Printable View
Here is my suggestion to finish the clouding in Legends..
1. increase no. of players in Titan so. put 2000 gems for achievement to get Titan 2.
2. Don't matches th's in Legends.
3. Increase no. of players in Legends by giving surprise gifts for them . like 10 gems . 1 extra power potion after every season ends. so this will increase the players in Legends and clouding will be less.
Adding extra players to legends will increase clouds even more. Clouds are caused by far more online, shielded, and/or guarded players than there are offline, unshielded, unguarded bases. Adding more players to legends will compound the problem because that's even more online players trying to find one of those offline bases.
As noted in the post above mine, more players doesn’t necessarily mean less clouds. More players that aren’t very active does help. Regarding your suggestions, I don’t think a one time gem bonus would increase the number of players in titans or higher. A gem bonus at the end of every season would because that would actually keep them there. I’m not sure what you mean by don’t match th in Legends. As for legends gifts, power potions wouldn’t do it. Gems or better potions might increase the number who play there.Quote:
Originally Posted by HarshHVM
Too all .. listen guys haven't you read probability?
If it's more player then it means less probability of clouding and less player more probability of CLOUDING...
Okay guys see example.. if 200000 players are in Legends in all over the world with different time zoned then it will be more clouding ?
Or 400000 players from different time zoned. How can you for get that player sleeps too.
What does probability have to do with it?Quote:
Originally Posted by HarshHVM
Clouding isn't about probability, it is about there being far more players looking for bases to attack than there are bases available to be attacked.
That happens not because of a small number of players, but because almost all the players that high are very active (or trying to be!).
Many people with a very superficial knowledge of clouds assume they are caused by a lack of players, but that is simply not the case.
It doesn't matter how many players you have, if they are all as active as those currently in legends.Quote:
Okay guys see example.. if 200000 players are in Legends in all over the world with different time zoned then it will be more clouding ?
Or 400000 players from different time zoned. How can you for get that player sleeps too.
May I suggests that the “GUARD” will be shortened in titan & legend leagues temporarily until the developers will come up for a solution to this. I understand how high profile players are protective on their hard earned trophies, but as I said, only temporary. Cheers! ��
I think this is a good example to explain: Clouds are caused by players trying to get 2 or more attacks for each defense. If you have 10 players trying to get 2+ attacks for each defense, that causes clouds. There are only 10 defenses to go around but the 10 players are trying to get 20 or more attacks. If you make that 100 players doing the same, the clouds are worse, not better. If you make it 100,000 players doing the same, the clouds are worse, not better.Quote:
Originally Posted by HarshHVM
It doesn’t matter what time zone they are in. Yes, they might take one defense while they are sleeping an maybe even one defense while they are awake, but if they are trying to get 3 or more attacks for those 2 defenses they are making the clouds worse, not better.
Guys, why don't you getting... Flooding more players in Legends, gives more bases to attack.. okay tell me why there is no Clouding in lower bases... See in Titan 3 .. more players less clouding.. and more options to attack.....
We don’t get it because it doesn’t work!Quote:
Originally Posted by HarshHVM
I am in legends and on average do 7-10 attacks for every defence I take.
I also have a more casual th9 in Crystal that does 2-3 attacks for each defence
Herein lies the problem. EVERYONE in legends is there because they are active and attacking much much more than a player in the lower leagues.
For those who think reducing guard will impact, it will be negligible. I would be online right up to my pbt regardless of whether this is in or out of guard.
To expand this further let’s say all 200k legends players look for 10 attacks a day - that’s 2m bases required to be hit and each only face 1 defence meaning a deficit of 1.8m bases.
If there were 1m people in legends this would be 10m attacks vs 1m defences so a deficit of 9m this making clouds even worse.
And before you say that players joining won’t be as active then the simple response would be that they wouldn’t be in legends long as they would lose more trophies than they gain and be pushed back down the leagues pretty quickly.
Hope this clears up the matter...
Please actually read the responses and try to understand them.Quote:
Originally Posted by HarshHVM
We are "not getting" because it is simply wrong.
The reason why there are no clouds lower down is not because there are more people, it is because a higher proportion of the people there are less active.
It is highly active players which causes clouding - which is also why the clouds extend lower whenever clan games starts. There are still the same number of players in the lower leagues, but suddenly, far more of them are active.
https://i.stack.imgur.com/jiFfM.jpgQuote:
Originally Posted by HarshHVM
If this doesn't help you understand clouds then nothing will. Look at the diagram below. Everyone in the green can only attack players in the yellow, but cannot attack anyone else in the green because those players are online, and cannot attack anyone in the red because those players have a shield or guard.
As you climb into higher leagues there are less and less total players, hence the reason why the diagram is a pyramid. Each higher league contains less total players than the one below it. As you move up in trophies the proportion of active players to offline/shielded/guarded players remains roughly the same but the number of offline players without a guard or shield diminishes since there are fewer players in each higher league. Hence the reason why the yellow portion shrinks as you move up. This is what causes clouds: a shrinking availability of offline, unguarded and unshielded bases for the active players to attack.
Pumping extra players into legends will cause clouds to become even worse because it increases the amount of players in the green, not the yellow. Say, for arguments sake, that in legends 90% are online looking for a base to attack, 8% are offline with a guard and shield, and 2% are offline without a guard or shield. If we pump more players into legends then that 90% can grow to 95% while diluting the other two categories to something like 4% offline with a guard and shield and 1% offline without a guard and shield. That's how your idea makes clouds worse by leaving even fewer bases available for an increased size of players looking for a base to attack.
https://i.imgur.com/O1lU44j.png