Clash Of Clan Troops!

Hey Clashers!!!

Just had an idea, may be a bad one or a great one, but I need you guys and girls to comment below to see if it would be beneficial or not! :):)

My idea was, if you have ever played Boom Beach, which is another Supercell-made Mobile Game App, you will know that when you fight with your troops, the only ones you lose are the ones that died.

So on Clash of Clans why can't troops just be kept instead of re-training them if they haven't died?

Troops that die = Non-Respawn

Troops that live the war/attack = Respawn and kept until they die

This would mean that elixir would be saved and could be used more on resources, however, like I said, you would still have to use elixir if your troop "Didn't live to see another day".


What are all your thoughts on this?


Happy Clashing

LordSinister22

It's a good idea, but I've seen this idea floating around the web for quite some time. Personally I think it would make a great addition to the game especially for the new guys just starting the game.

Yes, I agree. Low levels need to focus more on upgrading resources than using elixir over and over for troop recruitment. It would also be beneficial to higher levels as well in my own opinion.

I thought I had seen this elsewhere as well, but, nonetheless, the more posts about this idea, the more it may come into play! :)

I've suggested this months ago; just keeping all the troops that survive is too OP, and troops should only stay with you depending on your mortality rates, success, etc.

This idea has been posted here countless times ever since I started self-policing this forum, and the responses are always the same:

It's a bad idea.

Go find the other threads to find out why.

(Sorry for being blunt, but Supercell's complete failure at a new MMA has me in a bad mood)

Can you copy and paste the comments that said it was a bad idea? So far, a couple of people have already agreed it is a good idea. :)

Lord its a old idea with many threads and yup its a bad idea its not needed

Can you explain why it isn't needed?

Good idea. For lower TH you can add this feature for free, and for higher level TH & troops introduce some kind regeneration cost which will make them usable and if you don't regenerate them, then they will die.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rushabhshah999

Good idea. For lower TH you can add this feature for free, and for higher level TH & troops introduce some kind regeneration cost which will make them usable and if you don't regenerate them, then they will die.

---

why is it a good idea for lower town halls? I assume you mean th3,th4,th5 all they need is a few high lev cc troops to have a successful raid in the first place

I suggested it to add sort of a more realistic element to the game. YOU suggested it because you played Boom Beach. This is not Boom Beach this is CLASH OF CLANS.

TheChunkMaster is right, this is not Boom Beach, it is Clash Of Clans...Believe me, I am a Town Hall 5, and some high cc troops don't work all the time...Either the opposition also has cc troops or high level defense....You try being my level and defeating a level 2 Wizard Tower, Level 3 Air Defense, Level 6? Cannons, and Level 6/7? Archer Towers (The big looking ones)....With only level 2 Wizards as my highest available troop, and cc only allowing 15 troops, it ain't easy for us low levels as you may think it is!

Now...My point of this whole thread was just to point out Clash Of Clans should have a feature off Boom Beach, not BE Boom Beach...It would be quite beneficial to lower and higher levels, I have plenty of other ideas for this game, this one was just one of them that came to my mind...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by LordSinister22

TheChunkMaster is right, this is not Boom Beach, it is Clash Of Clans...Believe me, I am a Town Hall 5, and some high cc troops don't work all the time...Either the opposition also has cc troops or high level defense....You try being my level and defeating a level 2 Wizard Tower, Level 3 Air Defense, Level 6? Cannons, and Level 6/7? Archer Towers (The big looking ones)....With only level 2 Wizards as my highest available troop, and cc only allowing 15 troops, it ain't easy for us low levels as you may think it is!

Now...My point of this whole thread was just to point out Clash Of Clans should have a feature off Boom Beach, not BE Boom Beach...It would be quite beneficial to lower and higher levels, I have plenty of other ideas for this game, this one was just one of them that came to my mind...

---

Because I am a Town Hall Lv.5, half of your argument was filler. Good point, though.

What does half of argument is filler mean??

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by LordSinister22

What does half of argument is filler mean??

---

Your first half of the argument was unimportant, especially since TH5 isn't really "low level."

The difference between Boom Beach's troops and Clash of Clans troops all comes down to the resources used. Boom Beach is more realistic, and all of your units are human. You buy them with gold, very much the same as when a military needs pay their military members for their service.

In Clash of Clans, your troops are not recruited, they are built and grown using elixir. You notice that elixir is pumped from the ground, and you also notice that when a troop dies, you see a little poof of elixir. The troops in clash of clans are expendable. For all we know, the villagers don't see your troops as human or natural, they are simply designed in a lab and grown, trained, and conditioned in a barracks. Once the raid is done in Clash of Clans, the troops are just too exhausted and they wither away into the elixir they were created from and soak into the ground.

Unlike Boom Beach, you're able to place any unit anywhere on the map. In Boom Beach you're only limited to spawning troops on the beach. I also noticed that you really need to rely on the gun boat in Boom Beach to aid your troops, as it isn't as deploy and location-oriented as Clash of Clans is. Of course, you have spells, but you understand how both offense systems work. The support system with the gun boat is what makes Boom Beach a tad more realistic, as support and roles in any military situation are important.

Enough with the technicalities, here's a main reason why we aren't able to use the troops that survive in battle:

Troops in the game are strong, and it really isn't uncommon to see a lot of troops still alive after you get that three star. Especially when you're using some mass/spam attack, it's easy to keep troops together and aid them with spells. When you have a lot of troops left, you only need to spend a fraction of what you would for a whole army and would save you a lot of time. If everyone is staying online, it'll be even more difficult to find a match. Especially at TH10-11 in Titans or Legends league if the person gets the 3*. It would slightly decrease the matches you find and would throw offense out of balance.

TH7 mass drag has always been a thing. I always see at least 5-6 dragons still alive on a good attack. Now think about how expensive an entire army of dragons are. If you only need to pay 4/10 or half the amount of a mass dragon army, people would simply be making a lot more profit, even when using an expensive army.

Now look at TH11 dips on TH10's. Most of the time, because of the Grand Wardan, the TH11 just steamrolls the heck out of the TH10 and has so many Bowlers/witches/balloons left. It would be a mess.

These are two different worlds. One with magic, one with technology. In Clash you have troops 'created' from elixir and dark elixir. In Boom you have actual people.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by jaronhudson15

The difference between Boom Beach's troops and Clash of Clans troops all comes down to the resources used. Boom Beach is more realistic, and all of your units are human. You buy them with gold, very much the same as when a military needs pay their military members for their service.

In Clash of Clans, your troops are not recruited, they are built and grown using elixir. You notice that elixir is pumped from the ground, and you also notice that when a troop dies, you see a little poof of elixir. The troops in clash of clans are expendable. For all we know, the villagers don't see your troops as human or natural, they are simply designed in a lab and grown, trained, and conditioned in a barracks. Once the raid is done in Clash of Clans, the troops are just too exhausted and they wither away into the elixir they were created from and soak into the ground.

Unlike Boom Beach, you're able to place any unit anywhere on the map. In Boom Beach you're only limited to spawning troops on the beach. I also noticed that you really need to rely on the gun boat in Boom Beach to aid your troops, as it isn't as deploy and location-oriented as Clash of Clans is. Of course, you have spells, but you understand how both offense systems work. The support system with the gun boat is what makes Boom Beach a tad more realistic, as support and roles in any military situation are important.

Enough with the technicalities, here's a main reason why we aren't able to use the troops that survive in battle:

Troops in the game are strong, and it really isn't uncommon to see a lot of troops still alive after you get that three star. Especially when you're using some mass/spam attack, it's easy to keep troops together and aid them with spells. When you have a lot of troops left, you only need to spend a fraction of what you would for a whole army and would save you a lot of time. If everyone is staying online, it'll be even more difficult to find a match. Especially at TH10-11 in Titans or Legends league if the person gets the 3*. It would slightly decrease the matches you find and would throw offense out of balance.

TH7 mass drag has always been a thing. I always see at least 5-6 dragons still alive on a good attack. Now think about how expensive an entire army of dragons are. If you only need to pay 4/10 or half the amount of a mass dragon army, people would simply be making a lot more profit, even when using an expensive army.

Now look at TH11 dips on TH10's. Most of the time, because of the Grand Wardan, the TH11 just steamrolls the heck out of the TH10 and has so many Bowlers/witches/balloons left. It would be a mess.

These are two different worlds. One with magic, one with technology. In Clash you have troops 'created' from elixir and dark elixir. In Boom you have actual people.

---

Good point. That makes me wonder why we post this troop respawning idea in the first place.

Yep...I cannot fight or argue his point, it would have some kind of "effect" on other players that may be disastrous which I did not obviously consider.