Printable View
I have a few ideas that I'll list individually so they aren't over looked or duplicated...
1.) have an approval button for troop donations
for example, I want archers, but someone sends me a wall breaker
i should be able to REJECT that troop(s) and send them back
Its not the end of the world of you get bad cc troops, especially if you are farming.
You can request again in 20 minutes
Nah, can you imagine not getting 5 archers because you weren't playing? resulting in a loss of 100k gold?Quote:
Originally Posted by sean007r
I would not like this at all personally
No, no, and no again.Quote:
Originally Posted by sean007r
If you have good clanmates, they will send you what you need. Also, dictating what troops (and level) can be sent to you is absurd. People need to donate to bring their donations up, and it doesn't much matter what you get. Also, some troops are RIDICULOUSLY expensive and take FOREVER (That's a hyperbole) to train.
Rejecting all but the best troops, or rejecting all, is one example of how snobbish players could abuse this feature. Also, players could refuse every troops given, and then claim that they 'were never given anything when they requested.'
Sorry, but this feature could be abused.
Also, as another mentioned: Clan castle troops are just a bonus. 20 minutes isn't that long to wait when you consider the train time of an army. Don't complain when someone gives you something. It's sort of like Christmas:
It's rude to say "I don't like this, take it back and give me what I want."
This is the number one thing I would like to see added to the game. Nothing is more frustrating than training a balloon/minion army, requesting minions, and then having the "guy who always requests dragons" fill me up with giants so his "ratio" doesn't go out of wack. Why have a request button at all if people just ignore it, give whatever they want, and then expect gratitude in return? I would love the idea of a box popping up exactly the way it does when you're giving troops. Instead it pops up when you're requesting. You tap the type of troops you would like to have, and only those troops can be given. I can't tell you how many masters and champs have left clans I have been a part of because ole "giant giver" keeps ignoring requests but sure does love taking those lvl 5 hogs or upgraded witches that he can't make. Frustrating.
What's rude is saying "I don't have what a person is requesting so I will fill them up with whatever I want or have lying around, regardless of what their army composition or attack strategy may be."
maybe people donating the wrong thing and terrible troops should push you to farm more and get into a better clan where donation requests are respected.Quote:
Originally Posted by Wattsahh
I could make an account here. Search the forums to be sure not to make a repeated thread. Reply to thread found in search that already addressed my issue. And offer an in game user interface improvement that would address the issue that bothers me.Quote:
Originally Posted by tonjerfita
That's a better idea than "leave a clan where you enjoy the company and conversation of most of the members because a few people have annoying habits. "
Are you married? Does your spouse annoy you at times? Get a divorce!!! Find someone who doesn't annoy you!! It's just that easy.
Perfect idea...and this is a perfect example.Quote:
Originally Posted by Wattsahh
If the box opening up for requests like it does when donating is too tough to quickly implement, how about a trash can icon where you can dump unwanted troops and not have to wait the 20 minutes to request again?
Of course Im sure this would lead to donation spamming for xp boosting but some type of cool down could be placed on donating repeatedly to the same person.
Why not kick "ole giant giver" or give him wallbreakers or barbs to teach him a lesson?Quote:
Originally Posted by Wattsahh
Sounds like he as an antisocial user, and any clan would be better off without him.