Freeze witch overpowered at th10....

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by wind30

Errr... I never said it can 3 star every base. Do u want to post your base which I failed twice?

---

Well, you sort of gave that impression, given you claimed the attack plan was OP and said:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by wind30

When is the nerf coming? U can’t defend freeze witch...

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by wind30

I can personally come and wreck all your th10 bases

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by wind30

I can’t find a base that defend vs my comp... I don’t even tweak my comp during fc.

---

But then you did admit you were basically trolling with the thread:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by wind30

My hit rate was just average. The title is just attention grabbing.

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by wind30

:) ok, but surely u did not take it seriously. I just wanted some fc vs a variety of bases. Some clans are nice and polite, others are just too sensitive

actually I practise a lot as I need it. I never said I was good. In fact I think I learn slower. I just said I think the comp is op.

---

Yet somehow you couldn't 3 star, with the second attack coming to 2 star 70% even. Different comps for different bases, so just because the comp is super effective for your base doesn't automatically means it wins the lottery. Oh and in case you haven't figured it out yet, the only reason you could "wreck all your clanmates bases" is because of wallwrecker, a TH12 troop available for TH10s, otherwise the comp is trash if you straight up just deploy cc. Thus a better topic would be "remove WW for TH10s" instead of nerf a certain comp, because every solid war comp is greatly enhanced with WW, does that make all comps OP? There's your answer and my 2 cents. I don't imagine WW being available for TH10s for long anyway so if I were you I would attack in wars the old school way, just normal cc. That's the challenge.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Qatar101

Can't see how OP's clan bases failed. OP joined and failed twice to 3 star, that with WW as well. Conclusion: No strategy can 3 star every base

---

No surprises there.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by wind30

3 def is 300dps.... not counting enemy heroes cc. Hard for the ww will reach anywhere good without freeze...

---

Do the maths. 5700 hit points is a lot. With nothing at all taking down defences (ie no trailing heros) it would still last 19 seconds with 300 dps incoming constantly (which isn’t always happening). I’m telling you from experience on bigger bases that deployed as you do with heros appropriately sized to size of base defences, it gets through 3 layers of walls with a high degree of reliability unassisted. Better yet, don’t just take my word, learn exactly what yours can do on things the size you attack: fc with it on fellow th10 to experiment by just putting ww and hero component of attack (ignore main army part), using no spells except in case of single inferno. Repeat over and over with different points on bases that have different concentrations of defence types. Use a few weak funnel troops that will just do that funnel job but not impact ww durability findings by taking out any defence (like some disposable wizards) to ensure your king and king follow it into the base promptly. I think you’ll find you are underestimating it and probably wasting spells there.

Lol, good thread. Need op to post more results against good bases

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by wind30

When is the nerf coming? U can’t defend freeze witch...

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by wind30

Which clan are u in? I can personally come and wreck all your th10 bases

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Qatar101

Alright fine show me how you can magically 3 star me, with farming base too. Let me know if you're on.

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Qatar101

Can't see how OP's clan bases failed. OP joined and failed twice to 3 star, that with WW as well. Conclusion: No strategy can 3 star every base

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by wind30

Errr... I never said it can 3 star every base. Do u want to post your base which I failed twice? I really did not have much practise on such a base....

I haven’t seen a centralised th base for a Long time

why u kick me after two tries?

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bigdome757

Sure looks like you said so here?^^^^
Perhaps you meant you could wreck all of them that don’t have a centralized th and with a bit of practice?

---

And this is a good example of why you should read the whole thread before coming to any conclusions. Now that I have read each post I can safely conclude OP has failed wholeheartedly at proving his point:p And in fact has proved the opposite :saywhat:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by wind30

errr.... just because you have 3 golems does not mean you are doing stoned goho. How you use your troops/spells is by far the most important. The fact that this comp has not become popular just shows that people does not know how to use the troops right.

If someone have a similar comp but uses the spells/cc in a totally different way, I think it is fair to say it is original.

---

By definition stoned means 3 golems, shattered means 2 and cold blooded means 1. Those are the established names for that sort of attack. It does not matter whether or not you are doing the attack wrong or right.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Qatar101

Can't see how OP's clan bases failed. OP joined and failed twice to 3 star, that with WW as well. Conclusion: No strategy can 3 star every base

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by wind30

Errr... I never said it can 3 star every base. Do u want to post your base which I failed twice? I really did not have much practise on such a base....

I haven’t seen a centralised th base for a Long time

why u kick me after two tries?

---

Hmm sometimes it is best to be humble and thoroughly test out your "new" strategy first before going to the forums calling for a nerf and making claims you cannot substantiate.

I think this thread would have been a whole lot more productive if

1. The OP simply asked to join a clan and test out his attack as an experiment.
2. Publish his attack on YouTube and see how the community reacts.
3. Invited a YouTuber into his clan to showcase the attack.

I agree that this thread ought to be closed to prevent further toxicity.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Gorbash098

1. The OP simply asked to join a clan and test out his attack as an experiment.

---

He did go to a clan and failed to 3 star on two tries.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by 2222

He did go to a clan and failed to 3 star on two tries.

---

Yes, indeed he did but under the arrogant position that he can 3 star any TH10. If he would have approached from the position of asking to simply test his hypothesis and not have a preconceived notion that he posses an OP strategy then I think the forum members would be more cooperative and less cynical of the OP's claim.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Damiz

And this is a good example of why you should read the whole thread before coming to any conclusions. Now that I have read each post I can safely conclude OP has failed wholeheartedly at proving his point:p And in fact has proved the opposite :saywhat:

---

Let's hope he at least copied a good base or 2 in the process, then it's not a total failure.

I am the guy who Knows all, sees all, beats all!