Clan games

It is very frustrating when people do the minimum in games to get rewards. I think there should be a minimum score of 1000 to get rewards and if you max out you get a bonus.

Hi and welcome to the forums.

Please take a moment to look at the stickies (this one in particular with the ruled-out ideas list), as setting a point minimum is ruled-out. If you're having issues with people not earning enough points, have you or your leadership set up a rule where your clanmates must earn x points or get the boot. I'd also recruit players who will earn points towards clan games (if their CG Champion has over 10k points, that's usually a good indicator).

Quote:

---

Currently Ruled Out:
Here are some amazing ideas that have been ruled out by the dev time for the time being. Posting these ideas will result in your thread being removed without notice!

---

Quote:

---

Clan Related:
*Add other clan requirements to apply besides trophies, ex: Specific troop lvl, TH lvl, lab lvl, game lvl
*Customizable clan flag
*Add ability to send short message to rejected applicants similar to when expelling
*A large text area for clan rules that just the clan can see (separate from public clan description)
*Leader (and co-leaders) ability to delete messages in chat
*Modify clan msg of player joining with who invited player: xx joined clan, invited by xx
*Add clan rank to Clan Info Screen – Quicker to reference than scrolling to end of top 200 list
*Increase clan size: 75 or 100 are most common requests
* Separate Elder+ chat tab in-game
*Ability to set points threshold required in order to gain rewards from clan games or to vary the tier received according to individual contribution

---

Disappointed with this. Think this would be a great addition to the game and help motivate clan members to participate and help out in clan games.

I don’t understand. Why don’t you want your clan mates to be able to get all of the rewards? Why don’t you want them to be able to progress their base easier with magic items?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Surferflick

Disappointed with this. Think this would be a great addition to the game and help motivate clan members to participate and help out in clan games.

---

Rather than changing the gameplay kick those out of the clan who do not take part in the CG or those who complete one task and take full rewards,,make clan rules to collect atleast 50% of the max individual points..

I’m TRIGGER, the leader of my clan called New Order. I personally am frustrated as well with the loop hole members have found with games. It’s hard enough to recruit members but what we’re seeing more and more of is people looking for clans during game time that are either maxed in points or going to be. So what they do is, select a challenge of 50 points or whatever the easiest one is. Complete it and sit back knowing they’re going to get full rewards whether they stay, leave or get kicked.

We had two almost maxed TH11’s join our clan. One completed 300 points and the other 150. They left the clan shortly after that.

It’s discouraging for the clan because as we all know it takes a lot of time, especially for members in Titan and legend. I’m in legend and it takes me an average of 45 minutes for a base to show up. So when you have freeloaders do that to your clan it’s just not right.

I believe rules should be set, such as;

If you VOLUNTARILY leave the clan with under 50% of the max game points you get nothing.

If you get kicked but got at least 1 or 2k points, you get full rewards.

If a member is clan hoping, disable the ability to take part in games until the new one starts.

There has to be a penalty put in place for members abusing the game. Simply joining a clan and getting 50’points then leaving and still getting full rewards is unfair and absolutely a flaw in the game.

The game seems to encourage flaws in the games, such as when engineered bases were basically causing clans to fold and leave the game. It took forever for supercell to finally correct it. Games will eventually do the same if it’s not corrected. There needs to be a balance, but a fair one that will please the overall clan and each individual playing for games.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Mysupratoy94

I’m TRIGGER, the leader of my clan called New Order. I personally am frustrated as well with the loop hole members have found with games. It’s hard enough to recruit members but what we’re seeing more and more of is people looking for clans during game time that are either maxed in points or going to be. So what they do is, select a challenge of 50 points or whatever the easiest one is. Complete it and sit back knowing they’re going to get full rewards whether they stay, leave or get kicked.

We had two almost maxed TH11’s join our clan. One completed 300 points and the other 150. They left the clan shortly after that.

It’s discouraging for the clan because as we all know it takes a lot of time, especially for members in Titan and legend. I’m in legend and it takes me an average of 45 minutes for a base to show up. So when you have freeloaders do that to your clan it’s just not right.

I believe rules should be set, such as;

If you VOLUNTARILY leave the clan with under 50% of the max game points you get nothing.

If you get kicked but got at least 1 or 2k points, you get full rewards.

If a member is clan hoping, disable the ability to take part in games until the new one starts.

There has to be a penalty put in place for members abusing the game. Simply joining a clan and getting 50’points then leaving and still getting full rewards is unfair and absolutely a flaw in the game.

The game seems to encourage flaws in the games, such as when engineered bases were basically causing clans to fold and leave the game. It took forever for supercell to finally correct it. Games will eventually do the same if it’s not corrected. There needs to be a balance, but a fair one that will please the overall clan and each individual playing for games.

---

Fortunately, SC does not agree with you. I’ll never understand why a clan leader wouldn’t want EVERY member of their clan to receive rewards. I don’t know about you, but I want my clan to succeed and grow as fast as possible. That includes everyone in my clan, even those that only do one challenge for whatever reason. Then I wonder, why would a clan leader allow a freeloader to stay in the clan? SC has given you the tools to deal with those people. Kick them.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Mysupratoy94

I’m TRIGGER, the leader of my clan called New Order. I personally am frustrated as well with the loop hole members have found with games. It’s hard enough to recruit members but what we’re seeing more and more of is people looking for clans during game time that are either maxed in points or going to be. So what they do is, select a challenge of 50 points or whatever the easiest one is. Complete it and sit back knowing they’re going to get full rewards whether they stay, leave or get kicked.

We had two almost maxed TH11’s join our clan. One completed 300 points and the other 150. They left the clan shortly after that.

It’s discouraging for the clan because as we all know it takes a lot of time, especially for members in Titan and legend. I’m in legend and it takes me an average of 45 minutes for a base to show up. So when you have freeloaders do that to your clan it’s just not right.

I believe rules should be set, such as;

If you VOLUNTARILY leave the clan with under 50% of the max game points you get nothing.

If you get kicked but got at least 1 or 2k points, you get full rewards.

If a member is clan hoping, disable the ability to take part in games until the new one starts.

There has to be a penalty put in place for members abusing the game. Simply joining a clan and getting 50’points then leaving and still getting full rewards is unfair and absolutely a flaw in the game.

The game seems to encourage flaws in the games, such as when engineered bases were basically causing clans to fold and leave the game. It took forever for supercell to finally correct it. Games will eventually do the same if it’s not corrected. There needs to be a balance, but a fair one that will please the overall clan and each individual playing for games.

---

Or you could prevent clan games hoppers from joining in the first place.

To be fair, those points that those people do help progress your clan further to the max tier. Yeah, I know, 50 points, that's a small amount. If you don't want people doing that, then simply don't let them in. As I said in my above post, before accepting people, I always check their achievements, specifically the CG Champion one. If they have a very little amount earned towards it, then those are the people you won't want to recruit, since they'll most likely just earn the bare minimum for rewards.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Mysupratoy94

I’m TRIGGER, the leader of my clan called New Order. I personally am frustrated as well with the loop hole members have found with games. It’s hard enough to recruit members but what we’re seeing more and more of is people looking for clans during game time that are either maxed in points or going to be. So what they do is, select a challenge of 50 points or whatever the easiest one is. Complete it and sit back knowing they’re going to get full rewards whether they stay, leave or get kicked.

We had two almost maxed TH11’s join our clan. One completed 300 points and the other 150. They left the clan shortly after that.

It’s discouraging for the clan because as we all know it takes a lot of time, especially for members in Titan and legend. I’m in legend and it takes me an average of 45 minutes for a base to show up. So when you have freeloaders do that to your clan it’s just not right.

I believe rules should be set, such as;

If you VOLUNTARILY leave the clan with under 50% of the max game points you get nothing.

If you get kicked but got at least 1 or 2k points, you get full rewards.

If a member is clan hoping, disable the ability to take part in games until the new one starts.

There has to be a penalty put in place for members abusing the game. Simply joining a clan and getting 50’points then leaving and still getting full rewards is unfair and absolutely a flaw in the game.

The game seems to encourage flaws in the games, such as when engineered bases were basically causing clans to fold and leave the game. It took forever for supercell to finally correct it. Games will eventually do the same if it’s not corrected. There needs to be a balance, but a fair one that will please the overall clan and each individual playing for games.

---

How exactly are those freeloaders causing a problem in your clan? Are they preventing you from receiving your rewards? Those two TH11s actually contributed points toward your games - how is that a problem?

If you don't like freeloaders during clan games, close your clan. Problem solved.

This has been discussed to death on these forums, so much that they added this topic to the RULED OUT list. Supercell has stated they have absolutely no plans to change this. It's not worth discussing any further. I'll report this thread to be closed.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Mysupratoy94

I’m TRIGGER, the leader of my clan called New Order. I personally am frustrated as well with the loop hole members have found with games. It’s hard enough to recruit members but what we’re seeing more and more of is people looking for clans during game time that are either maxed in points or going to be. So what they do is, select a challenge of 50 points or whatever the easiest one is. Complete it and sit back knowing they’re going to get full rewards whether they stay, leave or get kicked.

We had two almost maxed TH11’s join our clan. One completed 300 points and the other 150. They left the clan shortly after that.

It’s discouraging for the clan because as we all know it takes a lot of time, especially for members in Titan and legend. I’m in legend and it takes me an average of 45 minutes for a base to show up. So when you have freeloaders do that to your clan it’s just not right.

I believe rules should be set, such as;

If you VOLUNTARILY leave the clan with under 50% of the max game points you get nothing.

If you get kicked but got at least 1 or 2k points, you get full rewards.

If a member is clan hoping, disable the ability to take part in games until the new one starts.

There has to be a penalty put in place for members abusing the game. Simply joining a clan and getting 50’points then leaving and still getting full rewards is unfair and absolutely a flaw in the game.

The game seems to encourage flaws in the games, such as when engineered bases were basically causing clans to fold and leave the game. It took forever for supercell to finally correct it. Games will eventually do the same if it’s not corrected. There needs to be a balance, but a fair one that will please the overall clan and each individual playing for games.

---

Instead of going on that long rant, which I didn't even make it past the first paragraph, you could've read the first reply to this thread to see that supercell has already ruled out this idea. It will not be happening.