Printable View
Hello, I would like to suggest an update I see fitting. Usually players in my clan call upon me in order to donate troops to them. I sometimes am unable to and it is a bit frustrating for the both of us. To solve this I would like to put forth the solution of a ‘clan armory’. The armory would be like a giant storage facility for troops that clan mates can donate to and others can take from. Of course with a troop camp space limit.
I agree with you i posted 2-3 days ago the same idea!! I believe this should be heard!! See if you want my post with title make us Independent from donations!!! I agree with you!!
This has been suggested many many many times. So it has been heard. There are many reasons why this could be complicated and difficult to implement. Search for the other threads to find the counter points that have been presented over the years.Quote:
Originally Posted by cocmar
Links please?
https://forum.supercell.com/showthre...lan-Troop-BankQuote:
Originally Posted by Dan123yal
https://forum.supercell.com/showthre...lan-Troop-Dump
https://forum.supercell.com/showthre...War-Troop-Bank
https://forum.supercell.com/showthre...olve-Clan-Bank
https://forum.supercell.com/showthre...-donation-Bank
https://forum.supercell.com/showthre...lan-troop-bank
From what I see the response seems generally positive to this idea.
May be it is positive, but it can be abused.
Suppose someone joins a clan, takes high level troops from armory and leaves the clan
Armory can store any kind of troops --> powerful E-drags, siege machine like Wall Wrecker, etc
What if someone just joins and takes away troops for there.
People would come on forum and flood threads again negatively on this idea.
Even if implemented, when would clan-perks affect troops?
When donating it to armory or while receiving from armory...
And, suppose I donated troops in armory then I request troops from armory ie I take same troops which I donated inside armory (With additional bonus from clan-perks)
Not a good idea.
Its open to abuse.
Then let's say you can only take troops from clan bank if you have been for a longer time in that clan. You have to admiy is a good idea. We can allways can just fix it so will ne loger be open to abuse
Quote:
Originally Posted by LEGODAVID
The problem is taking your own troops back!
Its not about when you can take troops back, its me, myself, taking troops which I donate.
Suppose I donated troops. Got 50% refund + 2 lvl increase (lvl 10 clan)
I take same troops back from clan armory.
I can never "admit" this is a good idea.
Sorry. This is never coming. This can never be fixed.
It is open to abuse, unless SC provides 1000+ line of code and restrictions, to prevent negative use of this.
SC team has much more work to do than to implement this idea with lot many restrictions.
CC has sleep option for your kind information. Leave you request and you are done.
This idea has lot more disadvantage compared to advantages.
Again, Sorry.
This idea should not be supported.
my final Opinion: Kill this idea, and the thread. Add it to Ruled out section.
This has been answered multiple times since I joined the forum.
So no new members cannot get troops even if that new member gets included in war. There are many players out there that jumps to and from their sister clans to donate or get troops and this idea will prevent that from happening.Quote:
Originally Posted by LEGODAVID