Clan vs. Clan Wars

Hello,

Yes yes we have all heard of clan wars being incorporated into the game or not. Some people are for it and some people are against it! Some people mean "clan wars" as in, they want to battle their friends. To specify, I mean one clan vs. another clan. Not attacking your friends or your clan members.

Anyways... I just sent this email to Supercell. I was talking to a lot of people in-game and had a lot of support for the idea, so I decided to send them this:

Quote:

---

"Hello,

I play clash of clans and I'm the leader of a clan. I think it would be really cool if Supercell introduced Clan vs. Clan Wars into Clash of Clans for few simple reasons:

- It would be really fun for players
- It would increase the social aspect of clans
- It would keep users playing the game
- More users playing the game means more gems purchased from Supercell for you guys

From my experience playing the game, some players tend to get bored of farming and waiting to upgrade things, so at around Town Hall 7 or 8 they stop playing as much or quit all together. I think by introducing Clan vs Clan Wars, this wouldn't happen! Players wouldn't get bored and the game would be more fun.

Here are my suggestions for Clan vs Clan Wars in CoC:

Challenging:
The leader of a clan can challenge another clan in a specific trophy range around the clans trophy level. In order for a Clan War to start the leader of one clan must challenge another clan and the opposing clan must accept by the following methods: The leader of the clan accepts the challenge, 10 elders+members accept the challenge, 5 elders accept the challenge.

The War:
For a certain number of days (probably 3 or 5 days would be best) the 2 clans are at War. Players of one clan can attack players in the opposing clan or Find Match as usual and attack players outside the 2 clans. Trophies gained outside of the War will not be counted towards the Wars trophy pool. Gaining trophies for your clan by attacking members of the other clan will go into a pool that lasts as long as the War. The clan with the most trophies at the end of the war, wins.

Rewards:
Resources will be split amongst the top contributors to the war of the winning clan (probably top 15 contributors would be best). The amount of resources awarded depends on the on the trophy range the war was started at.

Thanks for taking the time to read this! Me, and many other players would love to see this in the game. This is also a great way to keep current players interested in the game by introducing a new aspect of competition.

Thank you"

---

These were just some quick ideas I thought up. What do you guys think? Currently in the game you can basically only do 2 things: Farm and upgrade, or trophy push with a clan. I think by introducing this, it brings another cool aspect to the game without interfering with the previous ones.


EDIT:
With respect to challenging, I think the method I mentioned could be exploited by a leader accepting with a clan full of inactive players. I think for accepting a challenge it should be the following:
- The leader of the clan can turn Wars on or off in clan settings. If on, the clan can be challenged to a war by other clans. If off, the clan cannot be challenged to a war.
If Wars are turned on, and the clan is challenged:
- 10 members minimum (if 30% of members is less than 10) have to accept the challenge or 30% of total members must accept
- members than can accept or decline the challenge have to have been in the clan for longer than 10 days


EDIT:
they could make it so you can only attack people in the opposing clan with a TH 2 above yours or 2 below yours (this would make it so higher level clan members are attacking higher level members of the opposing clan and not targeting much lower levels)
Or... Have no limit on who can attack who within the war and if a TH10 attacks a TH4 it's only worth 1 trophy
- I think maybe +/- 2 TH from yours is a good range though and would work better


EDIT:
To deal with feeder clans letting main clans win - You can't go to war with the same clan more than once every 1 month (let's say, or more). Also choosing which clan you want to go to war with could be like the 'Find Match' feature. The clans you will be presented with to challenge is randomly generated, not selected from a list. So you couldn't select your feeder clan unless it came up (which is unlikely). When the leader is looking for a clan to challenge, he/she can see the level of the members in the clan


EDIT:
When challenged by a clan, the members of the clan that was challenged should be able to view the other clan to see what level people are that challenged them before making a decision to accept or decline the challenge

EDIT:
Winning resources we be split amongst all the members of the winning clan that contributed to the wars trophy pool, with a higher % going to the top contributors. Members that didn't contribute to the wars trophy pool will get zero. Contributions to your clans trophy pool includes winning trophies from successful attacks and winning trophies from successful defenses.


Please mention any possible issues or exploits you see with the current idea so we can make more edits

Welcome to the forums! Make sure to search the forums before you post because there is a idea similar to yours just said before you :D If you want to see the top 3 clan wars on the forums that include artwork from photoshop, click the Clan Combo button in my signature... Thanks!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Boblo

Welcome to the forums! Make sure to search the forums before you post because there is a idea similar to yours just said before you :D If you want to see the top 3 clan wars on the forums that include artwork from photoshop, click the Clan Combo button in my signature... Thanks!

---

The idea that was below mine was clan wars within the clan. He was saying he wants to battle friends and stuff. Your post makes me think you didn't even read my original post.

I think all players should get resources but the more you contributed the higher percentage you get so if a player was inactive during the whole war they would get nothing while if a play won half the trophies they'd get half the resources. Also could a TH10 in one clan attack a TH4 in another if the average trophies of the two clans were close to each other?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Balloons

I think all players should get resources but the more you contributed the higher percentage you get so if a player was inactive during the whole war they would get nothing while if a play won half the trophies they'd get half the resources. Also could a TH10 in one clan attack a TH4 in another if the average trophies of the two clans were close to each other?

---

Yeah true, everyone who contributed getting resources makes sense

And for the other part of that.. maybe they could make it so you can only attack people with a TH 2 above yours or 2 below yours.
Or... Have no limit on who can attack who within the war and if a TH10 attacks a TH4 it's only worth 1 trophy

I think maybe +/- 2 TH from yours is a good range though

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Baasonic

The idea that was below mine was clan wars within the clan. He was saying he wants to battle friends and stuff. Your post makes me think you didn't even read my original post.

---

Yes i have and those ideas have been suggested before... i even read it twice now

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Balloons

I think all players should get resources but the more you contributed the higher percentage you get so if a player was inactive during the whole war they would get nothing while if a play won half the trophies they'd get half the resources. Also could a TH10 in one clan attack a TH4 in another if the average trophies of the two clans were close to each other?

---

No there shouldnt even be a recourse reward, this could lead to lots of extra recourse for clingers

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Baasonic

Yeah true, everyone who contributed getting resources makes sense

And for the other part of that.. maybe they could make it so you can only attack people with a TH 2 above yours or 2 below yours.
Or... Have no limit on who can attack who and if a TH10 attacks a TH4 it's only worth 1 trophy

I think maybe +/- 2 TH from yours is a good range though

---

Yeah so what happends if there is a clan with all th 8s and 9s and tens but they attack a clan with only 3s and 43s with 3 th 7s

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Boblo

Yeah so what happends if there is a clan with all th 8s and 9s and tens but they attack a clan with only 3s and 43s with 3 th 7s

---

.....As I said above, the clan can deny the challenge. If your clan is a bunch TH 3 and 4's. It would be a bad idea to accept a challenge from a clan with a bunch of TH 10's

Also the clans must be in the same trophy range to even challenge the other clan to a war

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Baasonic

.....As I said above, the clan can deny the challenge. If your clan is a bunch TH 3 and 4's. It would be a bad idea to accept a challenge from a clan with a bunch of TH 10's

Also the clans must be in the same trophy range to even challenge other clans to a war

---

ok what if the big clan is farming and the little clan is stupid and accepts it?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Boblo

ok what if the big clan is farming and the little clan is stupid and accepts it?

---

Well then that's the little clans fault for accepting isn't it. No problem there

But a TH 10 attacking a member of the opposing clan with TH 4 will get an extremely low amount of trophies towards the wars trophy pool

- or they could make it so you can only attack people in the opposing clan that are +/- 2 TH's from you

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Baasonic

Well then that's the little clans fault for accepting isn't it. No problem there

But a TH 10 attacking a member of the opposing clan with TH 4 will get an extremely low amount of trophies towards the wars trophy pool

---

Alright so how could you stop feeders from just letting their main clans win?