Clan Battles

Amazing idea!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Mlee107

Please do a forum search before posting. So many dupicates.

---

I don't see anything wrong about sharing ideas that have already been said. Unless it's ruled out or if it's very little detail then it's not worth sharing. That's what ideas and feature requests are for. To let people share ideas on what they want in a different perspective than others because no two human beings are the same. That means no two human beings think exactly the same thing. They have different views of things. Let them share how they think it should be! If this thread just said " we should have clan wars" then I can see what you mean. But it's not like that. It's detailed. If there's more duplicates than supercell will see it more often. That means they might implement it. If 1 idea is posted only once, then supercell will surely not see it. If there were duplicates, then Supercell will definitely see it!

the people of the clan should be able to choose if they want to participate in the battle if they don't they shoudnt have to

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by rardriar

the people of the clan should be able to choose if they want to participate in the battle if they don't they shoudnt have to

---

I agree, however it can be a bit tricky to implement, when the clan leader decides to enter with his clan into a Clan Battle, it is possible that not all members are online, and sending "Accept/Reject" messages to all of them and waiting for all of them to answer can be complicated.

Love the idea but on the second part I think when the leader is telling people to declare war on the other clan, I think they shud be allowed to object so they're not forced to war and spend their troops

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Vsavsa

Well, I included the "no resource" part in the idea, because, you know the dudes that play dirty. There could be people who set up clans with second accounts in order to attack themselves for resources. If everyone was fair, then I´d say "double resources in Clan Battles!"

---

You don't think that trophy hunters would do the same thing, and attack for trophies?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TheConfuzed1

You don't think that trophy hunters would do the same thing, and attack for trophies?

---

In fact I do. That's why I specified in the original post that the trophies earned in this battle mode would add up to a different CLAN trophy count special for Clan Battles. I'm sorry I wasn't clear in the original post. INDIVIDUAL TROPHY COUNTS WILL NOT BE AFFECTED. NOR WILL THE MAIN CLAN TROPHY COUNT.
I appreciate the feedback of all of you guys, let's improve and polish the idea, so SuperCell can consider it and implement it!

Keep commenting, I will answer further questions and clarify doubts. THANKS ALL FOR THE ATTENTION TO MY POST!!!

- Vsavsa, Leader of INNER HELL
TH 8, LVL 70

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Vsavsa

In fact I do. That's why I specified in the original post that the trophies earned in this battle mode would add up to a different CLAN trophy count special for Clan Battles. I'm sorry I wasn't clear in the original post. INDIVIDUAL TROPHY COUNTS WILL NOT BE AFFECTED. NOR WILL THE MAIN CLAN TROPHY COUNT.
I appreciate the feedback of all of you guys, let's improve and polish the idea, so SuperCell can consider it and implement it!

Keep commenting, I will answer further questions and clarify doubts. THANKS ALL FOR THE ATTENTION TO MY POST!!!

- Vsavsa, Leader of INNER HELL
TH 8, LVL 70

---

Whether they're individual trophies, or clan trophies, it's too easily manipulated.

Don't get me wrong, I'm in favor of clan wars, but this isn't it.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TheConfuzed1

Whether they're individual trophies, or clan trophies, it's too easily manipulated.

Don't get me wrong, I'm in favor of clan wars, but this isn't it.

---

Ok, I see what you mean, but why not, instead of saying "it's too easily manipulated", do you come up with an idea to solve this, let's make this thread constructive. Everyone is invited to post their ideas here! :)

Well it seems that the voters prefer the Group Attacks, I think this would be extremely fun but it is, sadly, too difficult for Supercell, because it requires completely new gameplay, so let's keep commenting on this thread about how to improve the First Type, the Second Type is practically ruled out, I think.