Leader need helps from supercell

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Geniosity

this was my original post:
So we probably all know those people who do 1/2 challenges just to get in with rewards while not actually contributing towards the Clan total points.
i think Supercell should also add a threshold so, leechers dont get full rewards, so you have to score a certain amount of points to be eligible for a certain tier reward
Like if clangames go to 30k score, each clanmate can do 3000 points and there are 6 rewards. in order to get the 4th reward c.q. requiring 18k points. he/she should at least have 1/10th of the total required points, 1800 personal score to get this reward.
Though this is just a raw suggestion, i think you guys should really look into it, the only measurement we can take is kicking after clangames, which ofcourse leechers will find yet another clan to suck blood from.

Good enough for you now?

---

As stated before, this forum has another section dedicated to ideas, sugesstions like these and feature requests :)

If this encourage activity I am for this tool.

It is sad to see people playing or active in chat with 50 or something points.

Since rewards are for progression, it does make sense to require active members to participate.

This tool is not only for freeloaders or people who don t take challenges because are not active, but for people who are active but don't participate. The latter is the main issue I think.

It is correct to see people who enter the clan just for taking a challenge or people who take a challenge and then close the app for 3 days to not get rewards, but I think that this tool will encourage participation in clan games for most of clan mates.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Herrjr1979

That's a bit snarky. He obviously means that people that don't pull their weight shouldn't receive the same rewards. While I don't necessarily agree, I certainly understand his point of view and it seems kinda belittling to respond like you did, imho.

---

I wasn't being snarky.

Some people think there is a problem, some don't. He listed the facts, which are the same facts we all have, and which many people do not think give rise to a problem.

He did not say why those facts cause a problem. He didn't say what negative effect those facts have on him or his clan.

He probably does want something along the lines of those who don't do as much shouldn't receive the same rewards, but that would be his proposed solution (if he does want that, he doesn't say so), it doesn't say what the problem is.

The fact that some people get full rewards for little effort while others get the same for more effort is not in itself a problem. What may be a problem is the effect that has on the clan or other members of the clan, and that is what needs to be explained in oreder to work out what (if any) remedial action would be appropriate.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Geniosity

this was my original post:
So we probably all know those people who do 1/2 challenges just to get in with rewards while not actually contributing towards the Clan total points.
i think Supercell should also add a threshold so, leechers dont get full rewards, so you have to score a certain amount of points to be eligible for a certain tier reward
Like if clangames go to 30k score, each clanmate can do 3000 points and there are 6 rewards. in order to get the 4th reward c.q. requiring 18k points. he/she should at least have 1/10th of the total required points, 1800 personal score to get this reward.
Though this is just a raw suggestion, i think you guys should really look into it, the only measurement we can take is kicking after clangames, which ofcourse leechers will find yet another clan to suck blood from.

Good enough for you now?

---

But they do contribute towards the total clan points by doing 1 or 2 challenges. It might not be much in your eyes, but they have contributed. If you missed a tier because someone didn't contribute 100 points, how would you feel then ? Your entire clan would miss out on the rewards in that tier for the sake of having one person score 100 points.

What happens when most of your clan have hit their cap and you need 200 points to get to 18k and there is an hour left ? Who's going to try to get 1800 points in that hour, just so that they unlock that tier for the rest of you and qualify for rewards under your system ? Certainly, no-one is likely to just get those 200 points, knowing that they won't get any rewards for it.

What about real life getting in the way ? What about the fact that the games should be fun and not a chore ? Lastly, what about actually helping those other clanmates of yours who maybe (for one reason or another) cannot contribute much to clan games ?

Oh, and if you don't want to help them progress and make your clan stronger in the process, why are they in your clan in the first place ?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Geniosity

this was my original post:
So we probably all know those people who do 1/2 challenges just to get in with rewards while not actually contributing towards the Clan total points.
i think Supercell should also add a threshold so, leechers dont get full rewards, so you have to score a certain amount of points to be eligible for a certain tier reward
Like if clangames go to 30k score, each clanmate can do 3000 points and there are 6 rewards. in order to get the 4th reward c.q. requiring 18k points. he/she should at least have 1/10th of the total required points, 1800 personal score to get this reward.
Though this is just a raw suggestion, i think you guys should really look into it, the only measurement we can take is kicking after clangames, which ofcourse leechers will find yet another clan to suck blood from.

Good enough for you now?

---

You still haven't said what the actual problem is. You are proposing a solution, but without saying why it is necessary.

What negative effect are the "leechers" having?

there are a number of clan leaders in both this and other similar threads, who have said near the end, they encourage members who have not yet completed a challenge to do so in order to get the rewards. Those leaders clearly don't see the existence of "leechers" as a problem, so you need to define why you do.

I am not saying you are wrong to feel there is a problem, just saying you need to define just what the problem is - it is NOT just the simple existence of players who get full rewards without contributing much.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ajax

You still haven't said what the actual problem is. You are proposing a solution, but without saying why it is necessary.

What negative effect are the "leechers" having?

there are a number of clan leaders in both this and other similar threads, who have said near the end, they encourage members who have not yet completed a challenge to do so in order to get the rewards. Those leaders clearly don't see the existence of "leechers" as a problem, so you need to define why you do.

I am not saying you are wrong to feel there is a problem, just saying you need to define just what the problem is - it is NOT just the simple existence of players who get full rewards without contributing much.

---

the negative effect is that the active members who strive to get that certain reward are unable to obtain enough points for the next tier because half of the clan just sits by and watch while they get free rewards

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Geniosity

the negative effect is that the active members who strive to get that certain reward are unable to obtain enough points for the next tier because half of the clan just sits by and watch while they get free rewards

---

Maybe they have busy lives an are not able to get on much and raid?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Geniosity

the negative effect is that the active members who strive to get that certain reward are unable to obtain enough points for the next tier because half of the clan just sits by and watch while they get free rewards

---

If the leader cannot encourage members to try and do more for the overall betterment of the clan then perhaps it is time to replace those players.

However, imo you should be slow to remove players simply based on CG points. I rarely hit max points because of other things going on in life but there is not a chance I would be kicked from my clan. I contribute more than just points to the clan.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Geniosity

the negative effect is that the active members who strive to get that certain reward are unable to obtain enough points for the next tier because half of the clan just sits by and watch while they get free rewards

---

So how is that worse if those members do 1/2 challenges than if they do none?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ajax

So how is that worse if those members do 1/2 challenges than if they do none?

---

If players are getting rewards only after 1 task than ....its a bad impact on others who earn full points(except few players who are going to say that.....that donot effect them).....as players will think why we work hard if others are getting same rewards at less work......in the end just leader and co are going to burned....