people coming out in the middle of the war !!
developers could punish or disable the option to leave the clan until the war ends !!
many clans with this problem !! :):thumbsup:
Printable View
people coming out in the middle of the war !!
developers could punish or disable the option to leave the clan until the war ends !!
many clans with this problem !! :):thumbsup:
The only clans with this problem are those clans with a clan management problem.
There are countless threads on this topic, with countless responses describing why it is a bad idea.
Why should you get to hold me hostage in a clan if I don't want to be there?Quote:
Originally Posted by Pasoka
Quote:
Originally Posted by Phoenix1027
You made a commitment to the war !!
Do you think it's fair to make people angry?
Do you think it's fair to lose the war because you leave the clan?
I do not think it's fair!
Thats a BIIIIIIG no no...
You cant force people to stay on your clan...
My Warchief only brings member to war who make they'r attaks...
If you invite every new member to war its your fault if they are leaving.
Just bring in trusted people this leads to less frustration.
Quote:
Originally Posted by JohnnyPC
You may not be a clan leader to know how difficult it is to make wars and people leave the clan without communicating !!
I think it's fair to pay with recourse to leave the clan or disable the button to leave the clan until the war is over!
only for people who are at war!
many clans complaining about this, because most people do not have responsibility !!
this harms the clan who wants to have fun !!
not to force people to stay in the clan, it's just to make people think twice before going to war so as not to harm the clan !!Quote:
Originally Posted by Stady507
a new clan suffers greatly from this and prevents it from evolving !!
the leaders are not to blame.It's the fault of the people who do not have responsibility, enters the war and then leaves the clan !!
it's just an idea to end this problem !!
Forcing players to stay in your clan is not a solution. They still can’t be forced to attack. Also, many players leave their clan during war to get better troops donated from sister clans or req and leave clans.
Well if you bring just trusted people you dont have the problem... Write your clan rules in your clan description.
with this idea, the clash of clans will have many more new clans active in wars !!
the idea is only people who go to war disable the option of leaving the clan until the war is over !!
the global does not know if the person is reliable to recruit !!
creating this rule in clan description will not solve the problem !!
change is for all people to have fun !!
I wish there would be a solution, but OP these people are usually Referred as Hoppers, no matter what, the earth would rotate upside down, They'll leave your clan after receiving donations/Roam around 1000+ clans. You just need to be careful while choosing players for wars. Try to know more about figuring hoppers.
Clan leaders can put me in war even if I opt out. Should I be forced to stay in a clan if the clan leader starts bullying me by continuously placing me in war even though I opt out?Quote:
Originally Posted by Pasoka
the idea is not to force anyone to stay in the clan ... it's just punishment for irresponsibility and disrespect for clan players who are in the war !!Quote:
Originally Posted by Bigdome757
the attacks at war have the rules that can be put in the description, all the clans put in the description !!(not doing 2 attacks at war will be expelled from the clan)
ask for donations of troops in the global that do not need to leave the clan to ask, players in the global can enter the clan to help in donations !!
the idea is only when the player is at war as punishment, not being able to leave the clan or pay with the resources to leave immediately !!Quote:
Originally Posted by Phoenix1027
the war ends the option to exit appears and the player can leave the clan !!
with this idea the players will think better before making a commitment in the wars !!
Forcing them to stay won't make them attack and if they are forced to stay when they want to leave they will just purposely cause problems and disrupt the clan until someone kicks them.Quote:
Originally Posted by Pasoka
This solution will only make things worse for the clan not better
What about leaving the players who want to leave the clan temporarly, for ex to go in a friend clan to get/give troops ?
Of course they could.Quote:
Originally Posted by Pasoka
There is no chance they will, as there is no good reason to do it, and plenty not to.
Let's say I'm a new member in your clan. And you included me in the war. I don't get to leave the clan until the war ends. But I won't attack as well. What can you do to make me attack? Tell me please. What if I just go offline all day during battle day? Or even if I'm online, stay active in chat, and spam the clan chat with the words "I won't attack"
Get the picture?
I'm the leader of my clan and I have seven accounts ranging from th9 to th12. Whenever someone new comes in, they are subjected to try out my war bases. That is to determine their capability on attacking during wars. But still, that doesn't stop them from not attacking if I included them in war.
One thing you can do is impose a rule that they have to sit out in a number of clan wars while staying in your clan.
You didn't address my concern. What's to stop a clan leader from bullying me by holding me hostage in a clan that I don't want to be in? What the clan leader and I live on opposite ends of the world and clan wars end while he's awake and I'm asleep, and he immediately starts a new war when the last one finishes. I'm asleep and I would be stuck in the clan AGAIN because the leader keeps putting me into war.Quote:
Originally Posted by Pasoka
This idea will never happen. Too abusable, too unnecessary.
Wait but how is it unfair IF he already finished his war attack? Then thats not his fault. Thats the clan management's fault, yeah!Quote:
Originally Posted by Pasoka