Clash Of Clan Troops!

Hey Clashers!!!

Just had an idea, may be a bad one or a great one, but I need you guys and girls to comment below to see if it would be beneficial or not! :):)

My idea was, if you have ever played Boom Beach, which is another Supercell-made Mobile Game App, you will know that when you fight with your troops, the only ones you lose are the ones that died.

So on Clash of Clans why can't troops just be kept instead of re-training them if they haven't died?

Troops that die = Non-Respawn

Troops that live the war/attack = Respawn and kept until they die

This would mean that elixir would be saved and could be used more on resources, however, like I said, you would still have to use elixir if your troop "Didn't live to see another day".


What are all your thoughts on this?


Happy Clashing

LordSinister22

It's a good idea, but I've seen this idea floating around the web for quite some time. Personally I think it would make a great addition to the game especially for the new guys just starting the game.

Yes, I agree. Low levels need to focus more on upgrading resources than using elixir over and over for troop recruitment. It would also be beneficial to higher levels as well in my own opinion.

I thought I had seen this elsewhere as well, but, nonetheless, the more posts about this idea, the more it may come into play! :)

I've suggested this months ago; just keeping all the troops that survive is too OP, and troops should only stay with you depending on your mortality rates, success, etc.

This idea has been posted here countless times ever since I started self-policing this forum, and the responses are always the same:

It's a bad idea.

Go find the other threads to find out why.

(Sorry for being blunt, but Supercell's complete failure at a new MMA has me in a bad mood)

Can you copy and paste the comments that said it was a bad idea? So far, a couple of people have already agreed it is a good idea. :)

Lord its a old idea with many threads and yup its a bad idea its not needed

Can you explain why it isn't needed?

Good idea. For lower TH you can add this feature for free, and for higher level TH & troops introduce some kind regeneration cost which will make them usable and if you don't regenerate them, then they will die.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rushabhshah999

Good idea. For lower TH you can add this feature for free, and for higher level TH & troops introduce some kind regeneration cost which will make them usable and if you don't regenerate them, then they will die.

---

why is it a good idea for lower town halls? I assume you mean th3,th4,th5 all they need is a few high lev cc troops to have a successful raid in the first place