TH sniping should no longer give shields

Why is this thread refusing to die? I will be th9 real soon so I am not terribly afraid of this change. I have a nice base, win plenty of raids and my village is online a whole lot but do you people really not see what this would do to the masses? I guess Ive given to much credit where it wasnt due. The loss of th sniping will hurt so many more than it helps. Sit down and seriously think about how many times a day youll get raided and not shielded. Your losses a day will amount to millions. everyone will then leave builders free to spend what they can. People will start gemming shields constanty. A few people around here need to sit down and really think this one out because its a fail on so many levels... My god man....

This thread won't die because, y'know, TH shielding is cheesey and maybe something should be done about it?

Not saying the OP has the answer, but not saying that the situation now is right either.

Everyone who refuses to lose their risk-free TH shields is afraid of playing the real game.

Yeah, I went there.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by KENdiabolics

If they did that... I would be really really MAD lol

---

I would be very mad too but it can still happen :)

I don't think removing the shield given for destroying a TH should be removed.

I would not be to worried about loosing a higher amount of resources from taking a TH out, as with a 12 hour shield you gain, 216k of elixir and gold (granted you don't break the shield, and have maxed collectors and mines)

I actually keep my TH inside, as I like to test what I have farmed so hard to get, which is why my defence wins have shoot up in the recent months, and for this i will carry on keeping that TH inside, i cant understand low level farmers wanting to keep everything safe, but players TH8 & 9 should be at a point where they would want to test their base.



The only way to coax players into leaving their TH inside would be to reward players on a successful defend, equal to their Loot Bonus.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Golden119

This thread won't die because, y'know, TH shielding is cheesey and maybe something should be done about it?

Not saying the OP has the answer, but not saying that the situation now is right either.

Everyone who refuses to lose their risk-free TH shields is afraid of playing the real game.

Yeah, I went there.

---

Might be an idea to come back from there then.

How on earth is putting your town hall out a risk free shield? You have all the risks you had if you did protect it, just that it is less likely to happen over and over and over again while you aren't logged into the game.

Farming is essential to the majority of players and preferable to many more. If farming is adversely effected like some fools want it to be then the game will die. Mark my words.

Bad Idea. I stopped playing Samurai Siege, a Clash copy, for that exact reason...they way they operate the shield system sucks! Doesnt suit my style of play so I dont play...

If clash did the same the dynamics would alter so much...too much probably. It would be a bad thing imo and offer little benefit to the community or the developers

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Gulyas1

I don't think removing the shield given for destroying a TH should be removed.

I would not be to worried about loosing a higher amount of resources from taking a TH out, as with a 12 hour shield you gain, 216k of elixir and gold (granted you don't break the shield, and have maxed collectors and mines)

I actually keep my TH inside, as I like to test what I have farmed so hard to get, which is why my defence wins have shoot up in the recent months, and for this i will carry on keeping that TH inside, i cant understand low level farmers wanting to keep everything safe, but players TH8 & 9 should be at a point where they would want to test their base.



The only way to coax players into leaving their TH inside would be to reward players on a successful defend, equal to their Loot Bonus.

---

Which in turn would be an enormous influx of resource into the game. I can't see SuperCell being overly enthusiastic about doing that.

If even half of the most vocal forum users ideas were implemented in coc this game would be worse than Festers Quest for the orignal Nintendo. Thank god it takes most of us united to make change to this game. This issue is sorely lacking that kind of support. Post all you want about this. Its going nowhere so go ahead and waste your time.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Growler

Which in turn would be an enormous influx of resource into the game. I can't see SuperCell being overly enthusiastic about doing that.

---

Then half the loot bonus, simple.

Its just a suggestion, rather than completely removing some players, vital protection.

The whole point of farming is leaving your townhall exposed, so people will take that and go. This saves your resources, most of the time, from being stolen. If you don't like it, don't farm <_<.