Leavelock and messages

Hello,

I have a suggestion for the game.

There must be a lock to leave the clan, from the preparation day to the end of the clanwar. It can not be that members of the clan can choose a clanwar and leave the clan 10 minutes before the war begins. Thus the clan has two attacks and the chance for a victory. If this was not possible, it would be sufficient for another member to move up and take his place.

Secondly, I would be pleased if the (vice) leader of a clan is informed as soon as important matters have to be clarified in the Clanchat. For example, when requests are made to join the clan. After all, you're not in the game 24/7, but would like to react as quickly as possible.

Greetings Thomas




Hallo,


ich habe einen Vorschlag für das Spiel.


Es muss eine Sperre zum Verlassen des Clans geben, ab dem Vorbereitungstag bis zum Ende des Clankrieg. Es kann doch nicht sein, dass Mitglieder des Clans sich für einen Clankrieg entscheiden und 10 Minuten vor Kriegsbeginn den Clan verlassen dürfen. Somit fehlen dem Clan zwei Angriffe und die Chance auf einen Sieg. Wenn das nicht möglich sein sollte, dann wäre es auch ausreichend, wenn ein anderes Mitglied nachrücken kann und seinen Platz einnehmen könnte.


Zum zweiten würde ich mich freuen wenn der (vize-) Anführer eines Clans benachrichtigt wird, sobald im Clanchat wichtige Angelegenheiten zu klären sind. Zum Beispiel wenn Anfragen zur Aufnahme in den Clan gestellt werden. Man ist ja schließlich nicht 24/7 im Spiel und würde dennoch gern schnellstmöglich reagieren.


Grüße Thomas

This has been mention a lot and your over looking a key thing if you stop bases from leaving the clan during war will that base be happy and attack or will that base be very annoyed and go out of his/her way to ruin tbe war as they are forced to stay also the other thing your overlooking is lots of bases in war also pop over to their main clan or feeder clan this would effect them as well so its is a really bad idea

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Mrlk

This has been mention a lot and your over looking a key thing if you stop bases from leaving the clan during war will that base be happy and attack or will that base be very annoyed and go out of his/her way to ruin tbe war as they are forced to stay also the other thing your overlooking is lots of bases in war also pop over to their main clan or feeder clan this would effect them as well so its is a really bad idea

---

How exactly does it ruin a war if someone who was going to leave before war starts, uses their attacks, regardless of where their attacks are being used? I do agree with the leaving the clan to get donations part, that could be frustrating... That being said maybe you shouldn't be allowed to get troops from someone outside of your clan for war... Just a thought.

No read what i said i said would the person who is forced to stay in tbe clan be happy at being stuck in the clan i doubt he would so he wouldnt want to help with the war more likely he would try and ruin the war in order to get kicked out as he wants to leave anyway sorry if i wasnt clear on my point earlier

Sorry if I misinterpreted. I see what you are getting at now. I still don't see it as a major issue but I do understand.

Its totally fine sumosloth its my fault for not being clearer on my point

To clarify what Mrlk is saying, you can't force a person to stay in a clan for any reason. That doesn't guarantee I'll use my attacks. In fact, if you don't let me leave, not only will I not use my attacks, I will go as far out of my way as I possibly can to get you to kick me out. If you have to force someone to stay, you're better off letting them leave.

As for the second suggestion, I have CoC notifications turned off. I already get too many of them. I certainly don't want extra notifications for things like join requests. That's a personal preference though, I can understand why a person would want this

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SumoSloth

How exactly does it ruin a war if someone who was going to leave before war starts, uses their attacks, regardless of where their attacks are being used? I do agree with the leaving the clan to get donations part, that could be frustrating... That being said maybe you shouldn't be allowed to get troops from someone outside of your clan for war... Just a thought.

---

This is where the CCs should have two rooms, one for attack, one for defence, and the two CCs completely separate, war map vs home base.

On the war map, preparation day, the war party fills war defence CCs, as currently.
On the war map, war day, the war party fills attack CCs.

Also, the war map camp grounds house the war attack armies.

Everything war is separate from the home base, and only the war party can donate anything on the war map, attack or defence.

maybe I do not understand the course of a clanwar. If someone leaves the clan during the preparation phase, the enemy clan can attack his base in the war? if not it would be my anger for the whole thing in vain, because then the opponent clan would have no more three stars.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Th0M45

maybe I do not understand the course of a clanwar. If someone leaves the clan during the preparation phase, the enemy clan can attack his base in the war? if not it would be my anger for the whole thing in vain, because then the opponent clan would have no more three stars.

---

your warbase will be there till the war ends even if you leave