Troop bank - read it or get mashed

Hi guys and gals (If there are any),
I was thinking that you could have a little button on the side of the clan chat underneath the arrow called a "bank"
And in this bank you can take troops that people have donated earlier. You just donate into the bank and then any CHOSEN CLAN MEMBER can come and take the troops

Basically the leader/co-leaders if they ever exist can choose members they find trustworthy and allow them to use the bank. And if youre leaders inactive then it sucks to be you :/

This could help get your donations up because if no-ones online you can donate into the bank and then you receive the donates when someone takes it into their clan castle

And maybe the leader could return troops to the donaters if they were trolling and donating wb's or gobs.

Please leave feedback
Ps. I know its a repost of what i did earlier but whatever :p

THE STATS
Maximum donate limit is 250 per season
Maximum intake is 3x your CC per season (is that fair? tell me what you think)
You can take in as much/little as you want at a time (so if you requested and had 4 troops left you could just take some archers from the bank to fill your CC up)
You can donate as much as possible per go

Idea
(Maybe you could only request as many as you donated or something like that)

Right so that failed...

Amazing Idea!
I Love It!

What's the stats, though? Like how many can you donate at once, what's the donation recharge time, and how many troops can an elder take at once?

-DragonHealers, Out-

Love the idea, add more technical details Ex: how many troops someone can take out, how many put in and add a poll.
This actually has a chance of getting added by SC IMO.

AMAZING!!!!! If I were in supercell and saw this i would freak and hire this guy for this single idea!!! Then I would go and share it with all of my other mods and say this was all my idea!!!

that's an awesome idea.. SUPPORT!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Dorkface0

that's an awesome idea.. SUPPORT!

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Alivebuddy33333

AMAZING!!!!! If I were in supercell and saw this i would freak and hire this guy for this single idea!!! Then I would go and share it with all of my other mods and say this was all my idea!!!

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BenG

Love the idea, add more technical details Ex: how many troops someone can take out, how many put in and add a poll.
This actually has a chance of getting added by SC IMO.

---

OMG guys thanks so much for the support

I was thinking really you could just fill yourself up then maybe a 3 hour wait??
And you can obvs donate as much as you want

PS. Thanks a bunch and PLeAsE CoMMeNT it lets other people see it

Hey guys lets keep this thread alive
And I want YOU to answer your own questions
give me feedback and ideas

At first i thought, terrible. Then I realised this is genius, beside the elder being pointless, this is a really good idea. Everyone should be able to give to the bank though. Like a max of 500 troops a day, if you can be bothered. But you can take troops you gave in, that's ♥♥♥♥♥ing

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by kashmoney

Hi guys and gals (If there are any),
I think you guys'll agree that Elder is kinda pointless and worthless
SO
I was thinking that you could have a little button on the side of the clan chat underneath the arrow called a "bank"
And in this bank you can take troops that people have donated earlier. You just donate into the bank and then any ELDER can come and take the troops

This could help get your donations up because if no-ones online you can donate into the bank and then you receive the donates when someone takes it into their clan castle

And maybe the leader could return troops to the donaters if they were trolling and donating wb's or gobs. Another thing could be donating to yourself DONT HATE ITS JUST A SUGGESTION

Please leave feedback
Ps. I know its a repost of what i did earlier but whatever :p

---

way to complicated and members cant take troops from the bank?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jjs709

way to complicated and members cant take troops from the bank?

---

let me dumb it down for you
Elders donate to the bank
Elders can take from the bank
Is this simple enough?
And eldership is pretty sucky atm so i decided to make it better

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by kashmoney

let me dumb it down for you
Elders donate to the bank
Elders can take from the banks
Is this simple enough?
And eldership is pretty sucky atm so i decided to make it better

---

I think it would work but you have to let members donate and take

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Thom

At first i thought, terrible. Then I realised this is genius, beside the elder being pointless, this is a really good idea. Everyone should be able to give to the bank though. Like a max of 500 troops a day, if you can be bothered. But you can take troops you gave in, that's ♥♥♥♥♥ing

---

Yeah i was thinking that but why would a member donate to the bank if they cant get anything from it...
Donating to yourself REALLY RARELY
Oh maybe if you were top donator 3 times or something you could donate to yourself

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jjs709

I think it would work but you have to let members donate and take

---

Nah man i want it to be exclusive to elders because right now all you can do is invite and that kinda sucks

Please leave feedback

If only elders can take out of it, what's going to make normal members want to donate in the Clan Bank? I certainly wouldn't. If anything, I would donate a whole bunch of Barbs to increase my donation count and my level.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by 966souchou

If only elders can take out of it, what's going to make normal members want to donate in the Clan Bank? I certainly wouldn't. If anything, I would donate a whole bunch of Barbs to increase my donation count and my level.

---

Yeah that's what i thought so there's no point in members donating
And the leader can send troops back to the person who donated them revoking the donate count aswell

Every single person who wanted it could get the "Friend in Need" Achievement which is 250 gems. Then after that they would never donate again.

i like the idea a lot. Should get the logistics figured out but a bank would be perfect.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by waymond

Every single person who wanted it could get the "Friend in Need" Achievement which is 250 gems. Then after that they would never donate again.

---

Unless you are a mean, heartless guy then no AND that wouldn't happen because you'd keep getting kicked out of clans if you didnt donate...

Are you guys liking the numbers?

Please dont bump... Pleasee

I'm sorry, but I don't like it.

I would like to see more ways to interact with clan mates. This is a way for people to interact less.

I'm sorry, but I don't like it.

I would like to see more ways to interact with clan mates. This is a way for people to interact less.


Well its helping people who dont log in regularly to contribute to the clan.

I like the idea, but I think everyone should be allowed to take out troops if they choose too.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jjs709

way to complicated and members cant take troops from the bank?

---

I agree i dont even understand it :(

The idea is a very good one, but there are a couple snags, 1. some clans will take turns(like "inthedark" record clan donations in a season=2 mil something, most for one person 300,000+) that will just use it as exp booster, one of them will donate everything and all the others fill up from it...i dont think this should be too much of a problem, and i dont care but i do think it would get abused in a way like this, 2. it should be open to everyone i think, otherwise everyone will only join a clan where they are made elder, and then it is pointless. 3. then if there is a donation rule to stay in, then lower level players will not be able to make it, since everyone will take the higher level troops.

Those are the only -'s i could see with this idea, i probably missed something big :P

But on the flip side the same things that could be bad could also be good, as u said then people that are online when no one else is dont have to worry(this could help a lot with international clans) also it would give people a better pick as far as what works best for them, and it would be a good way to not get crappy troops...

so all round good idea, but i would change a couple things
1. each person can only put a max of 100 in(to avoid people using it as a way to hide elixer)
2. no one can give to themselfs,
3. the only cool down would be your cc time
4. everyone could use it, but leader( maybe elders too) could control it some how? idk about that one though

What a bumpies,

so this thread was ugly, the idea was greedy for elders

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Streamshot004

What a bumpies,

so this thread was ugly, the idea was greedy for elders

---

Well i was just thinking that it would make elder more valuable rather than greedy

This sounds like a mechanism for self donation to me. Simply donate to the bank and pull the troops out.

Over the idea alot

Why limit donations? Donations are not limited already, and a lot of people would be upset if they were limited. As for how much you can take out, make it as much as your CC can hold! If someone could only take out 5 at a time, and the bank only had archers, would you make them wait to get more? I say this is an excellent idea, just make it so you can give any 5 troops, and take out as many as it takes to fill your CC. Any member should be able to take out of the bank. For donation count, donations should only count if someone takes your troops out of the bank (that way someone cant donate WB's that nobody wants and still get credit for donating).

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Hydrohorns

Why limit donations? Donations are not limited already, and a lot of people would be upset if they were limited. As for how much you can take out, make it as much as your CC can hold! If someone could only take out 5 at a time, and the bank only had archers, would you make them wait to get more? I say this is an excellent idea, just make it so you can give any 5 troops, and take out as many as it takes to fill your CC. Any member should be able to take out of the bank. For donation count, donations should only count if someone takes your troops out of the bank (that way someone cant donate WB's that nobody wants and still get credit for donating).

---

Donating wallbreakers is pointless and expensive and no one does it to get credit for donating. And people would get insane donation numbers if they weren't limited, i mean InTheDark is getting crazy donates anyway, imagine if people didnt have to request

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dahimi

This sounds like a mechanism for self donation to me. Simply donate to the bank and pull the troops out.

---

Except that's not allowed...

OMG Supporting this idea, i really love it. Maybe the leader can choose which troops can be donated so you can avoid the wb's and goblin donation..

Let's hope that the SC teams sees this idea!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jjs709

way to complicated and members cant take troops from the bank?

---

Hey guys this idea is awesome... but wat if an elder selects all the best troops from the bank... lol...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Hydrohorns

Why limit donations? Donations are not limited already, and a lot of people would be upset if they were limited. As for how much you can take out, make it as much as your CC can hold! If someone could only take out 5 at a time, and the bank only had archers, would you make them wait to get more? I say this is an excellent idea, just make it so you can give any 5 troops, and take out as many as it takes to fill your CC. Any member should be able to take out of the bank. For donation count, donations should only count if someone takes your troops out of the bank (that way someone cant donate WB's that nobody wants and still get credit for donating).

---

Hi,
Good question... but others also need an opportunity to donate troops.. so limited donation is good...

Nice idea, it just has to rounded out and adjusted to prevent abuse

This is a good idea, just add some more technical details.

I like the idea of a troop bank a lot, and it would be a fantastic thing to have. Instead of limiting to elder only, though, make it something the clan leader can grant access to with a check mark in the clan member list. Basically, a check mark would mean they were a clan member in good standing and could take troops from the bank. That would eliminate jumpers popping in and taking troops and leaving.

I also agree that the Elder title is a little overused in most clans. Maybe the Devs could devise a third or fourth set of title tiers?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ataraxis

I like the idea of a troop bank a lot, and it would be a fantastic thing to have. Instead of limiting to elder only, though, make it something the clan leader can grant access to with a check mark in the clan member list. Basically, a check mark would mean they were a clan member in good standing and could take troops from the bank. That would eliminate jumpers popping in and taking troops and leaving.

I also agree that the Elder title is a little overused in most clans. Maybe the Devs could devise a third or fourth set of title tiers?

---

Thanks for the feedback and i think this is a great idea

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Dodgers27

This is a good idea, just add some more technical details.

---

I dont really understand could you specify?
Or even give me the details yourself

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rocky810

Hey guys this idea is awesome... but wat if an elder selects all the best troops from the bank... lol...

---

Well i mean thats what youre kinda meant to do

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by gamerof13

Nice idea, it just has to rounded out and adjusted to prevent abuse

---

Again could you specify and even tell me how to improve it

Thanks a bunch everyone

Maybe 50 troops every 24 hours?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by IAmFruitcake

Maybe 50 troops every 24 hours?

---

Or maybe not.
Joking, thanks for the suggestion

Like most ideas this could be abused. You could have 1 account always training wizards, then you just take em. in a private clan of course.

Awesome idea!!!!!! The numbers should be changed, but besides this, i love the idea! I really hope this gets Added. Maybe you could fill your clan castle with these troops every 3 hours, and you could recieve as many as you've given that season (only through the troop bank, not normal request). This is one of the best ideas I've seen.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by vinnyXo

Like most ideas this could be abused. You could have 1 account always training wizards, then you just take em. in a private clan of course.

---

And this is exactly why it should be implemented
FREE WIZARDS FOR ALL FOREVER
YAY
Im sure sc can think of something

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by nathannathan1232

Awesome idea!!!!!! The numbers should be changed, but besides this, i love the idea! I really hope this gets Added. Maybe you could fill your clan castle with these troops every 3 hours, and you could recieve as many as you've given that season (only through the troop bank, not normal request). This is one of the best ideas I've seen.

---

Thanks a bunch
But could you be more specific about how the numbers could be changed

Thanks for all these views guys XD

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by kashmoney

Thanks for all these views guys XD

---

Stop bumping it... especially if you have nothing useful to say...

If it's dead, let it stay dead lol

~ Strider

P.S. Your signature link is broken.

This is a great idea! I think that the bank should be an option when you click on their clan castle though.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jjs709

way to complicated and members cant take troops from the bank?

---

I find this to be a great idea, but what if someone decides to be a troll and uses 10 dragons on a TH 4 for the lulz?

Heya
Great idea here. Something that is absolutely essential.
Here is my proposed working


Every clan has a clan bank. The clan bank start with 100 (4 x 25 CC worth) of troop capacity.
This guild bank has to be purchased with Gold, and all clan members can "donate to it"
So Level 1 could be, lets say, 10 million gold.


Once you have the guild bank...

• CLan Leader can specify the level and type of troops that are allowed to be donated (Eg. Only wizards level 5, or all troops level 5 plus)
• You can specify what rank of clan has access to what troops (eg. Clan Elders get dragons, members get archers)
• To stop one account just making wizards for another account, we could consider adding a max donation per day count. Or not being able to take a particular troop till you've donated x amount.
• As the clan bank increases in levels it could add more capacity, or actually start generating resources for the clan. This can then be rule based divided amongst lets say the top 10 in the clan.

Great idea overall.

I know it's January and all you guys posted replies back in November, but I think this is an AWESOME idea!!! I hate it when literally nobody is on, so I can't donate! I'm also adding some suggestions to the donating problem. So, I'm thinking you can donate 10 troops every 8-10 minutes. I don't know if that is a reasonable amount for the time given, so please reply back! Once again, awesome idea!

-JackAttack

This is me, realizing that there are multiple pages, so not all of you posted replies from November... Lol

-JackAttack

Um wrong sub forum (i think) and I'm not a big fan of the idea

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by kashmoney

Hi guys and gals (If there are any),
I was thinking that you could have a little button on the side of the clan chat underneath the arrow called a "bank"
And in this bank you can take troops that people have donated earlier. You just donate into the bank and then any CHOSEN CLAN MEMBER can come and take the troops

Basically the leader/co-leaders if they ever exist can choose members they find trustworthy and allow them to use the bank. And if youre leaders inactive then it sucks to be you :/

This could help get your donations up because if no-ones online you can donate into the bank and then you receive the donates when someone takes it into their clan castle

And maybe the leader could return troops to the donaters if they were trolling and donating wb's or gobs.

Please leave feedback
Ps. I know its a repost of what i did earlier but whatever :p

THE STATS
Maximum donate limit is 250 per season
Maximum intake is 3x your CC per season (is that fair? tell me what you think)
You can take in as much/little as you want at a time (so if you requested and had 4 troops left you could just take some archers from the bank to fill your CC up)
You can donate as much as possible per go

Idea
(Maybe you could only request as many as you donated or something like that)

---

That intake 3x would be too unfair for ppl like me, I normally donate 300-500 troops a season, I can hold 20 in my cc, so 60 out of that 300-500? Doesn't seem fair, I think the ability to take the amount donated is great :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jacksonian4321

I know it's January and all you guys posted replies back in November, but I think this is an AWESOME idea!!! I hate it when literally nobody is on, so I can't donate! I'm also adding some suggestions to the donating problem. So, I'm thinking you can donate 10 troops every 8-10 minutes. I don't know if that is a reasonable amount for the time given, so please reply back! Once again, awesome idea!

-JackAttack

---

Love that you can give 10 every 8-10 min.

Very good idea
;)

Im all for it! that would mean that no matter what time zone your in your clan could operate in a very easy way. It would help international clans loads! Brill Idea;)

What a cool and refreshing idea. I love it dude! +1 support!

Totally agree support all the way👍👏

This is a awesome idea I really think they should add this instead if the system now
good job

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by arzanp

Heya
Great idea here. Something that is absolutely essential.
Here is my proposed working


Every clan has a clan bank. The clan bank start with 100 (4 x 25 CC worth) of troop capacity.
This guild bank has to be purchased with Gold, and all clan members can "donate to it"
So Level 1 could be, lets say, 10 million gold.


Once you have the guild bank...

• CLan Leader can specify the level and type of troops that are allowed to be donated (Eg. Only wizards level 5, or all troops level 5 plus)
• You can specify what rank of clan has access to what troops (eg. Clan Elders get dragons, members get archers)
• To stop one account just making wizards for another account, we could consider adding a max donation per day count. Or not being able to take a particular troop till you've donated x amount.
• As the clan bank increases in levels it could add more capacity, or actually start generating resources for the clan. This can then be rule based divided amongst lets say the top 10 in the clan.

Great idea overall.

---

But the clan leader could troll and only allow level 6 troops in with a clan of like lvl 40's or something
And I dont want people to pay for this
Im pretty sure your last point wont be allowed by SC but it would be nice
Its only for Elders and above to add more value
Why would you want to stop people giving themselves wizards???? joking
Thanks for the effort you spent

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jacksonian4321

I know it's January and all you guys posted replies back in November, but I think this is an AWESOME idea!!! I hate it when literally nobody is on, so I can't donate! I'm also adding some suggestions to the donating problem. So, I'm thinking you can donate 10 troops every 8-10 minutes. I don't know if that is a reasonable amount for the time given, so please reply back! Once again, awesome idea!

-JackAttack

---

I think just a limit per day or week would be fine because you might be inactive so you donate your whole camp.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kowalski711

That intake 3x would be too unfair for ppl like me, I normally donate 300-500 troops a season, I can hold 20 in my cc, so 60 out of that 300-500? Doesn't seem fair, I think the ability to take the amount donated is great :)

---

Stop crying.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ChiefFirestar

What a cool and refreshing idea. I love it dude! +1 support!

---

Thanks bud

This is the best idea I have eve read! supper cell must now about this! Love the idea keep up the good work!:):):)

Sorry I meant ever and supercell.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SuperMarc

Sorry I meant ever and supercell.

---

And "know"
But thanks for the support
I hope someone from SuperCell reads this
And if it gets implemented then yay

Hey
This is a good idea they should make it included in the next update :D
full support

What if each member had an option of filling their clan castle not to use but for others to come and take? An individual would only be able to keep as many units in their clan castle as they could hold. Another clan member could come in and take 5 troops or their max clan castle capacity.

I like this idea because I could load up my clan castle at night and if anyone needed troops after I went to bed they could at least get a few.

First of all, the chat is already way to complicated for my liking... (i'm kinda still getting used to the new clan wars statistics) But your idea is pretty good because it would get people to donate more. So, I don't think there should be a limit on how many troops you can deposit in this magical bank of yours! Secondly, I think that being able to receive a percent of the troops you gave is a good idea also but it would make it even more complicated...so I vote no on that idea. You should instead have a limited amount, like you suggested, yet your suggested amount was way to generous. i think it should be like... i dont know... maybe around 150-200...

but a great idea on the whole, i give it 7/10 stars!!!