Printable View
We are a pretty well knit clan. Some has been there for years. I can only conjure up a year or so. If any of my clanmates new or old said that the could only do one Quests because of IRL stuff or whatever I wouldn't even think twice about it. Ofc they can leech. It's all for the benefit of the clan.
I wouldn't wanna be in a clan like yours where it's all about 'me me me'. I'm guessing it's an age thing?
I actually mentioned something like this when they released info for this round of clan games. I suggested you need at least one challenge per reward.
I’m the leader of a clan that has been around since mid 2013 with long standing members.
We are not as active as we used to be although the clan games has woken us up a bit.
I couldn’t care less if someone gets a power potion or 100,000 gold and hasn’t done many challenges as long as we reach a decent tier.
Don’t take things so serious, it’s just a game.
While I certainly can see things on both sides of the argument the main issue I have is the people who jumped in last minute and did 40/50 points after we were well above 30k. If your clan is struggling to hit the highest tier then by all means anything helps and would be appreciated. However when it's obvious that they only put in minimal effort to free load off of everyone else's work I like the idea of limiting their rewards.
That's just my initial take from last round but I can certainly see grey areas, case by case arguments, and alternative routes.
Yeah I 100% agree with you.I also want this idea to be implemented in the clan games or extra reward should be given to those who done more challenges means who are on the top in leaderboard of clan games and that way the leaderboard and different colours of the top 3 and rest below them will make sense.👍✌👌Quote:
Originally Posted by SilverX
Indeed, there are many grey areas as stated by other forumers here, such as busy during this weekend only, whil normally that guy is the toy players of that clan, should he get punished and noy get the rewards things like that.Quote:
Originally Posted by SLEEKYx16
But I do think to certain extent there is a loophole in the current system for people to cheat by freeloading other's effort. There is always gonna have players like that.
As compare to War, this is very different. Where freeloaders will receive much less rewards at the end of war if they did not win 2 war attacks. Even if they can win, they must do it against strong TH11 war base which is harder to do than completing a 40/50 points challenge in Clan Games, and yet receive Books that can instantly finish Hero or Defenses upgrade.
Yes this Clan Games is about helping others. But again, if the rewards is for everyone, why not SC just gives the rewards to all players without any challenges. I saw that this arguement makes more sense than countless threads asking for increasing points cap.
If you want something, work for it, there is no free lunch.
However, I do think giving rewards to top 3 player in Clan Games could be difficult. Because the next question will be raised, what is deciding factor of top 3 players? Then SC has another coming. Of course if there is anything simple and fair, I believe SC will do it.Quote:
Originally Posted by junaidd123
I really get what the OP is saying. I’m in a 15 member clan that only got to level 3 tier rewards as only 4 of us did more than 1 challenge. Most of the others just did 1 when we got to tier 3 to get the rewards. However the rewards are rewards, they aren’t massively game changing and it’s not like we lost a war because half the clan put in no effort. I would have got to my 2000 limit no matter what anyone else did because I actually enjoyed the challenge. What the others do/did would only make something good better. It does show good clan members from bad though.
Were having a clanmember that is having serious trouble in his family right now. He went online to support the clan in the games, since he still felt guilty for letting us down. He really didn't feel like playing clash, but his 'guilt' made him do it.
We told him to take a donation-task and asked for spells, so he simply could push out those spells. We encouraged him to leave, since we were certain we're getting that covered without having a fellow guildmate pushing his limits.
Wouldn't have been able to, if there would've been a minimum requirement for rewards.
Don't ask for even more technical regulations. The only thing we're getting into is less chance to manage it outselves, as humans should be able to.
In future, there might be rewards for getting more tasks done, for getting more points and whatnot. Called archivements.
Something like a 7th tier could work . "7th tier rewards for only clan members that reach 2000 points " so if you grind to max points you get rewarded for that achievement and players that just skirt by don't . There would be a lot less players doing the bare minimum and actually make it easier and less stressful on the rest of the clan to reach the 30 k mark since there would be more going for max points .
Wow man that is an awesome idea.You should make a thread on this idea.Also pm/dm this idea to Darian or any of the staff or mods.Quote:
Originally Posted by BloodyNine