TH sniping should no longer give shields

how to kill farming by gonfreakss

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bakhoumgeorge

how to kill farming by gonfreakss

---

What the thread should be called ⬆️ Good One haha

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by yesup

This is just plain silly.
Equating leaving TH outside with che@t shielding is totally ABSURD!

Che@t shielding involves colluding with another player(s) to BLOCK ANYONE ATTACKING you with guaranteed outcome.

Leaving TH outside is nothing more than your own base design and strategy - with totally unpredictable outcome while your base is still OPEN TO ANY ATTACKS from normal match making!

Huge Huge difference!

Why is leaving TH outside an exploit? Why should one have to hide TH behind walls? Why should one have to have walls?
Base design is total freedom. You can use walls to paint alphabets to send a message if you want - is that an exploit?

Where is the rule that one has to hide certain buildings behind walls? TH? Storage? Defense?

Some high level players level all their storage outside as a shield - would you call it an exploit?

Some people leave TH outside with level 7 teslas all around it - it's part of the game and part of the strategy. Would you call it an exploit?

Some people would take the outside TH and proceed to attack the storage for a 2 star - would you call it an exploit?

---

I hope now it is clear for all (: thanks

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Sandalhat

Leaving TH outside is an exploit,
Leaving storages outside for free win is an exploit,
Not protecting builder hut to help Union Buster is an exploit,
Not refilling xbow is an exploit,
Not refilling inferno towers is an exploit,
EVERYTHING IS AN EXPLOIT!

---

Spending all gold before logging off is an exploit
queue troops when your camp is full is an exploit
giant-healer combo strategy is an exploit
Funneling with traps is an exploit
and more more more
:D

So I've been hearing a lot of different numbers. 50k 100k that for the majority of players is not cheap, besides the players that are basically maxed.
But the whole reason to do this was so it is fair for all players correct? Well doing that would not make it fair. Now town hall 6 or 7s 8s and lower would have 8 storages 5 storages, more than they do already. Making it much easier for attacker to gain access to one or more of these, making it so much harder to actually get somwere in the game. Because the amount of walls and defenses barely protects what they have currently.

Now that said, I do think putting bonuses on defense wins and gem rewards for completing things might solve this problem. Supercell would have to be very careful on how much per town hall they give because someone could essentially never raid and get all their money from defense.

I also think that making me protect my town hall would have me play a lot less. I love farming, and absolutely hate cup pushing, I hate it because it literally gets me to stressed out. :rolleyes: I think that making me lose 50k would make so many people frustrated and not spend any gems for supercell. I don't lol but I could see others not.

One last sat thing sorry for the long post. So I see lots of loot.... Everywhere besides silver two and three. So clash of clans isn't supposed to just give us all these loot filled bases, if they did it would give me the sense of sattisafication of maxing my town hall 7 and soon town hall 8. People would fly through clash or clans making supercell have to work a lot harder to make new stuff. Working hard gives keeps me more interested in the game and how my base is doing than if there was loot everywhere.
Thnxs for reading, thoughts?:)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by NFactorial

What the thread should be called ⬆️ Good One haha

---

I hope a mod comes here to change the name to that

I don't quite understand how sc would get it to work, how could they distinguish between a th snipe and a simple 1 star by taking the th and not 50%, would they not get a shield either?
sorry if this has already been discussed, didn't get to read whole thread.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by rjaaay

I don't quite understand how sc would get it to work, how could they distinguish between a th snipe and a simple 1 star by taking the th and not 50%, would they not get a shield either?
sorry if this has already been discussed, didn't get to read whole thread.

---

That is one of the most valid reasons why this wouldn't work. Someone can easily just barge into your base with giant healer, take all your resources and your town hall, left at 39% and you wouldn't get a shield?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bakhoumgeorge

how to kill farming by gonfreakss

---

Idk I don't think it would kill farming, people would still purposely lose cups. I would, But it would mess a lot of stuff up

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by KENdiabolics

Idk I don't think it would kill farming, people would still purposely lose cups. I would, But it would mess a lot of stuff up

---

I do this to give myself a big 12 hour shield

I don't like how the game tries to make Town Hall the most important building, and then it's not.
So I'm all up for heavier penalties for losing your TH, gives more variety and challenges.