Mastermind's Daily/Weekly/Monthly Quests Idea (with TONS of pictures!)

Brilliant idea and really well thought out mastermind
Really hope this gets put in the game soon

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DominatorX

...Tanks: Use only Healers, Dragons, and/or PEKKAs to at least 1-Star a base...

---

Perhaps you should rethink that one...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Raneslane

yeah it may be easy for the active clans but not the other clans that are smalls or have inactive members.

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Mastermind

True, just depending on clan size, as a person in a large clan would have access to more troops, therefore requiring more troops needed (not a whole lot more to prevent abuse).

---

Incentive, to make your clan better.

I think this is exactly how quests and challenges should be done. Supercell please listen.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Reid

I think this is exactly how quests and challenges should be done. Supercell please listen.

---

they did listen were all waiting to see if they're going to add it in the next update cause i'm Sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo bored like tobuscus

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Raneslane

they did listen were all waiting to see if they're going to add it in the next update cause i'm Sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo bored like tobuscus

---

LOL you watch tobuscus too!:eek:

Jesus christ, good work!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by LaughingPanda3

Dear MasterMind,
Congratulations On The AMAZING Thread, And Your 700Th Post :)
Panda

---

Thanks LaughingPanda! 700 wow, much appreciated everyone :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TheConfuzed1

Incentive, to make your clan better.

---

Very true Confuzed, this idea would hopefully inspire better clan loyalty, unity, participation, and general activeness. It would make being in a clan more worthwhile, besides the social aspect and just donations. Clan Quests and Donation Quests would add a lot I'd feel like.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by safy1

LOL you watch tobuscus too!:eek:

---

yup he's hilarious and my favorite thing to watch when im bored.

Wow Mastermind just brilliant! Lets hope that 3/3 of your ideas get implemented. Some ideas for quests I have are.....

Trojan: Weekly Quest

Destroy 50 troop capacity of enemy clan castle troops

(Change stats if you want)

Heavens Above: Weekly Quest

Destroy 20 enemy buildings with lightning spells

(Change stats again if you want)

I am strongly hoping that this is added some time soon in the future!

Missed One :o.

Its Cold Outside: Weekly

Freeze 10 Inferno towers (freeze spell)

(stats change if you want)

Oh and the pictures are so good I could visualize it!! (this is now on my bookmarks lol)

one of the best ideas ive read, i hope something anywhere near this gets implemented

Sounds like a good idea to me.

you sir are an absolute genius, and if supercell put this to play, then i think i will officially be hooked
they should seriously consider being able to donate more to your team than just troops, that way it will make stronger team bonds and make it much more interesting... it may also reduce clan hoppers

Are SC considering this idea Mastermind?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by LachlanS

Wow Mastermind just brilliant! Lets hope that 3/3 of your ideas get implemented. Some ideas for quests I have are.....

Trojan: Weekly Quest

Destroy 50 troop capacity of enemy clan castle troops

(Change stats if you want)

Heavens Above: Weekly Quest

Destroy 20 enemy buildings with lightning spells

(Change stats again if you want)

I am strongly hoping that this is added some time soon in the future!

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by LachlanS

Missed One :o.

Its Cold Outside: Weekly

Freeze 10 Inferno towers (freeze spell)

(stats change if you want)

Oh and the pictures are so good I could visualize it!! (this is now on my bookmarks lol)

---

Appreciate it Lachan! Good ideas too! Unfortunately there is literally no room left in the OP for any more words, it's reached the 25,000 character capacity in all 3 posts. Thanks for the suggestions though, wish I could include them!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by jamalriaz

you sir are an absolute genius, and if supercell put this to play, then i think i will officially be hooked
they should seriously consider being able to donate more to your team than just troops, that way it will make stronger team bonds and make it much more interesting... it may also reduce clan hoppers

---

You are too kind my good sir :) As far as donating more, do you mean things like resources or spells? If so, those have actually been ruled out in the sticky since they could be easily abused (more so the resources part). But I like your thinking as far as thinking of ways to reduce hoppers and benefit clan participation, something I love brainstorming about!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ieu99

Are SC considering this idea Mastermind?

---

Yes Ieu, I haven't heard directly from SC in this thread, but have heard through private messages that they really like this idea and it's being highly considered. Jonas the developer even mentioned this idea in a Chief Pat developer interview video. In my opinion, this idea is much safer than Clan Wars for the team to make. Clan Wars, while being something practically everyone wants, could turn out to really benefit the game, but it could hurt it if done incorrectly. This idea (trying to look through unbiased glasses) is very safe and hard to mess up as far as causing people to quit. It's because it adds a lot of new challenges and elements to gameplay, but doesn't change the core of the game. I think SC knows that and like Village Edit Mode, can know that it's a big update (that everyone is begging for) and that everyone would like it (well, mostly everyone lol).

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Mastermind

Appreciate it Lachan! Good ideas too! Unfortunately there is literally no room left in the OP for any more words, it's reached the 25,000 character capacity in all 3 posts. Thanks for the suggestions though, wish I could include them!

Yes Ieu, I haven't heard directly from SC in this thread, but have heard through private messages that they really like this idea and it's being highly considered. Jonas the developer even mentioned this idea in a Chief Pat developer interview video. In my opinion, this idea is much safer than Clan Wars for the team to make. Clan Wars, while being something practically everyone wants, could turn out to really benefit the game, but it could hurt it if done incorrectly. This idea (trying to look through unbiased glasses) is very safe and hard to mess up as far as causing people to quit. It's because it adds a lot of new challenges and elements to gameplay, but doesn't change the core of the game. I think SC knows that and like Village Edit Mode, can know that it's a big update (that everyone is begging for) and that everyone would like it (well, mostly everyone lol).

---

Lol, that's ok I'm just happy you looked at them lol! :o. Good signs for the idea being introduced in the game!

please keep us updated on the status of what is going to happen to it... I want this in the game

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jaykhim

please keep us updated on the status of what is going to happen to it... I want this in the game

---

Will do bud, although I'm not on the team unfortunately and don't know when/if it will come out :(

This is a great idea! Extra achievements when you don't know what to do. This really should be added into the game.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Mastermind

Will do bud, although I'm not on the team unfortunately and don't know when/if it will come out :(

---

Did you contact supercell? If you did let me know what they've told you, I am really curious because we can all clearily see that you've put too much work in it to supercell not implement it.

Incredible thoughts, amazing edits and extraordinary job!

You're very helpful to this community, keep it up and I hope to see you on my channel, I wish you the best! ;)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by FredFlinstone

Did you contact supercell? If you did let me know what they've told you, I am really curious because we can all clearily see that you've put too much work in it to supercell not implement it.

Incredible thoughts, amazing edits and extraordinary job!

You're very helpful to this community, keep it up and I hope to see you on my channel, I wish you the best! ;)

---

I have talked to a member of their staff off and on, who is on these boards often, but that's the extent of it (besides the application I sent in). Thanks and if I hear anything, I'll for sure let you and everyone else know!

This is the best idea I have read on this forum by a ling shot, you deserve gems for coming up with this idea my problem within my own clan is inactive people this would also help with the casual user!

OUTSTANDING WELL DONE!

This my friend is awesome! The way you worked this out is brilliant!
I hope Supercell will read this and add this as soon as possible to the game.
Great work!

This is so awesome, I completely agree that you deserve a huge amount of gems for giving SC such a great idea! I fully support everything on here and think it would be a crime if it wasn't implemented! If SC ignores this, that would be absolutely insane, as this is really really good! SC should hire you to help come up with ideas for the game! I was thinking "This is legit" up till the point where I saw the special witch statue, then I seriously started jumping up and down with excitement, I don't know, it just seemed to actually register with me how awesome this was. I'm going to add my own two cents to this:

Quest rankings--

Whoever (or the top three) completes the most quests is given a special gift, (gems? a decorative statue?) and rankings would be able to be viewed. A player could view his own rank, the rank of any other player by viewing the profile, and the top 200. This would correspond with the seasons system (resets after every 2 weeks).

If you have any other ideas to add to this, please reply, as I think it would be a great addition to this phenomenal idea!

Mastermind is truly a mastermind!

P.S. Supercell please please pleeaaaassssse implement this, I can really vision it in Clash. Mods, please promote this too!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Mastermind

Appreciate it Lachan! Good ideas too! Unfortunately there is literally no room left in the OP for any more words, it's reached the 25,000 character capacity in all 3 posts. Thanks for the suggestions though, wish I could include them!



You are too kind my good sir :) As far as donating more, do you mean things like resources or spells? If so, those have actually been ruled out in the sticky since they could be easily abused (more so the resources part). But I like your thinking as far as thinking of ways to reduce hoppers and benefit clan participation, something I love brainstorming about!



Yes Ieu, I haven't heard directly from SC in this thread, but have heard through private messages that they really like this idea and it's being highly considered. Jonas the developer even mentioned this idea in a Chief Pat developer interview video. In my opinion, this idea is much safer than Clan Wars for the team to make. Clan Wars, while being something practically everyone wants, could turn out to really benefit the game, but it could hurt it if done incorrectly. This idea (trying to look through unbiased glasses) is very safe and hard to mess up as far as causing people to quit. It's because it adds a lot of new challenges and elements to gameplay, but doesn't change the core of the game. I think SC knows that and like Village Edit Mode, can know that it's a big update (that everyone is begging for) and that everyone would like it (well, mostly everyone lol).

---

Excellent, you are up there on my favorite 10 people in the world. Please look for my post on page 73 about rankings! It might be already posted, as I haven't had enough time yet to read all 73 pages :) but the amount of creativity is great! You should do another reply to this post with more stuff you think should be implemented! It's too sad that there's only 25k characters, they are limiting creativity (lol).

I'll be honest, I cant stop reading this idea! I just love it, and I keep getting excited if supercell will implement it. You sir are truly a "Mastermind". Hopefully supercell is looking over this to get this idea implemented:)

Quick! Someone give Mastermind gems!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by RegaliaRemix

HOLD IT!

Yeah I am not a fan of spin the wheel features or any type of gambling either. Thankfully the rewards aren't as game changing/insane like instant full storages or 1k gems but mere pocket change so it's not a big deal.

Also if you think about it, isn't searching for good raids somewhat of a small gamble too? You'll never know what you're gonna get.

EDIT: I retract my previous statement. I didn't read the wheel feature well enough and saw "permanent" collectors..... yeah... I wouldn't approve of that either. It should only be a boost or temporary collectors. Making them permanent gives some "lucky" people and folks who keep paying to get the best rewards an unfair advantage.

---

I understand both of your reasonings, but I think the wheel is a good way to add a bit of chance in the game. People get to do quests and have a long-term reward! But, I think that the luck is a bit unfair, as people wouldn't spin the wheel much. My answer to this is that there would be a system that, if someone spun 10 or so times, they would have to get something great like a resource collector.

Another slight flaw is that if you get something great like a trophy-push feature that you don't need (farming ahem!), that would be wasted. Perhaps a feature where you set your preferences (farming, trophy-hunting) and the wheel shifts the chances more? The shifted chances would only be for temporary bonuses, not to be used as a way to get the extra collectors faster.

I'm sorry if I'm spamming up this thread, I'm reading all these posts, and I feel the need to add so much that could make it even more phenomenal!

There should be an in-game survey about this.

Let keep this at the top for supercell to see

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Mastermind

Thanks Gremlin, appreciate it :)

1. Yes, and it's why I mention the potential problem right after it hehe. I mention the issue that people could leave their clan and join a small clan in the hopes of getting a donation quest (which would be stupid since there are like 50 other quests they could get) but the problem could still be there. One solution could be to average out the clan size from the past week or 2 in determining clan size for the quest. Also, once you get a donation quest, if you left the clan to join a smaller clan, that quest wouldn't change.

2. And yes, it would be pointless if you were maxxed out on Gold, which is why it would be wise to wait to spin the wheel once you have an opening for more gold. Unless you are a high spending gemmer who has maxxed out all your walls (which is .01% of the CoC population), then the gold reward will be useful. IN ADDITION to that, you'd be earning gold for your clan member as well :) And for the .01% who have spent thousands maxing their walls, there are other great potential awards for them, but the thrill of not knowing what you'll get is great in my opinion. Like I mention, unpredictability is a WONDERFUL thing for games.

It's not dissing at all, thanks for pointing out potential concerns and hopefully I explained it better to you! Keep reading and let me know what you think ;)

---

Instead of clan size, how about clan trophy level? It ensures that the right people get the right stuff. Or maybe a hybrid between size and trophy level. See, all these problems are solveable, :). I really appreciate this guide!

Supercell please implement this idea! This must be the best idea ever! I would be so happy to play every day for this! :D

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by amkwong

Supercell please implement this idea! This must be the best idea ever! I would be so happy to play every day for this! :D

---

He's not a genius, he's a Mastermind;)

If you hire Mastermind we will be happy for once.:rolleyes:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by owene

If you hire Mastermind we will be happy for once.:rolleyes:

---

If you're not happy with the game, then why do you play it?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by icebob99

Instead of clan size, how about clan trophy level? It ensures that the right people get the right stuff. Or maybe a hybrid between size and trophy level. See, all these problems are solveable, :). I really appreciate this guide!

---

I would agree with the trophy level but how would that affect all of us farmers?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by LachlanS

I would agree with the trophy level but how would that affect all of us farmers?

---

I'm not a farmer or MasterMind but I think it would make the quests easier. I'm not sure:confused:...you better ask the Mastermind of this whole idea... :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Nellybelly

I'm not a farmer or MasterMind but I think it would make the quests easier. I'm not sure:confused:...you better ask the Mastermind of this whole idea... :)

---

I don't think you can fix this problem without someone giving something up.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by icebob99

This is so awesome, I completely agree that you deserve a huge amount of gems for giving SC such a great idea! I fully support everything on here and think it would be a crime if it wasn't implemented! If SC ignores this, that would be absolutely insane, as this is really really good! SC should hire you to help come up with ideas for the game! I was thinking "This is legit" up till the point where I saw the special witch statue, then I seriously started jumping up and down with excitement, I don't know, it just seemed to actually register with me how awesome this was. I'm going to add my own two cents to this:

Quest rankings--

Whoever (or the top three) completes the most quests is given a special gift, (gems? a decorative statue?) and rankings would be able to be viewed. A player could view his own rank, the rank of any other player by viewing the profile, and the top 200. This would correspond with the seasons system (resets after every 2 weeks).

If you have any other ideas to add to this, please reply, as I think it would be a great addition to this phenomenal idea!

Mastermind is truly a mastermind!

P.S. Supercell please please pleeaaaassssse implement this, I can really vision it in Clash. Mods, please promote this too!

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by icebob99

Excellent, you are up there on my favorite 10 people in the world. Please look for my post on page 73 about rankings! It might be already posted, as I haven't had enough time yet to read all 73 pages :) but the amount of creativity is great! You should do another reply to this post with more stuff you think should be implemented! It's too sad that there's only 25k characters, they are limiting creativity (lol).

---

Thanks so much icebob :) Really means a lot and glad you liked the Witch statue idea!

Good idea with the rankings! I'd love to see more rankings (if the server would allow it) to not only trophies, but gold/elixir, attacks won, defenses won, etc. And Quests could fit in well too! I love stats and rankings and would love to see more :D

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Saltin

I'll be honest, I cant stop reading this idea! I just love it, and I keep getting excited if supercell will implement it. You sir are truly a "Mastermind". Hopefully supercell is looking over this to get this idea implemented:)

Quick! Someone give Mastermind gems!

---

Shucks, you are way too kind ;)

Hey mastermind. Got any ideas coming up?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TheHumiliator

Hey mastermind. Got any ideas coming up?

---

Yep! I'll finish it up after the next update, just waiting to see what SC puts in the update so I don't do the same thing ;)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Nellybelly

I'm not a farmer or MasterMind but I think it would make the quests easier. I'm not sure:confused:...you better ask the Mastermind of this whole idea... :)

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by LachlanS

I don't think you can fix this problem without someone giving something up.

---

Sure, what's the question exactly?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Mastermind

Yep! I'll finish it up after the next update, just waiting to see what SC puts in the update so I don't do the same thing ;)





Sure, what's the question exactly?

---

SCORE!!! BOOYA!!!

Lol, can't wait

This is what the developers should be thinking!!http://i.imgur.com/QtqpwpU.png

I understand that the supercell has a lot of work to do but at least an answer "is a nice idea, congratulations!" Or "you did a good job,good"...but nothing!
The work he did mastermind is in my opinion, VERY GOOD!
done in details, with photos and Detailed information well.
His ideas are great as the "Base Building", I hope that his idea is appreciated by the supercell and is put into the game!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Mastermind

Thanks for bringing it up Lannister,

Rewards are also scaled by Trophy Level, so dropping a bunch of trophies wouldn't necessarily be the best option. While easier to complete specific Quests, the reward would be minimal. I'm sure there would be other incentives in place to prevent people from doing this. Someone could even have a Weekly Quest of gaining trophies or not losing a certain amount of trophies for that week.

I think it's something that would be addressed but wouldn't be a big problem IMO. People wouldn't be staying in low trophy zones to finish Quests, when the loot would be terrible in raids and Quest rewards. The only benefit would be Quest Jewels, which the Wheel Loot Rewards would also take trophies into account.

Good point about donation Quests, and I don't have a problem with someone doing that. But SC could make the 20 minute timer be a hard timer to include the dumping method like you stated.

No it's all good, keep them coming Lann!

---

About getting quest jewels at lower trophy levels, to guard from people exploiting it that way, how about marking each quest jewel with a hidden bit of code that shows which league it was obtained at? Then the Wheel would correspond and shift the chances just a bit according to which leagues the jewels were obtained at.
Just another way to guard against that, there's a solution for every infinitesimal flaw here :).

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by chrisnastybro

I think the effort behind this is amazing, as is the thought put into it.

At first, I was sitting here wondering what quests would actually bring to the game, as everybody is already fully capable of making however much gold, elixer, dark elixer, xp that they need to make, realistically. So, it seems like a lot of busy work for more of the same.

But once I read the wheel part, I understood. I really liked the "clan members recieve small portion of the reward" part, as that's really a good reason to do quests. The whole winning gold/dark/elixer/xp for yourself thing is fairly pointless, but being able to win some for your clanmates, I can dig that.

Obviously, everybody wants more gems, so I can dig that part.

As far as getting another gold mine/elixer collector/dark elixer drill, the dark elixer drill may be pushing it, but I understand you wanting there to be something special in this. The gold mine/elixer collector isn't a big deal to me though.

Getting more troop space/attack time/tougher troops/tougher defenses... That's a slippery slope.

If it's kept non-purchaseable, I don't see these things as a big deal.

If Supercell makes it so these quest points can be purchased?

I think it could kill the game. Can you imagine players with not only maxed bases, but also boosted with 30 more seconds per attack, tougher troops, tougher buildings, extra troop space..

It further widens that gap, so to speak.

I think this may be a bit risky. I think the idea could be implemented, but I don't know about all of the rewards getting the green light. I think focusing more on helping clan mates as opposed to the "gem dominance" style rewards would be better.

---

I fully agree, you should not be able to purchase quest jewels with gems. Gemmers would obviously have an advantage obtaining them though, so SC could let that stand instead of having being able to be purchased.

I read it all and i must say the originality and thought put behind this is astonishing. To those who decided not to read it all i suggest you go back. Although if there was one thing i wouldn't like it would be the balloons carrying the quests. I feel it would change the overall look of the average players base too much. At the moment we have a total green boundary with the sea as well. If there were to be multiple balloons on the bottom of the screen it would alter the look completely. Again that would be a small adjustment i would make. I absolutely love everything about this suggestion except for the look of how the quests are delivered. Fantastic job!;)

would add so much more meaning to go on every day with meaning rather then the 5 minutes of collecting resorces and raiding. The one small thing i saw, and theres a great chance im reading wrong but why would the 50 gem spin info be grayed out intell you get 50 gems? i think having it able to read at any time i better, therefor you know what these gems do.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jaden99

Mastermind,

You just hit the key point why I was about to quit. It gets kind of boring having to wait 12 hours for my troops and buildings to finish. I like everything about the idea except one thing. Supercell ruled out the idea of sharing resources so if you win
the wheel of riches it shouldn't give your clan mates resources.

Other then that I love the idea.

---

If they did rule out that idea, then there should be no quest jewels on the Wheel. The clan wouldn't receive any, and it would therefore be a waste of quest jewels. However, I think the sharing should be in place, it would really give clans a huge boost.

Great idea, would love this in the game.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jazzathegreat

This is what the developers should be thinking!!http://i.imgur.com/QtqpwpU.png

---

Hahahaha I love this, it is great, thanks :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by icebob99

About getting quest jewels at lower trophy levels, to guard from people exploiting it that way, how about marking each quest jewel with a hidden bit of code that shows which league it was obtained at? Then the Wheel would correspond and shift the chances just a bit according to which leagues the jewels were obtained at.
Just another way to guard against that, there's a solution for every infinitesimal flaw here :).

---

Good idea Bob! I'm not sure how difficult this would be to implement, but great solution! That would prevent people from gaining a lot of trophies before they spin the Wheel for a higher reward. Or simply... the values on the Wheel could only be for just TH level and not trophy level.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by icebob99

I fully agree, you should not be able to purchase quest jewels with gems. Gemmers would obviously have an advantage obtaining them though, so SC could let that stand instead of having being able to be purchased.

---

I don't think they should be able to be purchased, however... I wouldn't knock on SC for making them purchasable. If they did though, there would definitely need to be a cap on the number of times the wheel could be spun, at around once every 2-3 weeks in my opinion.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Brownsugar10

I read it all and i must say the originality and thought put behind this is astonishing. To those who decided not to read it all i suggest you go back. Although if there was one thing i wouldn't like it would be the balloons carrying the quests. I feel it would change the overall look of the average players base too much. At the moment we have a total green boundary with the sea as well. If there were to be multiple balloons on the bottom of the screen it would alter the look completely. Again that would be a small adjustment i would make. I absolutely love everything about this suggestion except for the look of how the quests are delivered. Fantastic job!;)

---

Really appreciate it Brown! Thanks for the kind words :) And I agree with your statement of the balloons being distracting. The way I made it could easily be changed and not effect the core idea. Whether the ballons were smaller, changed into goblins that congregated in a hut (that could be bought with Gems almost as an expansion pack for SC, as a poster mentioned), or honestly any way would be fine with me.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by icebob99

If they did rule out that idea, then there should be no quest jewels on the Wheel. The clan wouldn't receive any, and it would therefore be a waste of quest jewels. However, I think the sharing should be in place, it would really give clans a huge boost.

---

They ruled out donating resources, which I agree with. However, the idea I made for the wheel of winning resources for your clan mates (a small amount and not very often) is not ruled out. I really like the idea and if this idea was implemented the way I have it, I would really want this feature to stay! I believe it would add a lot to clan participation, quest participation, and clan unity if you could win resources for your clan.

Very detailed and informative! This whole game presentation would add a real spark back to this game as it is becoming a bit dull. I've been playing this game since day 1. Now it's getting a wee bit dull. Your idea is spot on! I really like the detailed breakdown of what each individual player has accomplished. Also the long awaited and overdue private message function.

Hahahahaha!

Supercell, you have 76 pages of your players loving this idea. Mastermind has planned EVERYTHING out for you, so I really don't see why this hasn't been implemented! C'mon SC, this is the PERFECT way to add another dimension to this game. Nice work Mastermind, keep it up!

Another great idea. Good work. Mastermind you're such a genius. You should work for supercell

Still Love it, Supercell, give mastermind a job :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Mastermind

Yep! I'll finish it up after the next update, just waiting to see what SC puts in the update so I don't do the same thing ;)





Sure, what's the question exactly?

---

The amount of a prize you get from spinning the wheel. Someone said it should be trophy lvl but i said what about us farmers and so on..

Thank you everyone on this page for the nice comments! :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by LachlanS

The amount of a prize you get from spinning the wheel. Someone said it should be trophy lvl but i said what about us farmers and so on..

---

Appreciate the clarification Lachan. For the actual Quest rewards in general (not wheel rewards) I think it should be a combination of TH level and trophy level. I think encouraging trophy level is a good thing in the game and the reason there are farmers is because the loot is so much better as a farmer (and it's easier as a farmer, which I am one). Small bonuses from leagues and quests would help promote trying to move up on the trophy lists (which is something that SC would want, as those are usually the people who by gems more often).

The wheel rewards are a bit more tricky. If it were based on trophies (in addition to the default TH level) and having higher trophies meant higher level of rewards, then people could be low trophies to farm Quest Jewels easier (although at the sacrifice of better individual Quest rewards) and then trophy push right before they spin the wheel. To prevent this abuse, a poster recently (could have even been you or ice, forgot who) made a suggestion to put a small line of code in each completed Quest to let the system know what trophy level the player was at when each Quest was performed and completed, and then average it out to give an appropriate and fair value for the wheel rewards. This would be the most fair, but complicated solution (not sure how difficult it would be to program that).

The most simple solution would be to make only TH level affect wheel rewards and not trophy level to prevent abuse. Although I think it would be more difficult for high trophy pushers to complete quests, therefore they deserve a higher end reward. At the same time however, the choice is with the player: try to trophy push and get higher league rewards, get higher Quest rewards vs being a farmer with better loot per raid and possibly an easier time getting to the wheel. Games with choices are games that stay, I have found. CoC already let's the player choose, and this would add a new dimension and wrinkle to that choice.

I've been inactive for quite awhile and I'm just coming back to the game so i just saw this now. I can only say one thing: THIS IS FREAKING AWESOME. I think some of the rewards should be adjusted, especially the loot based ones (i personally think they are too small) but as you said they could be changed by SC at will. Your ideas are always awesome, but this one just blew everything away. Good job man.



~M

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Mufasa

I've been inactive for quite awhile and I'm just coming back to the game so i just saw this now. I can only say one thing: THIS IS FREAKING AWESOME. I think some of the rewards should be adjusted, especially the loot based ones (i personally think they are too small) but as you said they could be changed by SC at will. Your ideas are always awesome, but this one just blew everything away. Good job man.



~M

---

Appreciate it Mufasa and welcome back! I remember your posts in my base builder thread I believe :) Yeah the loot could definitely be adjusted to be fair yet rewarding and scale based on TH, trophies, and other factors in my opinion. Thanks for the kind words!

wow, is all i can say to this, i just finished reading. This is by far the greatest idea on the forums and i have read basicly them all. please Supercell, steal this idea and implement it. This is amazing.

Just finished reading, and I really like this idea, but SC should raise the amount of gems for the reward, 5 gems is not even enough to boost a low gold mine, let alone help out even a little with tasks.

yes this idea is very good! More player and more fun!!!
;););););)








------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G-4XV3TNt8M

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jackwillclash

Just finished reading, and I really like this idea, but SC should raise the amount of gems for the reward, 5 gems is not even enough to boost a low gold mine, let alone help out even a little with tasks.

---

Thanks Jack! I think 5 gems is appropriate for a Daily Reward for a TH8 low trophy farmer (as in th example). If the person was say TH8 and in Crystal 1-2 then I'd say the reward could go to more around 7-8. I really think trophy level should affect rewards in a very good way. Remember, there are Weekly and Monthly Rewards which would need to scale with Daily Rewards, so the higher the Daily Reward, the higher the others and I'm not sure SC would want to give away a lot of free gems. I'd be all for getting more free gems (besides obstacles and the rare achievement) but there could be 5 Quests done a day, every day, with Weeklies and Monthlies, so it would have to be balanced.

But I'd be all for more if they did it. Just stating as a business decision, I don't think they would go higher.

This is the best idea on the forums it is logical and does not really seem to have any possibility of abuse. Further and most importantly it would add another fascinating aspect to coc which would be great. SC this is gold get around it. Well done mate ripper of an idea.

Took me a while to read the whole post but it is soo awesome. And you u put a lot of effort in your work. Keep up the good work!

I love this idea. Its a great way to keep vetern players interested and could draw more people in as it makes the game very diverse

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TheCMan

This is the best idea on the forums it is logical and does not really seem to have any possibility of abuse. Further and most importantly it would add another fascinating aspect to coc which would be great. SC this is gold get around it. Well done mate ripper of an idea.

---

Thanks CMan and if anyone found a way this could be abused, please share! By the way, love the quote "ripper of an idea"! ;)

I love this idea, but I dont think SC has commented yet...it useually means they dont like it..but im not sure.

This is brilliant, if supercell uses this, it can take them to the next level

Best Idea I've come across in this forum.
+1 from me too :)

The gem percentage should be lower because think 5% in one but u do 5 a day u get 25% chance of it occurring in each week meaning the quantity of gems that would be inserted into the game would be very large so maybe reduce the number but i love the overall idea

Would love to see this happen! Full support over here! It would make the game much more interesting and active, particularly at higher levels where things tend to slow down.

keep up the good work and I'll give u all the great quotes you want mate. Can't believe SC hasn't commented on this cracker idea. It's just waiting to be put in. Come on lads get ur act together haha.

lets do this!!!

Bump!!!!!!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TheCMan

keep up the good work and I'll give u all the great quotes you want mate. Can't believe SC hasn't commented on this cracker idea. It's just waiting to be put in. Come on lads get ur act together haha.

---

They've commented--Not directly in this thread, but yes, they've commented, and they said they like it. That's not the same as saying they'll put it in the game, but we'll see.

Why hasn't SC tracked you down and given you a job!! great ideas man, keep it up! this and Saltin clan wars concept would change the game completely! i would pay for a game with all these ideas!!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bfoz

The gem percentage should be lower because think 5% in one but u do 5 a day u get 25% chance of it occurring in each week meaning the quantity of gems that would be inserted into the game would be very large so maybe reduce the number but i love the overall idea

---

True Bfoz, but that just means 25% each day (if all 5 Quests were done) of receiving just 5 gems. Hardly game-breaking in my opinion. You can currently get that from 2 obstacles, with a max of 9 a day (from newly spawned obstacles).

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TheCMan

keep up the good work and I'll give u all the great quotes you want mate. Can't believe SC hasn't commented on this cracker idea. It's just waiting to be put in. Come on lads get ur act together haha.

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TheConfuzed1

They've commented--Not directly in this thread, but yes, they've commented, and they said they like it. That's not the same as saying they'll put it in the game, but we'll see.

---

Great CMan, glad to have ya on board! And thanks :) Like Confuzed stated, they have comented to me (well a community manager said the team really liked it) as well as a developer in Cief Pat's video confirming the team has seen it. Unfortunately no direct posts in here (unlike the other 2 threads) but it is what it is!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by andyparsons1412

Why hasn't SC tracked you down and given you a job!! great ideas man, keep it up! this and Saltin clan wars concept would change the game completely! i would pay for a game with all these ideas!!

---

Thanks andy, really means a lot! How great would that be? :)

I couldnt find anything in the thread about it... Maybe i cant see.. But have you heard anything from sc about this awesome idea?

Great CMan, glad to have ya on board! And thanks :) Like Confuzed stated, they have comented to me (well a community manager said the team really liked it) as well as a developer in Cief Pat's video confirming the team has seen it. Unfortunately no direct posts in here (unlike the other 2 threads)

this is great to hear would love to see this happen think it would be great for the game.

this is exactly what is needed to bring life to the game :)

U are awesome my man !! well illustrated... :o

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Dannyperpon

I couldnt find anything in the thread about it... Maybe i cant see.. But have you heard anything from sc about this awesome idea?

---

Hey Danny, sorry forgot to write back. To answer your question there hasn't been anything from them in this thread unlike the other threads, but I did hear from a staff member in a PM that the team really likes the idea :)

Great idea!

Can imagine the amount of effort you put your thought into this..

Hope this comes true soon enough!

Ok. I have a question. If I spin the wheel and land on DE, what if my clanmates don't have DE storages?

This is amazing. I think that this may be one of the best ideas I've ever read on this forum. This fixes many of the common requests you see! (boredom, mini games, something different, extra $, etc...) If implemented it would give that spark that clash of clans needs in order to bring it to the next level. It would hook me even more, and get many worn out clashers back to the game! I honestly hope that sc puts this is. Thanks for all of your great work mastermind!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by krunkenator

This is amazing. I think that this may be one of the best ideas I've ever read on this forum. This fixes many of the common requests you see! (boredom, mini games, something different, extra $, etc...) If implemented it would give that spark that clash of clans needs in order to bring it to the next level. It would hook me even more, and get many worn out clashers back to the game! I honestly hope that sc puts this is. Thanks for all of your great work mastermind!

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Nellybelly

Ok. I have a question. If I spin the wheel and land on DE, what if my clanmates don't have DE storages?

---

Thanks krunk, means a lot :)

And very good question Nelly! The clan mates who don't have a DE storage would not get anything in your scenario. OR Supercell could make it so gold was rewarded to them instead, but a very minor amount. Although I don't think they should receive anything since it should specifically be DE.

One problem...

what at would people complain about? Great idea!

Late to the game here and just skimmed the OP, but oh my sweet crumpets what a brilliant idea!

Please SuperCell!?! Please please pretty please!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Mastermind

And very good question Nelly! The clan mates who don't have a DE storage would not get anything in your scenario. OR Supercell could make it so gold was rewarded to them instead, but a very minor amount. Although I don't think they should receive anything since it should specifically be DE.

---

Ok. That makes sense. Thanks.

I am relatively new to COC and this is by far the best idea I have seen posted. I read the forums quite often too. I like how you have included difficulty of quests to both areas, Trophy count and Town Hall size. I was thinking about a prize that would be very rare.. maybe add it to the wheel as a very small section. Thus making it very rare and hard to land on. The prize would be a bag/pouch of regular gems. The amount in the bag/pouch would vary as it would be calculated on a multiplier type counter that starts at say 5 or 10 and runs upward to say top amount available in a single purchase, ( I do not recall what that amount is, sorry) .
Basically if a player does land on that spot a big green gem appears and the player can tap it to start the counter, it randomly goes through the numbers of minimum to maximum at lightning speed and will stop randomly or when the player stops it, which ever system is chosen to activate and stop...it can be automatic or manual. I personally think its an idea that could boost non-gem paying customers incentive to play and try to win a good amount of gems. Thus if won helping them move further along and advancecreating more competition in the game.
Again love your idea here and an awesome job. You got my vote to implement it into COC. Thanks for sharing.

amazing
absolutly amazing

Why isn't this always at the top of general forum anymore?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by fenn93

One problem...

what at would people complain about? Great idea!

---

Lol, thanks :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MasterMerlin

I am relatively new to COC and this is by far the best idea I have seen posted. I read the forums quite often too. I like how you have included difficulty of quests to both areas, Trophy count and Town Hall size. I was thinking about a prize that would be very rare.. maybe add it to the wheel as a very small section. Thus making it very rare and hard to land on. The prize would be a bag/pouch of regular gems. The amount in the bag/pouch would vary as it would be calculated on a multiplier type counter that starts at say 5 or 10 and runs upward to say top amount available in a single purchase, ( I do not recall what that amount is, sorry) .
Basically if a player does land on that spot a big green gem appears and the player can tap it to start the counter, it randomly goes through the numbers of minimum to maximum at lightning speed and will stop randomly or when the player stops it, which ever system is chosen to activate and stop...it can be automatic or manual. I personally think its an idea that could boost non-gem paying customers incentive to play and try to win a good amount of gems. Thus if won helping them move further along and advancecreating more competition in the game.
Again love your idea here and an awesome job. You got my vote to implement it into COC. Thanks for sharing.

---

I'm glad you like the idea and the idea of trophy count acting as a measurement of potential rewrds, which I agree would be very important to encourage pushing. Interesting suggestiong about the gems, can you explain it a little more? Is it similar to one of the rewards on the wheel I have already (Gems)? Is it a separate spin itself to see how many you'd get?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Dinobarkleyj

Why isn't this always at the top of general forum anymore?

---

I asked the mods to move it to this subforum, since it's more appropriate for this one. It was on General for a week like the other thread so more people could see it :)

Can you plz make more threads like this I love reading them :)

I was a thinkin something a little more than just a few gems that can be won. My idea was a desperate spot as you already designated but this would be a small sliver on pie of the wheel, very small portion and very hard to land on. The reward would be a bag of gems that would be given by whatever amount the person lands upon on a automated random generator that goes from say 10 or 20 all the way up to a couple thousand or whatever. Kind of like a roll of the dice. The automated generated will randomly run thru all numbers from lowest to highest at lightning speed, numbers will be out of order and totally random. The player can stop it at any point and whatever it stops on they get that amount of gems...it could be a small amount or a big amount as if they just spent a ton of money on. But the chance of landing on this space would be 1-2% on entire wheel. So odds will be slim many will land on it but be snuff to stake a chance to try . As you said spending 50 quest gems for a chance on the wheel making more eager to be involved, play and interact. Hope this clarifies what you are inquiring. I don't know if you would count this seperate from the mentioning of winning gems only as you spoke of or the winning of sets of both kinds of gems or the mixture of specific rewards along with gems.
Question I did have and not sure it was included in your post of possible rewards, did you include items like additional towers,cannons, wizard towers, mothers, and the like defenses and at different levels? Say a chance to win a lvl 7 defends item or what ever level. This would give lower lvl players a chance to win and win and add an item of defends above what they are at. Possibly encouraging them to carry on the struggle knowing they won an item that could improve their chances of survival during a raid.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Metten98

Can you plz make more threads like this I love reading them :)

---

Should be up a little after the update, stay tuned :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MasterMerlin

I was a thinkin something a little more than just a few gems that can be won. My idea was a desperate spot as you already designated but this would be a small sliver on pie of the wheel, very small portion and very hard to land on. The reward would be a bag of gems that would be given by whatever amount the person lands upon on a automated random generator that goes from say 10 or 20 all the way up to a couple thousand or whatever. Kind of like a roll of the dice. The automated generated will randomly run thru all numbers from lowest to highest at lightning speed, numbers will be out of order and totally random. The player can stop it at any point and whatever it stops on they get that amount of gems...it could be a small amount or a big amount as if they just spent a ton of money on. But the chance of landing on this space would be 1-2% on entire wheel. So odds will be slim many will land on it but be snuff to stake a chance to try . As you said spending 50 quest gems for a chance on the wheel making more eager to be involved, play and interact. Hope this clarifies what you are inquiring. I don't know if you would count this seperate from the mentioning of winning gems only as you spoke of or the winning of sets of both kinds of gems or the mixture of specific rewards along with gems.
Question I did have and not sure it was included in your post of possible rewards, did you include items like additional towers,cannons, wizard towers, mothers, and the like defenses and at different levels? Say a chance to win a lvl 7 defends item or what ever level. This would give lower lvl players a chance to win and win and add an item of defends above what they are at. Possibly encouraging them to carry on the struggle knowing they won an item that could improve their chances of survival during a raid.

---

Thanks for clarifying it better MasterMerlin! A couple things to note: it's already similar to the Gem reward I included on the Wheel. Are you suggesting to have more Gems than what I put and specifically make that reward a varying number? Could be cool, but just different from how I think it should be. Also, Gems are tricky in that the reward shouldn't be sky high, as SC won't make a super high gem reward. It's possible, but from a business perspective it wouldn't be in their best interest, unfortunately :(

As far as including extra defense items as Wheel Rewards, that would be too much and too overpowered. Even having an extra mine is controversial but extra defense would make the wheel too powerful in my opinion. Again if SC did it I wouldn't complain, but I'm just writing as if I were an SC employee. Now... a temporary tower could be a fun alternative! Possibly something that lasts 5 days to a week :)

You could add base defense quests as well where you have to defend your base against CPU armies of varying strength.Attachment 26019
Sorry for the bad editing and the base isn't mine i picked a random one off the internet.

mazza109

it looks like an amazing idea, to let SC know we can keep commenting and Viewing so they do put it.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Mastermind

And very good question Nelly! The clan mates who don't have a DE storage would not get anything in your scenario. OR Supercell could make it so gold was rewarded to them instead, but a very minor amount. Although I don't think they should receive anything since it should specifically be DE.

---

Maybe you should clarify this on the orignal post because I'm sure others would have this question. Just an idea.

Not sure if this has been metioned before, but I thought maybe there could be like a "super" wheel of riches.
Basically this would be like a regular wheel of riches except with bigger and better rewards.
I was thinking maybe if you saved up a high amount of quest jewels (without spinning the regular wheel) you could have a chance at spinning the "super" wheel. Alternatively there could be a tiny part of the regular wheel which would allow you to spin the super wheel. Might be a bit too much, but hey.

Also I was thinking that there could be some sort of "respin" token that you could get from spinning the regular wheel.
For example, you spin the wheel and get a respin token. That is your spin for the 2 weeks or whatever.
However, the next time you spin the wheel but don't land on a prize you want, you could use the respin token to spin again in hopes of getting the desired prize. You could also possibly save up the tokens to respin many times at once. Again, it might be a bit too much, but hey, this is just my take on things.

Amazing idea though and I really hope SuperCell puts something like this in the game.
Keep it coming. ;)