Hello Supercell,
I would have an update - suggestion for you. For us this would be the following: "The fact that the Level 7 walls could be upgraded to the Level 8 walls with Elexier would be pretty cool, because the lower Town Hall players would not get that far or it would take a long time .." Because there are more and more coming Walls for the bigger Town Hall players would be fairer. Hope you talked the whole thing and my wishes. mfg: Yolo aka. Mert 😁
It was tried once already and Supercell needed to scale it back, because the loss of elixir created huge problems for the economy. I doubt they'd try it again.
that was the time there are no daily bonus, troop and spell events, clan war events and clan games rewards. i think they need to reconsiderQuote:
Originally Posted by SharkyFinn
It was in a time of sniping and full bonusesQuote:
Originally Posted by ninjalvl999
if the elixir shortage was fixable back then ( since players could just th snipe), why was upgrading walls at th with elix removed then?Quote:
Originally Posted by Somethingnotalreadypicked
Because, the way the game is, players at TH8 tend to run fat with elixir whilst finishing up the other stuff. TH9's farm those elixir heavy 8's for their initial elixir upgrades before moving on to farming each other for DE. If TH8's could dump their elixir into walls, then there would be considerably less for early 9's to farm and they would struggle to upgrade their camps and troops. As such, it would slow down progression at TH9 by a considerable amount and is therefore, a bad idea.Quote:
Originally Posted by ninjalvl999
based on what i observed when i was th8, you can get 300k-400k gold from other th8s with lower level walls. that means not every th8s is busy grinding walls. if elix walls are available at th8, that wont make every th8 you search now grind for walls.Quote:
Originally Posted by gaz1966
Lab research at TH8 is 212 days. Buildings (with 5 builders) take 167 days 12 hours. Elixir cost for research is 54M, elixir cost for buildings is 63.98M. Gold cost for buildings (excluding walls) is 153.93M. If a TH8 is doing all the buildings to max and all the walls as well then they will naturally start overflowing elixir.
If they could do walls with it then obviously they would dump it into them and it would be lost to the economy. I well remember what happened when SC let TH8's spend elixir on walls and trust me, they reverted it very quickly. It was proven to be a bad idea then, it's still a bad idea now.
It doesn't matter what the TH8's are grinding, what does matter is that if they dumped elixir into walls, it wouldn't be available for early TH9's to farm, so how would they upgrade their camps and farming troops ? TH9 is already a grind, this would make it a thousand times worse.Quote:
Originally Posted by ninjalvl999
what i meant to say is not every th8 dumps resource to walls . if you see a th8 who doesnt dump gold into walls, chances are he wont have the effort to put elix into walls either. th9s will still find elix.Quote:
Originally Posted by gaz1966
Unless that th8 is in the process of saving for their next defensive building upgrade.....Quote:
Originally Posted by ninjalvl999