Clan Castle Option

Don't you hate when someone accidentally sends you goblins when you requested for archers? Now your clan castle consists of 25 archers and 5 goblins.

Wouldn’t it be nice to have an option to select unwanted clan castle troops and discard them? Instead of having to dump the whole CC in single player mode, and requesting again. I use my CC for defense only, so not having the correct troops is rather annoying at times.

Request times will still be the same, but instead of needing to request another 30 archers; you’ll only need to request for 5 archers to fill your CC.

Hopefully I’m not alone in this. Just thought I’d share my thoughts. :D

I totally agree, I posted a very similar suggestion a few hours ago ;-).

http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...Request-Filter

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Brettsinc

I totally agree, I posted a very similar suggestion a few hours ago ;-).

http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...Request-Filter

---

Great idea...I'll be happy with either option.

Yeah, I actually want this. But what if a troll requests a dragon, and immediately discards it just to make someone waste elixir on a discarded dragon? Maybe, it just won't work with dragons/golems,

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Nonameentered

Im 99 percent sure this is a bad idea but i cant find anything wrong with it so ill suggest it.
so basically some reason a bunch of people hate clan hoppers but for me its to stop accidental troop donations. So basically you can retract troop your donation if someone joins and leaves your clan before he raids. Also to prevent accidental troop donations (Someone donates before he sees the request and donates the wrong troops. So then the person who wants the other troops. If the donater sends a request to remove the troops and the other person accepts than it comes back to the donater.) please comment below explaining why you like or dislike the idea.

---

i started a thread like this a long time ago. It ended up getting up a positive review but supercell had bigger issues at that time. It then got buried very click by people talking about clan wars(before the reformation that made it better.
nice idea :)

What if...

you could request certain troops!

when you click the cc a new window pops up and you could click on 5 barbarians & 25 archers, then that would all that the request would let in.

This is would be cool.

Or or your idea xD

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DonnieDon24

Don't you hate when someone accidentally sends you goblins when you requested for archers? Now your clan castle consists of 25 archers and 5 goblins.

Wouldn’t it be nice to have an option to select unwanted clan castle troops and discard them? Instead of having to dump the whole CC in single player mode, and requesting again. I use my CC for defense only, so not having the correct troops is rather annoying at times.

Request times will still be the same, but instead of needing to request another 30 archers; you’ll only need to request for 5 archers to fill your CC.

Hopefully I’m not alone in this. Just thought I’d share my thoughts. :D

---

I don't think supercell will add this. Let me explain:

*too many lower/higher players will request for pekkas and dragons and low members won't be able to donate. This will make it look like they aren't even donating when they can't because they don't have those troops
*Sometimes people will request for troops that nobody has/uses such as Valkyries and you won't get what you wanted because you requested for something unused. People might rage😡 because they didn't get any troops for defense overnight
* Some elders/leaders might not like that a member requests for pekka only every time and decide to kick them
* The main reason I don't think Supercell will add this is because lower lvl players that barely meet requirements will get kicked for not donating enough because they might have only lvl 4 archers when everyone wants pekkas


I hope you understand why Supercell might not add this from my info. Have a nice day. Nice idea but has downsides

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by CocTactics

I don't think supercell will add this. Let me explain:

*too many lower/higher players will request for pekkas and dragons and low members won't be able to donate. This will make it look like they aren't even donating when they can't because they don't have those troops
*Sometimes people will request for troops that nobody has/uses such as Valkyries and you won't get what you wanted because you requested for something unused. People might rage😡 because they didn't get any troops for defense overnight
* Some elders/leaders might not like that a member requests for pekka only every time and decide to kick them
* The main reason I don't think Supercell will add this is because lower lvl players that barely meet requirements will get kicked for not donating enough because they might have only lvl 4 archers when everyone wants pekkas


I hope you understand why Supercell might not add this from my info. Have a nice day. Nice idea but has downsides

---

My thoughts exactly.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by CocTactics

I don't think supercell will add this. Let me explain:

*too many lower/higher players will request for pekkas and dragons and low members won't be able to donate. This will make it look like they aren't even donating when they can't because they don't have those troops
*Sometimes people will request for troops that nobody has/uses such as Valkyries and you won't get what you wanted because you requested for something unused. People might rage because they didn't get any troops for defense overnight
* Some elders/leaders might not like that a member requests for pekka only every time and decide to kick them
* The main reason I don't think Supercell will add this is because lower lvl players that barely meet requirements will get kicked for not donating enough because they might have only lvl 4 archers when everyone wants pekkas


I hope you understand why Supercell might not add this from my info. Have a nice day. Nice idea but has downsides

---

I think you're getting confused.

My idea was just having an option to "Select and Discard" unwanted troops in your clan castle.

Example: You have unwanted goblin in your CC...Select/Discard and wait to request again.

http://i.imgur.com/rIUa86G.jpg

Easier then having to dump the whole CC in single player mode and requesting again. I just feel like I should have some say on what troops get to stay in my CC. :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DonnieDon24

I think you're getting confused.

My idea was just having an option to "Select and Discard" unwanted troops in your clan castle.

Example: You have unwanted goblin in your CC...Select/Discard and wait to request again.

http://i.imgur.com/rIUa86G.jpg

Easier then having to dump the whole CC in single player mode and requesting again. I just feel like I should have some say on what troops get to stay in my CC. :)

---

This is a great idea! :D

Yeah, I used to be in a clan with a lot of low level guys who just started, so I would get level 1 or 2 wall breakers, goblins, and such that I couldn't get rid of. This would be perfect! But the filter would make it seem like players weren't donating. But that is why some clans put restrictions on, like you have to have level 5 archers to join. So the filter wouldn't affect them if they all had the same troops.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by T0M

What if...

you could request certain troops!

when you click the cc a new window pops up and you could click on 5 barbarians & 25 archers, then that would all that the request would let in.

This is would be cool.

Or or your idea xD

---

It is easier, faster, and wayyy more practical. It prevents you getting troops you don't want in the first place! Done.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by northoford

Yeah, I used to be in a clan with a lot of low level guys who just started, so I would get level 1 or 2 wall breakers, goblins, and such that I couldn't get rid of. This would be perfect! But the filter would make it seem like players weren't donating. But that is why some clans put restrictions on, like you have to have level 5 archers to join. So the filter wouldn't affect them if they all had the same troops.

---

^ Exactly...it is less complicated than the filter, and seems more practical.

I Totally Agree, Supercell Should Add This As A Little Add On. Awesome Idea, And I Definitely Hate That When I Get Goblins......

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DonnieDon24

Don't you hate when someone accidentally sends you goblins when you requested for archers? Now your clan castle consists of 25 archers and 5 goblins.

Wouldn’t it be nice to have an option to select unwanted clan castle troops and discard them? Instead of having to dump the whole CC in single player mode, and requesting again. I use my CC for defense only, so not having the correct troops is rather annoying at times.

Request times will still be the same, but instead of needing to request another 30 archers; you’ll only need to request for 5 archers to fill your CC.

Hopefully I’m not alone in this. Just thought I’d share my thoughts. :D

---

Nice idea I would love for that to happen:cool: