Please bring back completely losing shield on attack

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Marchizmoh

Lol what? You attack other players bases and defend other plaers attacks that's the definition of pvp

---

No it isn't.

PvP is when two people each attack the other, either simultaneously, or in turn.

PvP is absolutely NOT when you attack one person, and somebody else atracks you.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Marchizmoh

Why is everyone here obsessed with attacking 10+ times a day? I don't have nearly as much time to be playing this game that frequently. I just want a chance to actually progress without getting my butt handed to me by an attacker 1 or 2 townhall levels higher than me with defenses that are way too low for their townhall level. I think actually being able to revenge and get your loot back without someone attacking them first resulting in them being shielded before i can even get my loot back would fix it

---

Some days I might attack 30+times and some days I don’t feel like playing. But what I can tell you is that the game should NOT be tailored to fit the needs of inactive players. That is just a ridiculously short sighted sentiment...

You need active players spending time with the app and hopefully spending money as well to keep the game going. You don’t play much and you won’t progress fast. Seems simple and it seems like it’s the way it should be

It doesn’t matter what level defenses the player that attacks you has. That has no bearing on multiplayer matching. Why are you so fixated on something that couldn’t be more irrelevant?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Marchizmoh

Alright since you all obviously hate my idea. Could we at least agree that being attacked by a player with a higher level townhall sucks and that only being able to be attacked and attack players with the same level townhall would be better?

---

It wouldn’t be better. Think how hard it would be to start a new townhall level?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Marchizmoh

If you'd actually upgrade your defenses you'd be able to defend against the revenges giving you a higher trophy count and putting you in a division/league you deserve resulting in you getting kicked back down to a lower one because your defenses are bad or boosted up even more because they're good. And when you finally do get 3 starred because you're in too high a divsion the shield gives you time to upgrade buildings and defenses so you can stand a chance at that divsion

---

You might, if you have really good defences, win one in 10.

The game is very biased towards offence, and even very good bases rarely survive for zero stars. The "unbreakable" achievement is by far the hardest one to get.

Op just for your in multi-player is based off of cups. The game matches you up (for the most part) with th + or - 1 of your town hall within around +or-200 cups.

Also there is a loot penalty for attacking a th lower
-1 = 20% penalty
-2 = 50% penalty
-3 = 75% penalty
And so on. So I'm not sure sure where your problem lies it's a fair system that millions of people play and had no problems with

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Marchizmoh

Why is everyone here obsessed with attacking 10+ times a day?

---

People on the forums tend to be those most enthusiastic about the game. Which means the average level of activity among forumers is going to be way higher than among the whole playing population.

Quote:

---

I don't have nearly as much time to be playing this game that frequently. I just want a chance to actually progress without getting my butt handed to me by an attacker 1 or 2 townhall levels higher than me with defenses that are way too low for their townhall level. I think actually being able to revenge and get your loot back without someone attacking them first resulting in them being shielded before i can even get my loot back would fix it

---

The game will always reward those who are more active. But even somebody who can only attack 3-4 times per day should still be able to make reasonable progress.

Though they wouldn't if your ideas were implemented. To make reasonable progress you must attack more than you defend. Your idea would stop that happening.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Marchizmoh

Alright since you all obviously hate my idea. Could we at least agree that being attacked by a player with a higher level townhall sucks and that only being able to be attacked and attack players with the same level townhall would be better?

---

I would be surprised if any of those posting agree with that, never mind all.

It would mean people who had just gone up a level would find hardly anything they could hit, while getting stomped all the time. It would make most peolle pretty reluctant to go up to the next Town Hall, which would be very bad for the game. And this effect is worse for those at low levels, particularly inexperienced players.

People who are going tgrough the low levels with 2nd, 3rd or more accounts don't have it nearly as hard.But this would really discourage fresh players.

First person? You must be new to the game. Either fix the revenge feature or take it away. It’s frustrating.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by downinahole

First person? You must be new to the game. Either fix the revenge feature or take it away. It’s frustrating.

---

There's nothing to fix revenge works as intended. Why do some people insist that just cause they are to high to revenge then no one should have the opportunity to use it?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by downinahole

First person? You must be new to the game. Either fix the revenge feature or take it away. It’s frustrating.

---

It's the new people who are concerned about it.

Most who have been playing for some time just ignore it. There are a few who think that just because people on higher leagues can't use it, then it should be taken way, but that isn't fair on those who can use it.

I'm not aware of anythingabout revenge not working as intended, so there is nothing to "fix".