Terrorism in Clash of Clans

Printable View

February 10th, 2013
Moseszator

Terrorism in Clash of Clans

My clan just got destroyed by this guy called "sparsh" (lvl 58) If you see him do please destroy every single bit of him till he cries.

Basically one of my 9 year old clan members agreed to give him eldership for his credit card number. He actually was so naive to do it. Up till now that member still believes that credit card no. is legit.

Because of the fact that this is a 9 year old + game as stated on the app store, we must not ignore the fact that we have children players. They are still very innocent and have no idea what corruption is. So many problems will arise, especially social ones.

Can you add these features in to prevent anymore such terrorist attacks on the clan?

1) Elder that promoted another member to elder has a 1 day window to demote him again. This is to give the leader time to stop any frauds

2) Co-leader position (1 only) so that the most trusted members also have the power to stop crazy players

3) Ability to message those that got kicked (Once a player has been kicked we can click on the chat name and send a message)

4) Ability for leader to set daily kicking limit for elders.

Many of you probably haven't been terrorized by such people, but I'm telling you you do NOT want to get hit by these cruel people. Hope SC will implement this to stop such folly.
February 10th, 2013
zachUVA

Love all 4 of those ideas. The last one may be a bit tricky because of its voluntary nature, but I would support it. I have never experienced a mass kicking, but I still feel that these features would help all clans.
February 10th, 2013
Duber

I definitely agree with having a Co-leader position in clans.
February 10th, 2013
Moseszator

The worst thing is: This happens everyday but there are no regulations to stop it :/
February 10th, 2013
dahimi

Why do you have a 9 y/o elder?

You know the power being granted elder gives. I would never trust a 9 y/o to have the proper judgement to not make mistakes.
February 10th, 2013
zachUVA

Lol, i actually didnt see that part; I skipped straight down to the numbers. Yeah, seriously, what is up with that?
February 10th, 2013
Moseszator

Quote:

Originally Posted by dahimi

Why do you have a 9 y/o elder?

You know the power being granted elder gives. I would never trust a 9 y/o to have the proper judgement to not make mistakes.

Haha only found out he was 9 years old after asking why he fell for such a stupid excuse!
February 10th, 2013
dahimi

Quote:

Originally Posted by Moseszator

Haha only found out he was 9 years old after asking why he fell for such a stupid excuse!

This tells me you need to screen your elders better. Alternatively, why not make everyone elder after they have been with the clan for a bit?
February 10th, 2013
Moseszator

Quote:

Originally Posted by dahimi

This tells me you need to screen your elders better. Alternatively, why not make everyone elder after they have been with the clan for a bit?

He has been with me for 3 months, thought he was ready. I actually demoted him once, but after that he seemed ready for eldership again. So yeah just gave him a chance. Anyway whats important isnt how old elders are, its how to stop such trollers.
February 10th, 2013
zachUVA

Quote:

Originally Posted by Moseszator

He has been with me for 3 months, thought he was ready. I actually demoted him once, but after that he seemed ready for eldership again. So yeah just gave him a chance. Anyway whats important isnt how old elders are, its how to stop such trollers.

Agreed. Regardless of the particular circumstances in your specific case, some changes should be made. The most important of which, in my opinion, is having a way to message kicked members. Even better would be a reinvite button.
February 10th, 2013
Moseszator

Quote:

Originally Posted by zachUVA

Agreed. Regardless of the particular circumstances in your specific case, some changes should be made. The most important of which, in my opinion, is having a way to message kicked members. Even better would be a reinvite button.

Oh yeah a reinvite button. That would be better. Even after the player has joined another clan.
February 10th, 2013
dahimi

Quote:

Originally Posted by Moseszator

He has been with me for 3 months, thought he was ready. I actually demoted him once, but after that he seemed ready for eldership again. So yeah just gave him a chance. Anyway whats important isnt how old elders are, its how to stop such trollers.

Who you promote totally matters. I mean you want to add a co-leader rank. Guess what happens after you do that. You get a bunch of posts here about co-leaders who kicked everyone.

Treat elders like co-leaders if you are promoting people selectively.
February 10th, 2013
Moseszator

Quote:

Originally Posted by dahimi

Who you promote totally matters. I mean you want to add a co-leader rank. Guess what happens after you do that. You get a bunch of posts here about co-leaders who kicked everyone.

Treat elders like co-leaders if you are promoting people selectively.

Yeah that could be a problem too. Coleaders shouldn't have the ability to kick people, just have the ability to suspend all activities of the member. So that particular "suspended" member can't post, request, or promote anyone. I think this makes co-leaders less dangerous, at the same time prevent the clan from "imploding"
February 10th, 2013
Moseszator

Bump. If we get enough responses one of the SC staff will see this...
February 10th, 2013
DirewolfInSheepsClothing

OP, I'm on your side

Totally agree with the OP on this one. OP: ignore the idiots who say "its your fault".

The truth is it's not your fault but a design fault in the game and some little people with no life have begun to exploit this flaw.

I have messaged the mods on this forum and gotten good responses re: this very issue. They have assured me they take this activity very seriously and we will probably see a change to eldership functions in the future.

Best,
Z
February 11th, 2013
Moseszator

Quote:

Originally Posted by DirewolfInSheepsClothing

Totally agree with the OP on this one. OP: ignore the idiots who say "its your fault".

The truth is it's not your fault but a design fault in the game and some little people with no life have begun to exploit this flaw.

I have messaged the mods on this forum and gotten good responses re: this very issue. They have assured me they take this activity very seriously and we will probably see a change to eldership functions in the future.

Best,
Z

Glad to hear that :)
February 11th, 2013
Madara

You choose your elders yourself. If they're not suitable, they just aren't. It's your fault making a 9 years old child an elder, and what's worse is that he tried to scam someones CC at such young age, lol. Choose your elders, and you won't have this problem. Been with my clan since level 14 and I'm 72 now. We have never had elder abuse, because our elders are chosen wisely.
February 11th, 2013
1mP3N

The ideas are neat in my opinion. However, it leads me to a fundamental question: The situation or ''fraud'' you have described would not have occurred if certain parties had taken reasonable care.

Having a young player to hold eldership powers appears to be unreasonable in some sense. As adults, the majority of us has the ability to judge rights and wrongs and determine what is reasonable. For a nine-year-old child, we certainly cannot place equivalent expectations.

However, neglecting how unreasonable and faultful it was to have a young player as an elder, then involved in an easily avoidable fraud, the suggestions are worth to be noticed by the SC staff.

I support the idea of implementing these features, regardless of how laughable the incident was.
February 11th, 2013
Destiny

love these ideas. on top of it i would suggest a ban button. so you would be able to ban someone from your clan to keep them from returning
February 11th, 2013
Cute

Oliver.101 kicked out everyone in my clan

Clan name The dark army :( one of my elder make him elder and he started to kicked everyone
February 11th, 2013
Cute

1 Attachment(s)

Look

Oliver.101

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cute

Clan name The dark army :( one of my elder make him elder and he started to kicked everyone
February 11th, 2013
Kansas

I would love to see a senior elder position established.
February 11th, 2013
Vrushabh

terrorists are invadind!
February 15th, 2013
Moseszator

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cute

Oliver.101

Yeah thats what I mean... All clashers out there don't think your clans are safe too... These no-lifers could enter your clan anytime too
October 13th, 2015
Halym5

Mass kicker in my clan

Most of my clan members were kicked by a mass kicker. I gave him co-leader and about two days later he kicked all the members and elders of my clan.. My clan had 15 members and this was dropped to only 4 members. My clan was nearly destroyed because of this kicker..
October 13th, 2015
HungryHungryHippo

On the upside, you only make this mistake once ;)
October 13th, 2015
herranton

I think this issue was resolved. Supercell broke down and added the coleader rank and also a cool down time for elders kicking people. Thread is nearly three years old and not really relevant anymore.