Approval of donated troops

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by sean007r

I have a few ideas that I'll list individually so they aren't over looked or duplicated...

1.) have an approval button for troop donations

for example, I want archers, but someone sends me a wall breaker
i should be able to REJECT that troop(s) and send them back

---

That would be like a troop request filter which is ruled out

Isn't this why we have the new custom request button?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Wattsahh

This is the number one thing I would like to see added to the game. Nothing is more frustrating than training a balloon/minion army, requesting minions, and then having the "guy who always requests dragons" fill me up with giants so his "ratio" doesn't go out of wack. Why have a request button at all if people just ignore it, give whatever they want, and then expect gratitude in return? I would love the idea of a box popping up exactly the way it does when you're giving troops. Instead it pops up when you're requesting. You tap the type of troops you would like to have, and only those troops can be given. I can't tell you how many masters and champs have left clans I have been a part of because ole "giant giver" keeps ignoring requests but sure does love taking those lvl 5 hogs or upgraded witches that he can't make. Frustrating.

What's rude is saying "I don't have what a person is requesting so I will fill them up with whatever I want or have lying around, regardless of what their army composition or attack strategy may be."

---

Hold on a second everyone: Why did you bump this thread?

Assumed it was better as stated in an above post that it was better to add my ideas to an existing thread on the same topic instead of starting a new thread about the same topic. Wouldn't this be a better way to go about things or do you enjoy sifting through the over 500 "boost builder huts" threads?
Also, while seeing that the idea of being able to filter donations as they come in was ruled out, I thought my idea would be a variant that would be easier to implement therefore, possible.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Wattsahh

This is the number one thing I would like to see added to the game. Nothing is more frustrating than training a balloon/minion army, requesting minions, and then having the "guy who always requests dragons" fill me up with giants so his "ratio" doesn't go out of wack. Why have a request button at all if people just ignore it, give whatever they want, and then expect gratitude in return? I would love the idea of a box popping up exactly the way it does when you're giving troops. Instead it pops up when you're requesting. You tap the type of troops you would like to have, and only those troops can be given. I can't tell you how many masters and champs have left clans I have been a part of because ole "giant giver" keeps ignoring requests but sure does love taking those lvl 5 hogs or upgraded witches that he can't make. Frustrating.

What's rude is saying "I don't have what a person is requesting so I will fill them up with whatever I want or have lying around, regardless of what their army composition or attack strategy may be."

---

If giant-guy is filling you up with unwanted troops, perhaps it is time for the leaders to step up and oust the member. That kind of behaviour isn't tolerated in many clans. On an night where ppl are on late, and requests stay open for longer, i wouldn't want to have to approve troops - this may mean an unprotected base if I didn't wait around to see what was given to me. i agree that clan troops should be looked on as a gift. If a member continually gives troops that are not asked for, then this, to me, is a clan management issue, not a Supercell game feature issue.