Troop bank - read it or get mashed

Printable View

Show 100 post(s) from this thread on one page

November 21st, 2013
Alex811h

Nice

Over the idea alot
November 21st, 2013
Hydrohorns

Good Idea, BUT

Why limit donations? Donations are not limited already, and a lot of people would be upset if they were limited. As for how much you can take out, make it as much as your CC can hold! If someone could only take out 5 at a time, and the bank only had archers, would you make them wait to get more? I say this is an excellent idea, just make it so you can give any 5 troops, and take out as many as it takes to fill your CC. Any member should be able to take out of the bank. For donation count, donations should only count if someone takes your troops out of the bank (that way someone cant donate WB's that nobody wants and still get credit for donating).
November 22nd, 2013
kashmoney

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hydrohorns

Why limit donations? Donations are not limited already, and a lot of people would be upset if they were limited. As for how much you can take out, make it as much as your CC can hold! If someone could only take out 5 at a time, and the bank only had archers, would you make them wait to get more? I say this is an excellent idea, just make it so you can give any 5 troops, and take out as many as it takes to fill your CC. Any member should be able to take out of the bank. For donation count, donations should only count if someone takes your troops out of the bank (that way someone cant donate WB's that nobody wants and still get credit for donating).

Donating wallbreakers is pointless and expensive and no one does it to get credit for donating. And people would get insane donation numbers if they weren't limited, i mean InTheDark is getting crazy donates anyway, imagine if people didnt have to request

Quote:

Originally Posted by dahimi

This sounds like a mechanism for self donation to me. Simply donate to the bank and pull the troops out.

Except that's not allowed...
November 22nd, 2013
Toxine

OMG Supporting this idea, i really love it. Maybe the leader can choose which troops can be donated so you can avoid the wb's and goblin donation..

Let's hope that the SC teams sees this idea!
November 22nd, 2013
Rocky810

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jjs709

way to complicated and members cant take troops from the bank?

Hey guys this idea is awesome... but wat if an elder selects all the best troops from the bank... lol...
November 23rd, 2013
Rocky810

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hydrohorns

Why limit donations? Donations are not limited already, and a lot of people would be upset if they were limited. As for how much you can take out, make it as much as your CC can hold! If someone could only take out 5 at a time, and the bank only had archers, would you make them wait to get more? I say this is an excellent idea, just make it so you can give any 5 troops, and take out as many as it takes to fill your CC. Any member should be able to take out of the bank. For donation count, donations should only count if someone takes your troops out of the bank (that way someone cant donate WB's that nobody wants and still get credit for donating).

Hi,
Good question... but others also need an opportunity to donate troops.. so limited donation is good...
November 23rd, 2013
gamerof13

Nice idea, it just has to rounded out and adjusted to prevent abuse
November 23rd, 2013
Dodgers27

Nice

This is a good idea, just add some more technical details.
November 23rd, 2013
ataraxis

troop bank sounds great...

I like the idea of a troop bank a lot, and it would be a fantastic thing to have. Instead of limiting to elder only, though, make it something the clan leader can grant access to with a check mark in the clan member list. Basically, a check mark would mean they were a clan member in good standing and could take troops from the bank. That would eliminate jumpers popping in and taking troops and leaving.

I also agree that the Elder title is a little overused in most clans. Maybe the Devs could devise a third or fourth set of title tiers?
November 24th, 2013
kashmoney

Quote:

Originally Posted by ataraxis

I like the idea of a troop bank a lot, and it would be a fantastic thing to have. Instead of limiting to elder only, though, make it something the clan leader can grant access to with a check mark in the clan member list. Basically, a check mark would mean they were a clan member in good standing and could take troops from the bank. That would eliminate jumpers popping in and taking troops and leaving.

I also agree that the Elder title is a little overused in most clans. Maybe the Devs could devise a third or fourth set of title tiers?

Thanks for the feedback and i think this is a great idea

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dodgers27

This is a good idea, just add some more technical details.

I dont really understand could you specify?
Or even give me the details yourself

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rocky810

Hey guys this idea is awesome... but wat if an elder selects all the best troops from the bank... lol...

Well i mean thats what youre kinda meant to do

Quote:

Originally Posted by gamerof13

Nice idea, it just has to rounded out and adjusted to prevent abuse

Again could you specify and even tell me how to improve it

Thanks a bunch everyone

Show 100 post(s) from this thread on one page