Leader need helps from supercell

Printable View

Show 100 post(s) from this thread on one page

February 24th, 2018
CaptainJackjr

Quote:

Originally Posted by gaz1966

No. Just no. Firstly, the leader is actively enforcing his/her opinion on everyone else. Secondly, what happens if I agree that the minimum should be 500 points, games kick off and I have 400 points and then, because of this dodgy heart that I've got, I'm whisked off to hospital for the rest of the games? My score doesn't count and I get nothing. Or worse, my score does count towards the clan but I still get nothing anyway. Sure, that's totally fair.

Besides, I fail to see any good reason why you should be able force a minimum amount on a player. By all means, set out your expectations through clan mail and chat. Kick the ones that don't meet those expectations if you want to, or at the very least, discuss it with them but don't try and force them into doing something that you want them to do. That's the very opposite of fair.

As a leader, I can't make you upgrade a wizard tower or make you attack in multi-player. I also shouldn't be able to make you score 100 points or whatever in CG before you get a reward. Such an ability would take away a players freedom of choice. Are you sure you would still want to play clash if someone else was able to dictate to you what you had to score and was actually able to enforce that and prevent you from obtaining CG rewards ?

Whichever way I look at it, I can see no positive benefits at all, only negative ones.

I'm against taking away someone's rewards but I'm also against that someone is freeloading in my clan. First I will not stay in clan where nobody respect me in anyways. I wish clan point were transferable in your case. Ok, this is all theory we can add something. Points are transferable if player get kicked before he achieve minimum points. There is always room for improvement.
February 24th, 2018
zaheerr

If tool to set minimum point get introduce into game then I believe no of 50 points will increase to 1000 and it will help a clan a lot.
February 24th, 2018
XtremeGamer234

Quote:

Originally Posted by zaheerr

If I am the leader and I set minimum of 1000 points and then myself couldn't score 1000 point then I DON'T DESERVE TO TAKE REWARDS. Imo 1000 points is not a big deal to score.

It may not be a big deal for you, but it can be a VERY big deal for many others.
February 24th, 2018
CaptainJackjr

Quote:

Originally Posted by XtremeGamer234

Very nicely put, gaz. I was thinking the exact same thing, I just couldn't put it down in words.
After all, it's a player's choice whether to participate in the Games, right?
Hey CaptainJack, what if you were the leader of a clan, and you decided to set a minimum of 500 points or 1000 points after discussing it with your clanmates, and then, you yourself couldn't get that much points, what then?

First, I will not get any rewards
Second,I will simply transfer my leadership. Because I don't deserve it.
Third, meaningless question who don't want rewards?
February 24th, 2018
Piper139

Should this ever be implemented, I foresee many, many threads of people won't join my clan or everyone left because I set the threshold to max. Fine with me if they do give leaders an option, but I don't see it as the magic fix some seem to. It would probably cut down on the hop and go crowd. It might encourage regular members to do more. Or it might encourage them to leave. It will discourage members who can't play a lot for various reasons. The one or two day games are worst for these players. Leaders would need to consider things very carefully to not create more problems than they solve.
February 24th, 2018
zaheerr

Quote:

Originally Posted by XtremeGamer234

It may not be a big deal for you, but it can be a VERY big deal for many others.

Seems you are defending yourself.
I want to ask a question are you a FREELOADER.
February 24th, 2018
gristy

I can just imagine the next batch of threads should some kind of minimum point requirements be introduced..."minimum points destroyed my clan...I set the minimum at x and half of my clan left. I demand SC brings my clan back"
February 24th, 2018
XtremeGamer234

Quote:

Originally Posted by zaheerr

Seems you are defending yourself.
I want to ask a question are you a FREELOADER.

FYI, I'm not a freeloader, my good sir. I'm just saying that if you set minimum points which are not achievable by someone, then he or she will be kicked, I guess, as people have been saying here. But what if he or she was VERY good at war, and yours is a serious war clan?
I'm saying that setting minimum points will be a bit harsh on those who can't get them, as they won't get any rewards, which may help them to progress in the game.
February 24th, 2018
Piper139

Quote:

Originally Posted by zaheerr

Seems you are defending yourself.
I want to ask a question are you a FREELOADER.

He is simply speaking the truth. There are times when real life interferes. There were a couple of players in my clan who did not have the time to complete more than a couple of challenges. We always say that real life comes first. If it were an every game thing and they were not contributing to the clan in other ways, I'd address it through chat or eventually removing them. However, I'm not going to punish my valued clan members for the misdeeds of others. Setting a 1k limit might be good for your clan. Not for mine. I also thinking setting arbitrary limits may cause more problems than it solves. As long as it's up to the clan though, doesn't matter to me.
February 24th, 2018
CaptainJackjr

Quote:

Originally Posted by Piper139

He is simply speaking the truth. There are times when real life interferes. There were a couple of players in my clan who did not have the time to complete more than a couple of challenges. We always say that real life comes first. If it were an every game thing and they were not contributing to the clan in other ways, I'd address it through chat or eventually removing them. However, I'm not going to punish my valued clan members for the misdeeds of others. Setting a 1k limit might be good for your clan. Not for mine. I also thinking setting arbitrary limits may cause more problems than it solves. As long as it's up to the clan though, doesn't matter to me.

When leader know his some clanmates are not able to complete too many challenges set minimum to 50. Even though your leader set minimum 1000 you have freedom to join another clan.

Show 100 post(s) from this thread on one page