!!!Solution to troops donation!!!

Hi,

Has anyone donated you wrong troops that you did not request for? Does it frustrate you? Well couple of seconds ago it just happened to me so here I am.

My solution is that people that are requesting for cc troops, have the ability to select SPECIFIC troops that people are able to donate. There would be a ! icon for people to press on to see the troops that are picked/chosen from the person who requested. This means that if a user chooses bowlers for their cc, the select the troop bowler in a menu, the only troop that people are able to press on to donate are bowlers.

1)if i request a pekka but i have 30 cc space that remaining 5 space cannot be filled and stay up there forever annoying every clan mate
2)if i click multiple units like pekka, archers, wizards then there is a chance to wrong donate by giving wizards
3)ok so you can click each unit to specify how many wizards, archer and pekka you need so you click 1each and no one can wrong donate now
but what if i need any ground troop then?
what if i need any air troop then?
You add more buttons for air troop, any troop, ground troop and make a simple feature like donation complicated?

wrong donations are a problem i can understand but its better to keep some of the simple game mechanics simple.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Timothyjo666

1)if i request a pekka but i have 30 cc space that remaining 5 space cannot be filled and stay up there forever annoying every clan mate
2)if i click multiple units like pekka, archers, wizards then there is a chance to wrong donate by giving wizards
3)ok so you can click each unit to specify how many wizards, archer and pekka you need so you click 1each and no one can wrong donate now
but what if i need any ground troop then?
what if i need any air troop then?
You add more buttons for air troop, any troop, ground troop and make a simple feature like donation complicated?

wrong donations are a problem i can understand but its better to keep some of the simple game mechanics simple.

---

IMO,maybe select a obligatory troop,and other place for others unita.I dont know,how realize it,but guys in supercell arent stupid and find a way for realizing this idea.

I would really like this to be added to the game

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ryuvong

Hi,

Has anyone donated you wrong troops that you did not request for? Does it frustrate you? Well couple of seconds ago it just happened to me so here I am.

My solution is that people that are requesting for cc troops, have the ability to select SPECIFIC troops that people are able to donate. There would be a ! icon for people to press on to see the troops that are picked/chosen from the person who requested. This means that if a user chooses bowlers for their cc, the select the troop bowler in a menu, the only troop that people are able to press on to donate are bowlers.

---

Easier solution, just let me see who donated what troops, even several hours later. That way I can correct the behaviour, demote them or kick them or rat them out to a leader who can do that.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tosti111

Easier solution, just let me see who donated what troops, even several hours later. That way I can correct the behaviour, demote them or kick them or rat them out to a leader who can do that.

---

Easier solution is Ruled Out solution.
https://forum.supercell.com/showthre...rum-guidelines

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by JohnnyPC

Easier solution is Ruled Out solution.
https://forum.supercell.com/showthre...rum-guidelines

---

I have read that many times before and unless my old eyes decieve me, that is not on the list. You may want to cut and paste what part you read.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tosti111

I have read that many times before and unless my old eyes decieve me, that is not on the list. You may want to cut and paste what part you read.

---

This is what JohnnyPC was referring to.

Quote:

---

Currently Ruled Out:
Here are some amazing ideas that have been ruled out by the dev time for the time being. Posting these ideas will result in your thread being removed without notice!

---

Quote:

---

Troop/Barracks Related:
*Queue troop donation notices when offline – display when back online or new interface to see info after
*Show total training time left above barracks
*Show total elixir costs of troops sitting in army camps
*5x or 10x button in troop training screens for faster queuing
*Modify healers to include healing air troops
*Release a hero for every troop type (Some more may come eventually, but not EVERY troop)
*Prepackaged troop clusters = similar to clan castle deployment, but you can load like 50 troop count in 4 different clusters to deploy on offense all at once.
*Have clan war troop donations count towards donation statistics

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DARDANIUS

This is what JohnnyPC was referring to.

---

My mistake then, I read that as showing the requests for donations so clans can track who is requesting.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Timothyjo666

1)if i request a pekka but i have 30 cc space that remaining 5 space cannot be filled and stay up there forever annoying every clan mate
2)if i click multiple units like pekka, archers, wizards then there is a chance to wrong donate by giving wizards
3)ok so you can click each unit to specify how many wizards, archer and pekka you need so you click 1each and no one can wrong donate now
but what if i need any ground troop then?
what if i need any air troop then?
You add more buttons for air troop, any troop, ground troop and make a simple feature like donation complicated?

wrong donations are a problem i can understand but its better to keep some of the simple game mechanics simple.

---

1) You can select more than one troop.
2) Select the specific amount of troops you want donated. 1 Pekka, 2 Wizards and 1 Archer.
3) If you need any ground troop then select all of the ground units?...
Same thing for any air troops.

It's not really complicated. It just makes sure that people who do not want wrong troops have that ability. If you want to have the 'simple way' there would also be an option to select all of the units so it would just be the same as a regular donation.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tosti111

Easier solution, just let me see who donated what troops, even several hours later. That way I can correct the behaviour, demote them or kick them or rat them out to a leader who can do that.

---

Yeah or make sure that it doesn't happen again with my solution. Although being able to know who donated to you is a feature I would like added as well.

Definitely should have been implemented from the start, hope this is added in coc.

Good suggestion, however, adding a button to choose troops is not all good, because if you choose badly and it is sent, you can not modify it, it would be good to reduce the waiting time by requesting troops as well.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Konely

Good suggestion, however, adding a button to choose troops is not all good, because if you choose badly and it is sent, you can not modify it, it would be good to reduce the waiting time by requesting troops as well.

---

True... but yeah if the time for requesting is reduced. It should not be a big problem since you can just quickly fix the troops and get it donated correctly.