Clan wars is a bad idea

Everyone wants for the clan wars to happen but I think this is just a premise for attacking a player over and over again. Like what if the top player in that person's clan has like 5million in gold and ur in a clan war with them so u attack said person for 39% damage. Then ur clanmate attacks them. where is the random attacking once clan wars come? This just seems like an excuse to gang up on attacking stronger players. Also, what if the vast majority of the clan has a shield? Then who will u attack? Who would initiate two clans being in a clan war?..obviously two people would have to agree on it but who would have control over that decision?

What I was saying in my thread was to pick a couple people from each clan and let them battle not a whole clan vs another clan

Clan wars have not yet been implemented. It might not be the same as you picture it.

it depends on the game mechanics

no, WE WANT CLAN WARS

even if it MIGHT be different than how i picture it going to be. I still asked a very smart question which nobody replied with an answer to. What if the majority of the clan has a shield? This just hinders a clan vs. clan war. The only way i could see it is if u took the two clans out of the game from other players outside the 2 clans being able to attack you. Seriously though, if u want this to happen post ur ideas of the benefits of this happening and I'll be happy to shoot down ur ideas..

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Champion

even if it MIGHT be different than how i picture it going to be. I still asked a very smart question which nobody replied with an answer to. What if the majority of the clan has a shield? This just hinders a clan vs. clan war. The only way i could see it is if u took the two clans out of the game from other players outside the 2 clans being able to attack you. Seriously though, if u want this to happen post ur ideas of the benefits of this happening and I'll be happy to shoot down ur ideas..

---

I still don't get your 'very smart question'. :p
Because the way I picture clan wars is this battle arena in this thread: http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...s-Battle-Arena
(I pictured it the same way coincidentally. I found this thread only yesterday but I though of the same thing months ago)
That is why, who cares if they have a shield or not? They face-off in an arena where there is no loot.
And I don't care about prizes. Who needs em?
I just want the fun gameplay that is all it's about.

Now hit me with your best shot! ;)

P.S. If they implemented it the way you picture it, they'll probably have to reduce the shield time to 2 hours instead or limit an amount of times a person can attack during clan war period but who knows how they'll make it? :p

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Mipwikefwiends

I still don't get your 'very smart question'. :p
Because the way I picture clan wars is this battle arena in this thread: http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...s-Battle-Arena
(I pictured it the same way coincidentally. I found this thread only yesterday but I though of the same thing months ago)
That is why, who cares if they have a shield or not? They face-off in an arena where there is no loot.
And I don't care about prizes. Who needs em?
I just want the fun gameplay that is all it's about.

Now hit me with your best shot! ;)

---

thats not how i picture it...
This is how:



troop -------troop
.clash :D

joke

a really good clan wars version is in my sig, check it out!

um...why would anyone want to attack one another and get nothing out of it? Oh I know..I just like spending a minimum of twenty minutes training my army of troops cuz hey training troops doesn't take long and whats even better is that I get to attack someone and gain nothing! Some real bright idea there, also I don't need my best shot to shoot down ur idea...yours was just really bad and there was no real thinking behind it but thx for posting.