Printable View
Clan members should be allowed to claim their rewards if all the tiers are collectively achieved by the clan...
This is especially necessitated when 50k or so point tiers clan games are run fr 7 days...(fr the sake of small nd busy clans as i see no other possible explanation)....So clans who come first should be served first...
This is also felt when u r already left with the last tier with only 2 days down in the current games with EVERYTHING BOOSTED....
So exactly why is this needed? Do the gifts go stale?
Even when you leave a clan, you can still claim the rewards when it is time, so I really do not see the purpose.
That's the main reason why we shouldn't have people asking for CG information early, as it doesn't help your preparation at all. Everyone need to wait until CG finished to claim rewards and thus have the time to prepare for the rewards. Similarly, you got to plan/manage your upgrades in line with when you can claim the rewards. Not asking SC to change the timing of the rewards to suit your upgrades plan.Quote:
Originally Posted by Paribodh
Nothing is “necessitated”. You would just prefer your rewards earlier out of impatience to use them, after going through your games tasks quickly rather than spreading them out over the event. Like Xmas, the presents don’t come any faster just for impatiently willing the day on. There’s no good reason I can see for them to change it, given gratifying your impatience about waiting isn’t a good reasoning itself.Quote:
Originally Posted by Paribodh
When my siblings and I were children we would sit in the back seat of the car on long trips chanting “are we there yet?” over and over again... credit to my parents for allowing us all to survive to adulthood.
Why?
/10questions
Plz ask the essence of getting the magic items earlier to a new next town hall than he was a few weeks earlier and waiting to get his most powerful combos to the max possible level thru those magic items...
Sitting stagnant at a particular th after maxing it out and u will surely comment so rudely after that...no offense
Bt Get Well Soon!!!
so you want them at the moment your clan hits the last tier.
what if some players decide not to do quests until the last day? you need the few points but the people maybe are busy or just want to enjoy your impatience.
what if you hit the last tier after one day in a seven day cg and next cg is seven days after the cg end? that is 13 days without any cg. will you complain than that you must wait so much time?
what if you hit the last tier after one day and some players in your clan havent done any quests? will they still be able to do quests and get the rewards?
Few weeks?? You mean a couple of days. And no one answered in this thread rude (except of you maybe).Quote:
Originally Posted by Paribodh
None of that is even relevant. If your clan has completed all the tiers, and you (as an individual) are ready to collect, allow it so that you can do so at any point, from the moment the games have been completed, to the one-week-after-games expiration.Quote:
Originally Posted by wotanwaton
If we could do that, it would be very nice, but if they never allow this, no big deal. He is asking for a quality-of-life improvement.
I don't like waiting either but it's better than not getting any rewards at all. Patience is key young grasshopper
its not relevant if some players in the clan doesnt do the needed few points to reach the last tier to get the rewards faster?Quote:
Originally Posted by TheConfuzed1
Our clan are doing competition who can finished 5k first. When done all 75k, we remind others to play at least a game to get all the prizes. There no jealousy among us whether you get more points or less points. Just finished them. Today is the 2nd day for the cg and we ve achieved 55k by tomorrow all done. And everyone is congratulating to each other.
That the the spirit of team work :)
cheers
Exactly the right attitude to Clan Games!Quote:
Originally Posted by Chiewping
The only thing I’m concerned about in the Games is, thay everybody in the clan are able to get the full set of rewards.
Luckily, there are enough highly active members to allow others to get by with just 1 or 2 challenges.
/Affront
Hmm. Our clan we work as a team, everyone doing their fair share. We set a minimum point goal for everyone who wants to do games(40% max points, 2k in this one). It encourages teamwork and prevent leeching. Thats the spirit of clash imoQuote:
Originally Posted by Affront
I know it's really not on topic directly, but this is one of those debates that keeps coming up in our clan leadership, I have always been thinking along these lines that it's more important for a person to do at least 1 challenge than to not, that way the resources are gained. A bunch of people are upset that those doing minimum work get the full reward, but basically if we are getting to the max tier, I am not too bothered how we got there. It's when you are struggling as a clan to get to the top tier that you need to start looking at those doing only 1 or 2 challenges and ask them to step up.Quote:
Originally Posted by Chiewping
Otherwise on topic. I suppose it wouldn't hurt if you could get the reward as soon as the clan gets to top tier. Either way you get the same loot in the end so I can't see that SC considering to make it so being intrinsically problematic. Personally I am not phased.
I’m more of a “do as I do” kind of Leader(co, at the moment) ,than a “do as I say” Leader.Quote:
Originally Posted by RagingKoala
That’s partly why I’ve made a point of maxing (and overachieving) in every single round of Clan Games.
Largely inactive players that can’t do more than a few challenges in a week, will be hard pressed to actually USE the rewards they could be getting... what use is a couple of Book and potions, if you can’t raid enough to use them anyway.
You can’t force people to play, but you can show them how it’s done.
When I have to kick somebody, I DO look at their performance in Games (because lookinh at war performance in our case makes no sense)
/Affront
Nobody has been rude to you. Yes, we understand why you are impatient to receive them quickly. That’s not a reason for SC to implement it, rather than suggest you cultivate a bit more patience and ability to delay gratification for a bare few days.Quote:
Originally Posted by Paribodh
If you are sitting stagnant at a particular th while intending to progress ASAP, then it’s you who has mucked your timing up on something, either by being careless with builder allocation, too impatient about letting any one of the sit idle a day or two, or been too fast to plan on the basis of having magic items you hadn’t yet got. Plenty of others manage to get all builders coming free and full storages on the day the th upgrade finishes. If you were truly interested in maximising progression speed through town hall levels then you wouldn’t be maxing anyway, so a couple of days now won’t hurt... what hurts that aim of speediest possible progression is any willingness to spend any stagnant time at all on any th level just for the sake of maxing. Full maxing is what you do if you enjoy that as a goal in itself, not what you do if your goal is the speediest progression through the town hall levels.
Most of us just think “isn’t it great we have magic items now, especially to help us into a new th level... and I’ll have some soon, great” rather than ungratefully complaining we have none in the hand the very second we think we’d like to use one before the games we earned it from are done.
It creates an unfair advantage If you allow some to collect the rewards from the CG early and others not. While it is an accomplishment to be able to take care of the points that quick it should not be allowed to have the rewards faster.Quote:
Originally Posted by Paribodh
My clan youngest member is 6 yrs old, few are 12 yrs old, if he or she can get 200-500 points, that good enough. We as a co should cover up and finished the 75k, as for the kids we just take as compliments points. We ve never failed in cg and I like watching those kids enjoy themselves.Quote:
Originally Posted by Darkpye
We ve 50 members, just accepted last 8 new members last week from this forum and we were lucky, 8 of them , 5 achieved 5k, other 3 were kids and they help to contribute200 points.
Right now we have 68k, another 7k we re done and wait for the prizes.
You can’t imagine the work force in our clan. And the most crazy part is I myself finished my 5k within 4 hrs. So others followed, within a day completed. I even finished my 2nd Acc as well. I don’t mind I ve contributed too much. Clan members haPpy i m haPpy ....
This is the spirit of Team work
:)
That wouldn't change anything. You are getting the rewards anyway and if really can still wait a few days before collecting them...
No... If the clan has completed the achievement, they are ready to unlock the rewards. If an individual hasn't yet participated, then they still have time to do so. One has nothing to do with the other!Quote:
Originally Posted by wotanwaton
Quote:
Originally Posted by Chiewping
Agreed. That is exactly how I run my clan and we have never nice missed the top reward tier in any clan games.Quote:
Originally Posted by Affront
Everyone contributes and adds value in some way. For some that is more in war, donations, or otherwise than in clan games.Quote:
Originally Posted by RagingKoala
If I have a member who participates in every war, gets frequent six packs, contributes with strategy, and/or gives massive donations, but for some reason they're unable to do much in clan games, that is okay. I'll definitely remind him to make sure he completes at least one achievement though!
Exactly right. Clan games is only one indicator of clan member value. I max out clan games and I happen to be the biggest donator of siege machines. If I couldn't for whatever reason contribute whatever minimum is required by the clan for clan games and the clan made an issue of it, my siege machine workshop would suddenly become very very idle.Quote:
Originally Posted by TheConfuzed1
The point being, any decent leader will look at all facets of a clan members contributions, not just clan games to determine clan member value.
How would it be unfair if everyone had the option to do the same?Quote:
Originally Posted by Ckcrystalck2los
As far as we know, it looks like the Games are coded so that the rewards can be collected once the games end (it's the simplest way to do it, and we haven't seen anything to the contrary). They would probably have to fundamentally alter the base coding of the Games, which just doesn't seem worth it, at least to me.Quote:
Originally Posted by TheConfuzed1
Like I said, I really don't care either way. I'm just playing devil's advocate. Also, Pari is in my clan. ;)Quote:
Originally Posted by themariofan
Changing the base code of the game shouldn't have anything to do with it, in the grand scheme of things they can make it work whichever way they want it to work, ultimately this is really a 6 of 1 half a dozen of another scenario, I really can't see it breaking anything if they did change and any reasonable person really shouldn't take issue with a change like this, but unless there are a lot of people who really want the change I suspect they wouldn't bother.Quote:
Originally Posted by themariofan
I'm not saying I have an issue with it, but I imagine they'd be changing the foundation of the Games themselves, which opens it all up to bugs, bugs, and more bugs, and a buggy Games or two is the last thing people need.Quote:
Originally Posted by Darkpye