that resets every 6 months would be great. Still keep your total wins but give it purpose. The amounts of CW points earned each war is based on your war weight for that war. The purpose is to have fun. War win streaks are the indicator of what clans are doing the best. You can see a list of what clans have the highest streaks at cocp.it
We only need 1 gold mine and 1 Elixire/DE Collector, 1 Farm, 1 Barracks and so on. The extra buildings are actually needed to fill out space on the village. Trash buildings are about 60% of the base so removing them, like you suggest, would make it much easier to three star since troops wouldn't have as many buildings to destroy.
Clan Leagues??? Bo idea what you will do with them but I suspect it will be lacking in competitive play. I assume you mean Clan War Leagues...Criticizing something that isn't even out yet...nice. I for one am excited to see what they're about. I bet they'll be something similar to your clan war leader board actually.