Builder base sucks. Was a bad idea from jump street......clan games focused on the worst part of the game? Extra sucky. Please don’t do this again
Printable View
Builder base sucks. Was a bad idea from jump street......clan games focused on the worst part of the game? Extra sucky. Please don’t do this again
Participation almost nil in our clan with builder games while others it has been very busy. Don’t like them myself especially just raiding for game challenges and no rewards or loot Defeats the point imoQuote:
Originally Posted by kvkl1234
I also really hope they don't do this again. Hopefully they won't 😌Quote:
Originally Posted by Sabotage777
Supercell please don't ever do this again. This was horrible. No one in my clan even touches that base. We completed the 75k point challenge a few weeks ago in 3 days. We won't even break out of tier 3 in this one.
Also, can you just make two tabs for challenges. One full of BB and the other full of the actual REAL clash of clans base. Having to trash challenges and repeatedly sending emails to remind clanmayes to trash BB challenges before logging out is stupid. Thanks.
Well, I know some have said it before, but it's worth repeating IMO. Builder base should have never been associated with the main base. They should be 2 completely separate stand alone games (like COC and Clash Royale). I understand some people like Builder Base, and that's fine. I just think they should be able to play it to their heart's content as a stand alone game, and not keep it tied to the main base. Just my 2 cents...
UNFAIR to give main village rewards for builder base challenges only#SC
If you want to have builder base challenges only,,that's fine
You can give away builder base rewards and all for those challenges
It's really unfair to have main village rewards for builder base challenges..
builder base challenges only => builder base rewards only
main village challenges only => main village rewards only
Builder base + main village challenges => builder base + main village rewards
simple as that
Quote:
Originally Posted by kvkl1234
Disagree completelyQuote:
Originally Posted by Pianodave
1) The OP has absolutely no idea how many of the CG challenges are completed in the main village vs the builder base. So a claim of 90% is pure nonsense.
2) Non-participation doesn’t effect revenue at all, let alone make it shift downward.
3) If anything, revenue is likely to be up even if only marginally. With loot being available every 8 hrs, but having the same construction times and only 1 builder, everyone that is playing the builder games is likely sitting on max storages. Of course, that doesn’t mean they’ll spend gems to finish construction on things, but it certainly heightens likelihood.
Maybe in the future, they will launch "Builder Hall 9" and so called "The CELEBRATION of the release of" and make another builder juhgkjdfhgkdfbgkfd game. We better make a th6 with bh1 and lets all farm all day without any hassle....
Reducing the points cap and put some additional task in the challenge for only 4 days was obviously desperate moves of SC for us to use the clocktower by using gem all over again and again.
It's a better choice to have TH6 and BH1 since you can 3 star every base.. and army training takes only 1.30 minsQuote:
Originally Posted by Nevera
Been in legends for many months on my main, so bb challenges are all I’ve ever had the opportunity to do. Thus this exact reason for keeping my bb as low in trophies as possible. Makes challenges quick, painless, and so easy.Quote:
Originally Posted by KnowProphet
No... No one is forced to do anything, and if he chooses not to participate, that's between him and his clan.Quote:
Originally Posted by wynnsiensheng
I was simply saying that it isn't impossible to complete the challenge. I'm working on it now on my second account. My first is done.
Grinding only Builder Village challenges is getting way to mind numbing. Need both to keep it fresh.
the most horrible games of all time. never do it again please ...
I hope all the players who defended having more BB challenges in games see why some of us tried to stop it. Integrating the 2 game mode quests has been a problem. For those that said BB quests are easier and you preferred them in clan games over main base....still feel that way?
I feel each clan games should be for both modes. With the quests being separated. 12 main base and 12 BB quests. Then if they want to have a theme event they can double all the quest points for a certain mode, instead of excluding a mode.
I think that’s a good idea and hope they incorporate it sometime. I finally got my 3K points and it was not fun, it was a laborious, tedious chore. This game is supposed to be fun, that’s why I play.Quote:
Originally Posted by ayih
Yes, many of the Bh challenges are very easy and when we have the choice of both types I often choose the Bh challenges. However, this game is much harder for my clan than others. By not also having the easy Th challenges to go along with the easy Bh challenges, it makes sense that it is harder.Quote:
Originally Posted by ayih
The issue is that the bb is tied to main village development. In order to upgrade certain things on the main base - tower and cannon for example - players have to play the bb even though it isnt the game they signed up for.
so this gives me an idea...
I play a game called back alley bridge, and in our circle my brother and I are the rules keepers.
We decided to change the rules that between each card game hand (there are 26 hands in back alley bridge), we have to go outside and play and win a full game of tackle football in order for the hand's winning team points scored to count.
How long do you think before we stop playing back alley bridge?
Most of the quests for both sides are easy. How are BB easier compared to main base quests? Many of the BB quests require a minimum of 3 attacks to complete. Many of those quests are worth 100 or less points. Unless you're a bh2 with only 1 camp, it takes 3-9 minutes of waiting per attack.Quote:
Originally Posted by 2222
The problem with BB quests is the mandatory waiting. You can't snipe your quest objective and move on. You have to wait for an entire army to finish 1st.
In the main base you can make 520 archers and play for as long or short as you want with minimal waiting. You can play for 20 minutes straight and be actively attacking most of that time. In BB you spend a large part of the time just waiting. This type of game play may be fun for some. I prefer to avoid it.
Now those that choose to stay in legends in it's current state don't have the main base luxuries. However those luxuries are their waiting for them if they ever decide to leave legends.
I’ve not opened clash since the builder games started...Quote:
Originally Posted by Pianodave
I like the idea of incentivizing people to do builder challenges by increasing the challenge reward (50% or so might be a good number, such that a 100pt challenge would be worth 150 during the event) while maintaining a balance of builder and main village challenges.
For me, the difference right now is that I’m forcing myself to repeatedly do battles that I normally wouldn’t be doing, while I can do main village challenges within my regular gameplay. Because of this, it’s not much fun but I do it for the clan
Mind numbing boring games. Nerfed challenges. People in my clan normally chat and are enthusiastic with the clan challenges. But for this Yawn.
If SC have another of these I will tell my clan to ignore.
So, after 3 days of the builder games I did a poll of our 40 clan members:
How do you feel about the builder-only games:
A. I like them - 1 vote
B. I feel neutral about them - 0 votes
C. I hate them - 39 votes
Those 39 votes for answer C included a bunch of people (including me) who said they usually enjoy BH but that these BH-only games had sapped all the fun out of the game and turned it into a mind-numbing grind.
Please SC, listen to your community - clearly we're not the outliers in this - and never again foist such insanity on your playing community.
I'm finding these games very tedious, and the clan as a whole is struggling to complete when usually we bash through the tiers rapidly. I would be quite happy never to open my builder base after these clan games... I'm bored with it. I prefer to do a mix of both villages when doing clan games.
Yes, our clan is having trouble with the builder games as well.Quote:
Originally Posted by Chapstick1
I think it may have to do with some players just not doing the Builder Base, period.
It's very time taking builder games, I m not happy with it.
Speaking as a player who normally majors on BB challenges in clan games (I like to stay in high leagues in MV for the loot bonuses, so MV challenges are hard), BB-only games was a really bad idea. I have maxed two accounts for these clan games and it's just mind-numbing, as others have stated.
To complicate the issue, they -reduced- rewards, but kept the thresholds the same.
One hour challenges are OK, but it involves sitting on your phone for 40 minutes+ at a time, which not all players are able to do.
I'm also having a hard time figuring out how they "tiered" the challenges. There is one for 18 stars and one for 20, that IIRC have the same reward but one gives a day and one an hour.
They should have doubled all the rewards or halved the thresholds.
Again, I -like- BB and generally like BB challenges, but this was not well thought out. Our clan will likely tap out at about 40k or less (and we hit 75k for the big games)
I really wanna hear official words from Supercell about the current Clan Games and community feedback.Quote:
Originally Posted by GamingClash3
It's been a time many people complaining (with reason).
Ajax commented here, but as a player like us, not an official position of Supercell.
Community needs to hear it. Don't hide.
I too feel the same way like the huge bulk of community has expressed. #mind_numbing #absent_fun #too_tedious
Is supercell planning to change clan games focused towards builder base like the way main village is focused towards clan wars??? Adding xp points to clan games and making it entirely builder base centered doesn't rule that option out.
At least they could have made it more fun to play and rewarding than it is at current state.
Its monotony is so much so that I don't get points for removing obstacles from my main village when it clearly says Clear 5 obstacles from your main village or builder base.
Conclusion is that please make it more fun and time worthy to play rather than compelling a specific task.
We hate waiting for army to be ready.
Correction: We hate waiting for FULL ARMY to be ready in between successive attacks.
A perfect ending too these games would be a bug or glitch that doesn't allow us to collect the rewards. Sorry to joke around, but thought after the rightfully aired complaints and even those favorable for the games a bit of a change from both could be needed.
The clan XP listed in the first post is not correct. Please update the numbers Darian...
I am certainly not enjoying these games, neither many of my clan members, and still we're sucking it up pushing through them. Hopping on here and complaining like a bunch of spoiled children suddenly having to earn what was once free to them before and arguing who is right or wrong isn't suddenly going to change the course of these current games. Before these games were introduced we had to either gem or wait out the upgrades, Supercell chose to give us hand and by so have to earn them through tasks not forced to do. These games could be a one time deal and they'll return to the regular mixed builders/main village challenges. Some on here I would not want to work with if told too do job they didn't want to do, couldn't handle seeing grown men cry and complain the way some do here on the forum.
It is completely correct.Quote:
Originally Posted by NattensNinjaerJakob
You are probably reading the amount shown for each level as being the cumulative total to that point, when it is in fact the amount you get for that level alone.
Yeah agree with u, it's pointless discussion because people will always had their own opinion. Too many crybaby in this forumQuote:
Originally Posted by M2W
Only thing that annoys me with these games is, as a bh8 I can’t do much of the events. Where a little bh2 can smash a lot of the challenges in no time.
my lvl20 hero takes so long to heal
Not sure if it was SC's intentions to attempt to promote BB as the majority of players I game with do not enjoy it, but it's having an adverse affect in our clan...
... we dislike it even more now.
all we are doing now is laying out our bases in such a way that our defence always loses... that way we drop down in trophies and complete the clan games % and star challenges with ease. I assume this is the opposite of what SC wanted?
unless they just wanted more players playing BB? If this is the case then they have succeeded... for 4 days
i don't think so we are gonna have clan games like 'war on the night side'Quote:
Originally Posted by pranodan
The Builder Games are intended to celebrate the BH8 launch, and just it. It would be terrible if they change CG to only night side.
Regarding the comparison between war on the day side versus builder base
Darian hinted in the latest AMA on the Reedit some 2v2 or 5v5 (?) battles.
Clan Games are another dimension in the coc, that also bring xp for our clans, but are not 'war related'.
If you see in the above mentioned AMA Darian told they were thinking in additional perks beyond level 10 (cute but not outrageous perks).
CGs giving xp permit newer clans grind their level kinda faster than before.
All above my observations and some guessing as well ;)
No doubt. My baby BH3 is ripping up the star challenges.Quote:
Originally Posted by Sparky692006
Darian -
Will you update us on the results of this clan games. We simply didn't do it, there is too much mismatch if you are a BH 5 facing 6's and BH6 facing 7's. No one has the stuff from 8 yet.
I think my biggest complaint is that SC has officially pushed too much.
50k has been 6 days, now 4
200% used to get you 100pts, now it's 250%
800% used to get you 400pts, now it's 300pts
Doing more for the same, doing same for less progress and shorter window, we as a clan decided we are burned out and sat this one out overall. We might get the 15k tier, but probably not, we are tinkering away and some are doing their fair share where they had not gotten as much done on previous wars.
I'm guessing that you will have a lower percentage of participating clans get to the higher tiers and you will have a lower percentage maxing out their points. The 4 days isn't a huge thing because we slayed the last one, we had 25k first day and 35 by second, finished in 4, but it was break neck speed and we decided we wanted our weekend free.
I had been doing about 60-70% main village and the rest on builder hall in previous clan wars. I have only been playing for 15 months and I have multiple bases, that is where I continue to do most of my playing. At least I still make overall progress in the game after hitting 3 times in 8 hours. If I have a couple of hours to spend on the main village, I still make progress to the overall goal of the game, unlike the builder hall.
This is honest feedback and it's my first post, i really believe you will find that less people made progress to certain levels than they ever have before. X number of clans were in this clan games, X% made it to tier 1, tier 2, etc, vs last and previous games. This I hope will show SC the limits, I can't spend my entire life doing this game, it isn't healthy, but as part of a clan, you show up for wars, you show up for events, it is a social thing, like work, where you are part of a team. It's not the only team any of us are involved with in our lives and we have to be able to balance them all. Some people are really trying on this one and I feel bad for not being there with them, but 2 less days and less progress for more work, just can't do it.
Sincerely
Most of our our clan have no interest in the BH game, so we're barely registering points in these games. I'm hoping this is a one time thing for the BH8 release, as well.Quote:
Originally Posted by michelms
I'm also hoping for a longer break between clan games, since I'm finding it a burn out. YMMV.
I believe that this game has lost momentum because of the this Clan Games being Builder base focused. Our clan is not striving towards top tier because we are finding the 1hr chalkenges near on impossible and the tasks incredibly tedious. I really think that we should be seeing all of the new runes and other potions as part of the update in this clan games as well as the different challenges. Hoping that all the new challenges and magic items are shown in the next lot of clan games😀Communication of the game has been better, but decision making still seems questionable!
So. This clan games basically turned into who has the most BH2-3 members in their clan. Please explain why it is rewarded to have a baby BH2 that can easily gain 3k points in two hours or less, where anyone BH7+ in an average trophy range would take a minimum of 12-15 hours of solid gameplay?
I did this event with two BH2 minis and 90% or more of my battles were people doing the exact same thing. Defense/s in corner, and other buildings in other corner. 100% every raid. Rinse and repeat every 90 seconds. Isn't that kind of telling what people think of the BHB?
Not sure I mentioned this yet worst clan games ever!
And yes we will get the top tier (most likely it will be close). What makes it worse I loved the 8hr loot refreshing the first time this time after doing what seems like a week of builder attacks over and over and over I dread the loot bonus now that I’m done with the games
The worst clan games and they will kill the CG if they keep on putting up such impossible tasks
50k points. 1 day 5 hours to go. Immpossible?Quote:
Originally Posted by skele2on
actuallyQuote:
Originally Posted by cocloon
create new th 4 and repair the boat to bh 2 doesn't took much energy and time effort
Our clan finished the games yesterday and I'm so proud of all of those people who decided to do their part and help clan out even though it meant playing something they don't like :)
Silly me, I thought you had to be a th6 to participate in clan games. Did it change so that th4 players can now participate?Quote:
Originally Posted by Alishr99
Please let me know if it has changed so I can recruit a bunch of th4 and save this train wreck of a clan games for my clan.
I’m finding the one hour challenges very tough and too high in number even with people trashing and cleaning the board. I’ve failed about 4 of those tasks just short of getting there on 2 bases, which is very frustrating. The 3 hour tasks (low points ones) are far more doable. I’d like to see added to the mix more lower points tasks that require only 2-3 attacks to complete.
I won't play builderhall for one week. worst clangames ever...
I was lucky getting two clearing obstacle tasks and a lot of percentage destruction tasks which i was able to complete. But it felt like a grind and was boring reaching the 3000 points. Just did it to help my clan out. I really hope that there won't be builderbase only clangames anymore in the future.
I hate clan game with only builder base challenges, it sucks . My entire clan thinks soo too . Such a waste of time it is. Not fair to players who play only main village
Dear Supercell, please consider the 156 pages of negative feed back on your forums against builder-base only challenges, all of the negative replies you've received on Twitter about this clan games, and all of the negative replies you're likely receiving everywhere else about this clan games, and NEVER DO THIS AGAIN. Much love :)
Most of our clan guys don't play BH. This is just a method to blackmail the players to get playing BH, nothing more.Quote:
Originally Posted by Piper139
Awesome games Darian thanks for builder games our score is 56k 😋😋😋
I think the best way to communicate the negative impact of this bb games on my enjoyment of the game is to stop buying any gems for a couple of months. Thinking about this made me realize I spend around $100 a month on this game and perhaps I should stop, or will stop. I work too hard to have my recreation time adversely affected this way, and I certainly won't pay for the privilege. Ultimately, if this is the direction supercell take the game I will almost certainly lose interest and stop. I really don't like clash Royale and I really don't like builder base.
Quote:
Originally Posted by NatsuD
The stats telling SuperCell the actual player participation from the other 173 million players may be more important than the Forums, Reddit and Twitter.
/Affront
Feedback is important too. Stats don’t tell the whole story. A lot of clans are begrudgingly taking part in theses games but hate every minute of it. I think that’s important to feed back to sc.Quote:
Originally Posted by Affront
Going through this once with gritted teeth is one thing but we don’t want sc to get any ideas and make this is regular feature :smirk:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Affront
I agree with affront, and Somewhat fette is not wrong. Very less % of people are Actually in communication of SC. Rest of the players are not or maybe just by help and support. So the monitoring of The data of whole players still Plays a Very and big Important role in taking Decisions of future updates. Like if they find majority of players has weakly participated in CG then they consider this and try to improve. And we all who are in social platforms, and connected via forums/reddit/etc. Help to more precisely and transparently Explain and express their Problems and feedbacks which do help devs to come up more on something better.Quote:
Originally Posted by fette
By the way just imagine if the whole player base is on forums?:smirk:
How many of these players were really happy to do the grind and BH challenges only, the data fail to show in my opinionQuote:
Originally Posted by Affront
excuse me? This game is played for fun, not a salary. Please don’t lose perspective.Quote:
Originally Posted by M2W
as far as I am concerned, these Bh games provide me with a longer break. I don’t play Bh, so whether the events are easy or hard is immaterial to me and I have had a nice break. Well, I say a break, we have run 2 wars, just losing 1 by a star and are in position to win the second. I had 5 accounts in both wars, it’s been fun. Slogging away at Bh, meh, not so much.Quote:
Originally Posted by ChiefTuk
base on how much clan reach Max tiersQuote:
Originally Posted by MasterEdy
happy or not is all about personal
if our clan doesn't happy with builder games
but manage to reach Max tiers by allowing a bunch of bh2
it's not bad at all
(I hates builder games..... but I want those prizes in builder event..... sound funny)
Feedback in the form of "I don't like these Builder Games because I don't like the Builder Base" isn't worth a lot. It's an entirely natural reaction.Quote:
Originally Posted by SamirMishra
The entire player base isn't represented on the forums, not even as a scaled down representation, that's what I'm trying to say with the insanely huge number of players that are really playing.
SuperCell is very data driven, and they don't really change the game THAT much without the data to back it.
I'm sure, that based on the Builder Base participation data from the last games, they knew exactly what they were doing.
By now, the hate for Builder Base is pretty much like the hate surrounding the infamous "december update", when Town Hall sniping was removed from the game and the current shielding system was introduced. It's getting old, fast.
Builder Base is a part of the game now. Clan Games are a part of the game. A specific Clan Game concentrating only on Builder Base, closely following the release of a new Builder Base level is pretty much a given and obvious progression of the Games.
I will admit, that this iteration of the games has taken "Farm with US" a bit longer than usual, but I think that's due to the fact that the Builder Base Challenges are quite hard (the average points per attack is much lower on BB, than on the usual Main Base challenges).
In short, the few hundred really active and the few thousand lurkers on the forum weigh very, very little in our usual banter, compared to the cold hard data from the remaining 173 million players.
/Affront
We have no way of knowing. SuperCell do have the full overview of the actual data.Quote:
Originally Posted by MasterEdy
Besides "happiness" is pretty hard to determine .. some players are happy to grind several billion for their walls, but can't take the DE grind .. At the core of Clash of Clans you'll always find a degree of "grind".
/Affront
Attachment 208840 finally its done ��
So well done on splitting my clan
You obviously have an inflated view of how popular your Builder base is, out of 40 in our clan only 3-4 actually play it full time (i.e. 10%) The rest of us love the main village despite the lack of new content (troops, buildings etc). Is this a deliberate attempt to get people to play BB?? The few that are doing the BB challenges are angry at the ones who don't play it and the ones who don't play it are angry that there are no main village challenges - congratulations, you've made everyone angry!
Having a BB only games is a complete fail, we normally hit the top tier but on these games we'll be lucky to hit tier 5 (30000), BB challenges are good as they are a quick way to get clan games points but making it exclusively BB doesn't work for the people who only play main village. Main village challenges work because they are part of normal game play, BB only doesn't work because the majority do not play BB on a daily basis, only to get some extra points during clan games.
It's just part of a general neglect of the main village, no new troops since the bowler, really?? new town hall has been needed for a while , people clamouring for the giant skeleton to be permanent ignored, constant nerf/buff, clouds, war mismatches, when are you actually going to spend some time & resources improving the game that we all started with and love instead of trying to force us to play a poor copy.
These are points that have been made across the forum but i hope by laying them down in a clear & concise manner, someone with a bit of weight in decision making might take them on board and forward to to SC
BH
Chelsea FC
There's a sticky thread on this forum for input on the Builder Games that are currently being held...
If #SC had spent time on main village content and new th levels,, clan perks rather than spending time on builder hall updates...
trust me,,you will have more active players and new players.
Please arrange a voting system to know how players feel about your bh updates... then you can take a fair decision.
your point being...Quote:
Originally Posted by JusMe
this is a post about the effect on my individual clan
thank you i'll post in that thread as well
What were you thinking supercell???
So well done on splitting my clan
You obviously have an inflated view of how popular your Builder base is, out of 40 in our clan only 3-4 actually play it full time (i.e. 10%) The rest of us love the main village despite the lack of new content (troops, buildings etc). Is this a deliberate attempt to get people to play BB?? The few that are doing the BB challenges are angry at the ones who don't play it and the ones who don't play it are angry that there are no main village challenges - congratulations, you've made everyone angry!
Having a BB only games is a complete fail, we normally hit the top tier but on these games we'll be lucky to hit tier 5 (30000), BB challenges are good as they are a quick way to get clan games points but making it exclusively BB doesn't work for the people who only play main village. Main village challenges work because they are part of normal game play, BB only doesn't work because the majority do not play BB on a daily basis, only to get some extra points during clan games.
It's just part of a general neglect of the main village, no new troops since the bowler, really?? new town hall has been needed for a while , people clamouring for the giant skeleton to be permanent ignored, constant nerf/buff, clouds, war mismatches, when are you actually going to spend some time & resources improving the game that we all started with and love instead of trying to force us to play a poor copy.
These are points that have been made across the forum but i hope by laying them down in a clear & concise manner, someone with a bit of weight in decision making might take them on board and forward to to SC
BH
Chelsea FC
I was simply stating that there is a sticky thread, created by the community manager of SuperCell, about the current games. Quite a few other threads on the subject already have been merged into that thread by the mods.Quote:
Originally Posted by bottomheavy
There is still a good chance that they will move it there. The best place to post and get SC to notice is the ideas and feature request. Chances are it won't get seen here but it might.
I hated these games, I'm SO glad they are over. Over for us. We did finally reach 50K. I don't like BH but I will do what needs to be done for the clan and your clan mates should take the same approach. You losing members is because you didn't. I do understand, I was very tempted to not even try in these games.
I would get my loot for the day then set my defenses on one side of the base and the non-defensive buildings on the other. I dropped a 1000 trophies on my main but I don't care. I'll get it back soon enough. I was getting three stars on all most every attack.
I've been wondering if the economy might have been in trouble from the other clan games. Maybe not. I have several TH8s that are maxed as much as I'm going to max them so I did the challenges on those with dragons. In prior games, of course. Most still had an abundance of elixir but not was much as they usually have. So that thought crossed my mind as a secret motivation for these games. No way for me to know of course.
Again, I hated these games but I did it for the clan. Maybe promote that idea in your clan.
We have only around 10 people in our clan with 40ish bases so it can be done. But, participation is way down on these games.
Quote:
Originally Posted by bottomheavy
Well, then SC should make an in-game poll asking players whether they liked these games or not. Nobody's going to convince me that the data of how many people played these games nor how many (including my clan) reached the 50k tier is going to show the real situation of:Quote:
Originally Posted by Affront
1) how many did it beacuse they wanted the rewards not because they like BH
2) how many did it because they didn't want to let their clannies down (our case)
3) how many would choose MV challenges if given an option to do so
4) how many players did the necessary 50k and won't touch BH again
5) Any combination of above
Data are great, I'm astonished that that many people joined these clan games, but is the data sufficient enough in showing the whole picture? I'm inclined into believing that it hardly does.
Yes it makes sence..I hope next time SC dont add all BB challenges..otherwise forum threads will be full of insults and hate this time..Jst requesting to listen us!!!
the removal of th sniping and the introduction of the current shielding system, is a completely different scenario to that of Bh games.Quote:
Originally Posted by Affront
The former was a necessary change in order to address a serious loot shortage in the game caused by so many players gaining an easy shield and thereby removing themselves from the pool of players available to be attacked.
The latter is an “enhancement” introduced for a reason. We don’t know what that reason is. I doubt very much that the reason is one of celebration. It might be as a gem exercise to generate revenue (fair enough, sc need to make money), or to try to induce more players into Bh, a combination of the two, or something different entirely.
If the reason was to introduce a new version of games so that the majority of the player base can have more fun, I venture to suggest that it hasn’t worked out very well, notwithstanding that only a small percentage of players are members of this forum. Only a few in my clan are forum members, but there isn’t a wide variety of opinion on these games, other than from 3/4 avid Bh players.
You know the next CG will be back to normal. SC don't need to 'listen' to us as this was just a one-off event because of the release of BH8. No need to panic or fret about it. Just ride it out.Quote:
Originally Posted by BishalMarpy0077
My clan was not a fan of builder games however we still will max them out we are stubborn. Not to mention it’s free stuff nobody makes you earn the free stuff you have to decide if it’s worth it to you. I agree that I would prefer not to have builder base only games in the future but if we do I’m sure I will complete the challenge and get even more free stuff. Did I mention it’s free and optional so either step up and collect the goodies or step out and moan that’s your free choice
Yes this clan game did suck but my clan still maxed it out it’s FREE STUFF if you don’t want it don’t play nobody forcing you to. Hopefully these type of games will be rare but if clan members left because of it they were not worth keeping anyway. I told my members do what they can but I was not pushing this games they stepped up and we maxed anyway after all we like FREE STUFF
Quote:
Originally Posted by Justkeeponclashing
Totally agree people debating the use of the word forced..silly really. The people saying we are not forced really don't seem to understand the way in which the word is being used here. But I digress. I did a few challenges to help my clan on my two accounts with this bbclan games. It was incredibly boring and tedious. Please don't repeat these CG SC.. I am prob not gonna touch fail base again for a few weeks after this. Horrible side game with not so fast upgrades anymore.
The challenges this clan games seem to encourage gemming far more than ive seen for ages, it's pretty blatant. What happened to subtlety SC?
5000 points Needed to reach tier 5.
I can gain 3000 points but my friend is refusing to get more 2000, he is Frustrated with how Even destroying 6 buildings task is a heck of time. He eventually faces players who just took whole 3 minutes of battle during CT boost. Not particularly archers spam. And that matchmaking issue is common:rolleyes:
Yes we have done it now 47k running just another 3k needed 😎😎😎
done this games! but now i HATE BH!!!!!!! everyone in my clan hate this CG! EVERYONE HATE!!!!!!! PLZ no more of this
So everyone has this love hate relation with this BH. SC must be doing something good. This game will never die.
We’re on 17k I’m on 90, would have normally had 3k bashes in a day or two...Quote:
Originally Posted by GamingClash3
Removed from sticky... :smirk:
We are at 56k now
Worst clangames so far, it really shows that more than half of the Clash player base don't like to play BB full-time or they just force to play it due to clangames with undevelop BB base.
I see so much hate on the sticky bb clangames thread, I hope this type of clan games will never come around again.
Hypothetical Senario :
Imagine if we only had access to builder base ONLY. No access to main base. How many would actually continue playing the game?
The answer is the reality of BB
Keep silent subham😂😂 we can see faltu Mt bola kr
really disappointed about this BH only challenges for clan games
yupe... that day i will uninstall coc
Can sc please think about having different tabs for bb tasks and main base tasks for future clan games will help a lot. Thanks
Lol @ whoever unstickied this...telling that sc want to avoid more bad pr. Maybe rather think through decisions first before implementing?
That said clan games are an awesome addition, love where the game is going, but yeah builder base games a fail
imo this was harder than any quest or clan game so far, the grind was real.
i scores all 3000, but my clan mates don't have good participation at clan games. we are still in 14 k. is there any international English speaking clan to accept me. i am th11 bk37 aq42 and bb7 so tough, farmer, challenger and so active. Especially, i know where the donate button is....
I disagree. SC has added Builder Base with some reason and they have put an option of playing it or not if you want. Same is with Clan Games. Nobody is forcing you to play it.. YOU are playing it because YOU want the reward. If you are so Anti-BB guy, then probably you shouldn't worry about the CG or the rewards.
They are giving you something for free. Take it or leave it, all yours :) (The people who play BB more than Main base, they required this type of thing. And lemme assure you there is certainly going to be a full Main Village games that you'll enjoy a lot :))
yes you can join us #282JGJL0
Please never ever again, thx.
WE wouldn't care BH clan game if the rewards are for BH only.. we are happy to sitout for 4 days.
I don't understand why #SC gives main village rewards for BH challenges ?
Our clan had a great time this game. 37 out of 42 active members participating. 10 members hit 3k and 3 more are within a stones throw of hitting max. We made it to max tier with pleanty of time to spare......
http://i.imgur.com/vZswTKG.jpg
Nice clan:smirk:Quote:
Originally Posted by Jwp721
Just a small question, has your clan mates finished the Wizard event as well? Coz we are all stuck with these Clan games :facepalm:
The data will show whether there has been an overall drop off in participation, and how big that drop off is. The fact that some clans and some players will have done the games through gritted teeth will of corse have some impact on those figures, but probably not very much.Quote:
Originally Posted by MasterEdy
The number of active players is nothing like the 173 million of course, but I believe it is somewhere between 20 and 50 million. The total number of people who have posted to these forums in the last week, who have a total of more than 5 posts ever (to eliminate spam bots) is 2572.
If we assume around 25 million active players, that means around 0.01% have posted here in the last week (actually rather fewer since posters here include those only interested in Hay Day or Boom Beach).
The data will tell them a lot more about the overall popularity than the forums will.
Which is not to say the forums aren't useful, but it is more for fleshing out the data, showing what people dislike and why, than for dermining whether it is disliked.