Printable View
Sorry for my clumsy English.I would like to propose to introduce a ban to join a clan to the players who leave it at will. As it is realized in many games for at least a week, I think this will eradicate the escape of people in the middle of the war, those who change 10 clans in one day will disappear, and just the behavior of people in clans will grow significantly.
Regards Prestor)) 17.082017
Not everyone who leaves a clan is a hopper. In fact, a lot of the time, the reason a person leaves a clan is simply because they don't like it and want to find another one. It's not fair to stop those people from being able to try out another clan just because they didn't like yours
It's dishonest that people open their second self during a clan war. Begin to be disgraceful and quit the clan.
I understand that. But you also shouldn't take people to war who haven't proven themselves to be good for your clan. And if you absolutely must do take them to war, then you have to assume they won't attack, and cover them. It's still not fair to put a blanket rule over a large group of people because a subset of those people leave during war, and an even smaller subset do it to be meanQuote:
Originally Posted by Prestor
i like your idea and can see your point but lots of clans also have feeder clans and bases go back and forth between the two clans which your ban idea would cause problems withQuote:
Originally Posted by Prestor
Don't include new members in war.Quote:
Originally Posted by Prestor
Sorry to say OP, your suggestion will affect others who are simply looking for a clan that they can belong to. Part of this process is joining a clan and finding out whether or not the clan is a good fit for them. If the answer is no then they need to be able to leave the clan and try another one out without having to wait a week.Quote:
Originally Posted by Prestor
When I was looking for a good clan to be in, it took me a number of times joining a clan in a day and sometimes it took me a number of days before I find one. If that process stretches into weeks and months then I probably would have quit the game long ago.
What people here are saying is correct. Do not include new members into war unless you can be sure that they are not going to leave and that you can cover them in case they do leave. There are many people out there who is willing to promise anything just so that they can get maxed level troops from you. However there are also many who are legitimately looking for a good clan. Do not punish the good ones just because you do not like the bad ones.
well, do not have to enter a week-long ban) the ban period must vary according to many factors, 1 - LVL player, 2 - time spent in this clan, and indeed it is time to consider "reports" which are sent on inadequate people.
I read a thread a while back about dealing with this sort of thing. Instead of banning those people, a simple log shows the last three clans a player has been in, how much they donated/received, how many wars they participated in and how many stars they earned. It also would show how long a player stayed in each clan. This would help select players that are better at warring, donating, and staying loyal, and it would also encourage players to stay loyal, for the sole reason that people can see if they are not! Banning players does not fix the problem, it just creates more.
This would destroy people who change between feeder/sister clans.Quote:
Originally Posted by Prestor
You're trying REALLY hard to antagonize people who just don't want to be in your clan. You can't punish those people, it isn't fair. I think you need to go get some perspective for a while. Stop trying to lead a clan for a while and go join a different one. See what it's like trying to be the person looking for a good clan, rather than assume you run a virtual paradiseQuote:
Originally Posted by Prestor
Kinda bad idea. You never know what they're thinking, it's in short words an unfair punishment. And usually its a new person that leaves, don't put him in war.