Please bring back completely losing shield on attack

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Monoxide

I don’t understand why the OP is so hung up on “divisions” which I’m assuming he means league. Trophies don’t mean much when it comes to whom you are matched up it’s a + or - 2 th levels. Most usually the same level th or 1 below.

I also don’t understand who would want everyone they attacked to have a free pass to revenge? How would you save up any loot? To be honest I think that would make players hit lower th more often to avoid a chance of a decent revenge.

Bad idea and bad for the game

---

Why is everyone here obsessed with attacking 10+ times a day? I don't have nearly as much time to be playing this game that frequently. I just want a chance to actually progress without getting my butt handed to me by an attacker 1 or 2 townhall levels higher than me with defenses that are way too low for their townhall level. I think actually being able to revenge and get your loot back without someone attacking them first resulting in them being shielded before i can even get my loot back would fix it

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Marchizmoh

Why is everyone here obsessed with attacking 10+ times a day? I don't have nearly as much time to be playing this game that frequently. I just want a chance to actually progress without getting my butt handed to me by an attacker 1 or 2 townhall levels higher than me with defenses that are way too low for their townhall level. I think actually being able to revenge and get your loot back without someone attacking them first resulting in them being shielded before i can even get my loot back would fix it

---

Freaking NO!
If everyone keeps revenging me "even during shield" how will I save resource for upgrade.


This is a game bro, many players have been attacked tons of times by 2 Th above them.
I have been attacked by T 11 ans 12.
I have attacked Th 9 players.

This is a part of game.
Why are you so fixated on who should attack me or not?


Edit:
Free advice for you - Drop your trophies to Crystal league... you will enjoy your stay there

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by masteryasin

OP, why are you so fixated on your idea?

Simple thing is:
I am TH 10 player

It takes 7M gold to upgrade many of the defenses to max level.
It takes around 6 to 8M Elixir to upgrade troops
It takes lot of dark 100K plus (increases by 4 to 3 K every level) for Heroes


How am I supposed to farm resources if everyone keeps revenging me?


I don't understand your exact point of starting this thread.

This idea will RUIN the Game.

---

Because that's how i remember clash being. You upgraded your defenses and army defending against people so you could get more trophies so you could attack people with more resources. It seems to me now it's more "attack as many people as you can in a row racking up resources and trophies until someone 3 stars you giving you a shield so you can upgrade your townhall and army

Alright since you all obviously hate my idea. Could we at least agree that being attacked by a player with a higher level townhall sucks and that only being able to be attacked and attack players with the same level townhall would be better?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Marchizmoh

Why is everyone here obsessed with attacking 10+ times a day? I don't have nearly as much time to be playing this game that frequently. I just want a chance to actually progress without getting my butt handed to me by an attacker 1 or 2 townhall levels higher than me with defenses that are way too low for their townhall level. I think actually being able to revenge and get your loot back without someone attacking them first resulting in them being shielded before i can even get my loot back would fix it

---

You are, more or less, asking for a penalty to be applied to players that are more active than you. In other words, you want SC to tailor the game to your preferred playing style.

It won't happen OP; the more active a player is, the more likely they are to be a source of revenue. SC is a business, not a benevolent foundation.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Marchizmoh

Because that's how i remember clash being. You upgraded your defenses and army defending against people so you could get more trophies so you could attack people with more resources. It seems to me now it's more "attack as many people as you can in a row racking up resources and trophies until someone 3 stars you giving you a shield so you can upgrade your townhall and army

---

Trophies have no relation with resources.

Clash of Clans is made in a way that attacking > defending

3 star rates have slightly increased compared to past years.


There is tons of loot in crystal league. If you want resource, drop trophies instead of pushing.



I am Th 10 player. I can push to some extent.
But then I will face max TH 11 and 12, and Th 10 seriously doesn't have fire-power to destroy a max TH 11 and 12 base

So after a limit- I will not be able to go higher.

This is how game works.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Marchizmoh

Alright since you all obviously hate my idea. Could we at least agree that being attacked by a player with a higher level townhall sucks and that only being able to be attacked and attack players with the same level townhall would be better?

---

No it, absolutely, would not. That would entail separate leagues for each TH level. The result of that would be TH2's, 3's etc... in their own legends leagues. In turn, that would disincentivise some players from upgrading; which is entirely counter to SC's current strategy.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kaledonian

You are, more or less, asking for a penalty to be applied to players that are more active than you. In other words, you want SC to tailor the game to your preferred playing style.

It won't happen OP; the more active a player is, the more likely they are to be a source of revenue. SC is a business, not a benevolent foundation.

---

How is being more active making sc more money than people actually buying guards and resources? I currently don't see a reason to buy resources at all unless you also buy a shield be ause you'll just be attacked unless you spend all of it immediately. so how is attacking making them more money if you're just gonna possibley steal resources that people actually bought?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kaledonian

No it, absolutely, would not. That would entail separate leagues for each TH level. The result of that would be TH2's, 3's etc... in their own legends leagues. In turn, that would disincentivise some players from upgrading; which is entirely counter to SC's current strategy.

---

Why wouldn't attacking being based off of trophies fix that? It seems to me currently that the strategy is "upgrade army not defenses". If your trophy count was based off both with a close to 1:1 ratio of winning defenses and attacks it'd make it an even playing field for extremely active players and players that just don't have that much time

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Marchizmoh

Why wouldn't attacking being based off of trophies fix that? It seems to me currently that the strategy is "upgrade army not defenses". If your trophy count was based off both with a close to 1:1 ratio of winning defenses and attacks it'd make it an even playing field for extremely active players and players that just don't have that much time

---

If this is want you want:
Tough battles

You haven't heard of Clan War Leagues?


CWL is going to heavily punish low level players, engineered accounts...

Just wait for this...
CWL will force you to upgrade even defense of your village, apart from just the offense.