A comparison between the old and the new loot system: Influence on TH 7 - TH10

Printable View

Show 100 post(s) from this thread on one page

December 5th, 2013
Groovy

Quote:

Originally Posted by maggiep0tat0

Great work, OP!
Really helps for people like me who can't grasp at numbers. :)

Only if you are an active player who can raid at long stretches.
Casual players (like me - full disclosure), who currently can only afford to raid-logoff-raid-logoff, may end up playing less & riding more shields.

So, if you can't raid the collectors of people who are online,
and you can't raid the people who ride their shields,
who are you going to raid then?

exactly. This new system favors very active players and hurts the casual player.

And for players whose bases are not up to snuff they will be rolled for max loot
over and over again. You might have a player that attacks get 200/200 then log off
then their base is 3 starred for 400/400 because they can't be online for 8 hours straight.

premie bases are in even bigger trouble now.
December 5th, 2013
Groovy

Quote:

Originally Posted by deifieduandi

I wouldn't say too much before I can test the new loot system. However, I am a TH9, the only reason I dont attack a rigid TH9 or TH10 is because I usually get only 2 storages of gold which worth 100K in the old system whereas it will be 175K and 200K ish in the new system.

so don't do that since NOW you can 3 star th8 saving up for big upgrade and take 270/270
December 5th, 2013
deifieduandi

Quote:

Originally Posted by ConanLegLions

Thanks for the great explanation of the new loot system!

I do guess there is a small error in the graphs or the table below, or can it be explained why a lvl9 attacker has a max loot of 125K against a lvl7 in the table, but only 100K in the graph?

Thank you for pointing out the error, I believe it has been revised. and a curve showing the difference is added for those who won't bother to use the calculator :)
December 5th, 2013
cfl313

True that you can get more loot from the higher th but it is almost impossible to raid them :mad::mad: im a th7 and i couldnt even get to the storages of th9/th10 with loots more than 350k gold/elixer each!!So frustrating

Those at the same th with me only have loots around 30-50k gold/elixer. This update is so stupid

Btw, teach me how to raid. I have 180 army capacity with combination of 7 wallbreakers, 10 giants, 60/40 archers and goblins. Healers has been useless since the last update and it is also hard to destroy air defences.
December 5th, 2013
cfl313

Quote:

Originally Posted by Groovy

exactly. This new system favors very active players and hurts the casual player.

And for players whose bases are not up to snuff they will be rolled for max loot
over and over again. You might have a player that attacks get 200/200 then log off
then their base is 3 starred for 400/400 because they can't be online for 8 hours straight.

premie bases are in even bigger trouble now.

What is the point of increasing the loot capacity of th9 and th10 when their bases are so hard to raid. I am th7 and i find it impossible to gain loot from them. Then those at the same th with me (th7) have so little loot :confused::confused::confused:the loot range from 30-50k gold/elixer
December 5th, 2013
deifieduandi

Quote:

Originally Posted by cfl313

What is the point of increasing the loot capacity of th9 and th10 when their bases are so hard to raid. I am th7 and i find it impossible to gain loot from them. Then those at the same th with me (th7) have so little loot :confused::confused::confused:the loot range from 30-50k gold/elixer

You can find that the difference is negative (less loot) below a certain level of storage amount. This is usually a case where those bases are not strong enough to hold resource thus the major targets of "lootable" bases. The increase of loot at higher storage amount applies to the situation where people at higher league using more powerful troops to attack, for example, balloonion, hogs, or Golem and double "wi".
December 5th, 2013
vincentboy

i got 3 starred by TH10 all the time because of this stupid update.
Seriously!! What the hell is Supercell thinking!!??
December 5th, 2013
Smalls

With any update there are winners and losers. And it's pretty clear th9 and 10 are the big winners here since now they can demolish th8s and get way more loot. The huge losers are th7 and 8 who lose their loot bonus and don't have the troop capacity to reap the benefits of taking more gold from storages at th9 and 10.

I am th8 and play a lot but I have to log off and on often so I always break my shields. I'm hoping that this update won't completely ruin my game due to th9s taking 270k gold every time I log off.
December 5th, 2013
lucky816

This graph and info is incorrect. I have been searching all morning for decent attacks and have seen several th9s and th10s who clearly have more than 3 million resources saved and none of them have even had 200k available to raid. I'm th9 in crystal3. This update is terrible for raiding so far.
December 5th, 2013
MrBunnyCheeks

Quote:

Originally Posted by lucky816

This graph and info is incorrect. I have been searching all morning for decent attacks and have seen several th9s and th10s who clearly have more than 3 million resources saved and none of them have even had 200k available to raid. I'm th9 in crystal3. This update is terrible for raiding so far.

kk.... been playin all morning and no complaints so far, it could be that it is just the way the dice have rolled on the loot today, but will give it more time.

as far as the graphs.....really who has the time or energy to read that ♥♥.....come on, I see the MOD gave it a " great job" but can a MOD verify the graphs?:confused:

Show 100 post(s) from this thread on one page