Great idea. Hope this comes soon
Great idea. Hope this comes soon
Hello Mastermind
First of all, I would like to say a thank you for your hard work and I'm sure this thread wasted pretty much of your lifetime..
I would like to say sorry for being an oldie as I don't come on on this forums usually, so basically I would like to ask questions that may be answered but I don't want to look back cause there's too much too read..
1. Did supercell reply to this topic? What was their view about this suggestion?
2. If did, are they planning to put this in any patch?
Other than that, I really can't see any disadvantages and if there are disadvantages you really did a hard work there, Really, if I were a part of supercell I would give you something as a payback and if this suggestion get deny I don't really know what to say..
Radical editing skills and idea, looking forward for this awesome update coming. Answering my question would be very appreciated, Thanks
D.W
I'm really hoping this is in the update...
Thanks Squishy! Before this thread no one really talked about Quests on here and now it's one of the most desired ideas, so it cool to see my thread has brought it to the forefront :)
I wish I did at the beginning, but it's been so long that it might look weird with a hundred votes and almost 200,000 views :(
Thanks, and no waste of a lifetime lol.
1. Yes they did in the early pages, and actually the idea has been talked about in several interviews and discussion panels by SC and the top YouTubers. They all really want it in the game, but it would definitely be a big update. The cool thing for SC is that the idea is completely laid out and they can see how much positivity this idea has stemmed in the community. Of the couple thousand people who have replied in here, maybe 2 didn't like it, and that's just this thread. It's been even more sought after than Clan Wars was before it came out based on polls in general forums (which I have the links to if you'd want.) Definitely cool to see!
2. Think I have have answered it in part 1, but I don't know for sure. All I've heard is they really like it and want it as their "next big update" which basically has been Clan Wars and maybe the DE one. It would change the game for the better without changing the core ideas of the game, and the game would relatively remain the same in what you do.
Thanks DW, means a lot and let's just say I wish you worked for SC then lol!
Much appreciated guys and thanks for your support :)
Have you ever been contacted by Supercell? Or is that super secret info:cool:
Cheers on answering :D
I think there should be an option that can make quest balloon thing visible and invisible cause sometimes u might felt annoying to have something rotating around and around. ( That's just my opinion :p )
I hope I see this in Sneak Peak #3
Supercell has to add this. it is like 10 trillion times better than the clan wars update and that update was boss. come on supercell we need this it will boost the economy a bunch. also mastermind you are a FREAKING BEAST!!!!!:cool:
Totally agree, I just like the idea of something physically bringing you the Quests. Would make the world more lively IMO!
Ya never know lol, I haven't heard anything though.
Thanks man, appreciate the nice words :)
i think you should add a poll 😋
GREAT IDEA! I think SC needs to see this.
Someone from supercell has, and commented in this:p
Hopefully well see this in the update after this one. This clearly needs some time and care to create. I honestly wouldn't care if it took really long, as long as it came out good.
Also, your base edit idea is now in-game, I wouldn't be surprised if every idea of yours eventually became in-game. They dont call yuh the idea guy for nothing!
I think this would be a great thing to add to CoC. And if this thread has been going on for so this long, it's obviously wanted. Hopefully we'll see it soon. :)
Someone needs to hire this guy xD Or better yet, invest 50k into some programmers and make your own empire ;) I'll jump onboard!
I love this idea!
Haha you are too kind :) Really appreciate it. A couple developers from other similar games wrote to me about potential stuff, which was neat to see!
Ohhhh i see, thanks for clarifying that for me!
Thank you all so much, it does mean a tremendous amount that this idea is still so popular and almost 2,000 replies/200,000 views/most viewed thread on these forums. Let's keep it going and hope for 200 pages by this thread's 1 year anniversary, sometime in October hehe.
Simply Perfect..... I Hope Sc Takes A Look
Grt ideas 👍👍👍👍
Please can you see my post about the Defender Mode?
http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...-Defender-Mode
Why. Do. You. Not. Work. For. Supercell.
I created this account, just to say. Wonderful work. I hope to see your idea inside of my village.
Congratulation.
From Santiago/Chile
I like this idea
Seeing somebody so dedicated to the game, giving ideas even though he isn't being paid is very heartwarming :rolleyes:
You are really the mastermind :cool:
if you don't mind checking my base out that would be great! search the clan LEGENDSofSPARTA and their should be 2 champions in it I'm ductwork 7 I'm in gold 2 so you will have to scroll down in my clan a little bit but I'm there
SC, we need this!!!
Plz add it!!
yeah I'm thinking about changing my base its funny tho i and it actually works if you seen my trap placement but i just need a good new base but it is really funny when someone goes through her hand that is open because there is 3 spring traps and they kick but plus the big bomb is down there in her hand so they don't make it very far at all its hilarious!
Impressive amount of work here.
Okay, So I always hate having to change my village but then after I change it I want it back to how it was. My idea is when you open "Village Edit Mode" there will be a little tab on the right side of the screen, when you press that tab it will have a button on the top of that tab that's a "+" when you press that button it will save your current village to the "Village Presets" this Mideast makes it so when you want to farm you can go to "Village Edit Mode" and select your farm preset that you made before or a hardcore village layout, etc. I think this would make it faster and easier for a player to set up a new village. Thanks! I hope you read this!
Omg I have been waiting for this to come out for such a long time… I don't see why they haven't brought it up yet, this is refreshing and not just an improvement on a building or something boring like that… This is juicy <3
Good idea Mastermind! I hope this gets implemented! :)
EDIT: Im a newbie, how do u make a signature? I is Nooby :P
Thanks everyone for your support and desire for the idea! D3n14l, I made it in photoshop, but there are a number of other programs to make it in too.
Glad you like the other idea I made, but this is the Quests thread, think you posted in the wrong thread lol :) Regardless, I appreciate it!
Don't know how to reply with certain area of that reply, lol. I really hope you can get this implemented!
WARNING: Make a poll and I'll make 700 accounts to click that 700 times :)
I think the "Wheel Of Riches" isn't a good idea. It dosen't fit the game and it dosen't look good.
Thanks man :) And to reply with quote, go to the post you want to quote and hit Reply with Quote (or something like that). You are too kind haha!
As far as the looks I totally agree, it's just a visual idea so you guys could understand how it should be but SC could design a much better Wheel. As for having a wheel, can you elaborate more on why you don't think it would fit the game? Or again, is that only the look of the image I made? Thanks.
This is still my favorite post and needs to be in asap
Hi,
I have a VERY SMALL thing I want to ask: having you considered perhaps being a little more about where the balloons come from (e.g. In the single player mission, there is a mention of wizards of wizard ivory or something)?
This will give the players so much more to look forward to when we're on down time during the game!
ohh!
this is a very good idea.
it will do our work easier and faster and better.
i think it should be in the game;););)
This will relive a bit of boredom from the game when looking for a base to raid.
There is ;) Think you guys will like it hehe.
Could you reword the question? Sorry I'm having difficulty understanding :(
Thanks everyone, that's definitely the idea!
I know I'm late for the party, but I have t had anything constructive to add to your post in the 16 months since I first read it.
I have an idea now, though.
Are the prizes claimed instantly? I prefer the idea of having a "trophy room" to store your unclaimed prizes. So when you win a quest, the prize(s) you earn (not including quest jewels or gems) are sent there instead, where you can claim them at your leisure. It doesn't have to have any fancy graphics, either. Maybe just a tab next to one of the icons on screen with a list of unclaimed rewards and a quantity.
It could be an achievement, too.
1 Star - Have all daily quest rewards in your trophy room at one time
2 Star - Have all weekly quest rewards in your trophy room at one time
3 Star - Have all monthly quest rewards and Wheel Of Riches in your trophy room at one time.
And the other achievement track:
1 star - Have three of any quest reward in your trophy room at one time
2 star - Have eight of any quest reward in your trophy room at one time
3 star - Have fifteen of any quest reward in your trophy room at one time
This last achievement could be changed to "use 3,8,15 of the same reward in less than 90 minutes"
I don't know what they should be called or what the gem reward should be, though.
Garrr why is no one else commenting on this! Oldest and most edited idea here- you guys have to be looking at implementing SOMETHING like this!
Thanks for the great post Stealth! Sorry for the late response :(
As for your question, my idea was that they would be claimed instantly but I like your idea too. I think that they should have an achievement for if you unlock all 16 rewards on the wheel too (if they did exactly my idea that is).
Thanks for the suggestions! I think they might not want to add to much extra to the UI, but I like your thinking. Keep the ideas coming if you have them :)
Thanks Julez, really appreciate it and cool that people still really want this idea more than any other after all this time!
I'm curious to know, has SC said anything or asked any sort of question about your idea?
I don't think it gets better than this. You've practically done everything for SC. All they have to do is implement it and we'll have one more fantastic feature in the game. I bet if everyone was as efficient and slick as you, the world would be a different place. Maybe we'd all be making robots at home then. Keep it up man. We need more people on this planet like you.
I think Mastermind such an Idea shouldnt go waste to the depths of Ideas, why dont you PM a mod and try to get bump rights. Like each day you get to bump it like in clan talk. Just once a day so it doesnt get messy
You are too kind, thank you good sir! I am flattered :)
Thanks for the suggestion! However over the past 11 months it's managed to bump itself with new people posting in it because the people want this idea hehe.
Appreciate it friends :)
Wow... When is Supercell adding this? They'd better... haha
Great idea!
I hope Supercell implements this!
They probably won't, but still!
(Marches up to Supercell HQ's door)
"HEY, ADD THE MASTERMIND'S QUEST IDEA THING!"
(Disappears while leaving a message that says "ADD MASTERMIND'S QUESTS!")
You're welcome :rolleyes:
Well it did take sc a while for clan wars so i expect the quest balloon idea to come hopefully before 2015 or it'll be in 2015. Im fairly certain that sc has already started on the quests because they can't ignore it from the amount of support from it. It just a matter of time...
This fantastic idea which will increase the interest in the game further more. I was wondering the can this much interesting . Good idea bro keep it up.
I just spent quite a bit of time reading through this hooked on he idea, it is fantastically well thought out and tho a few ideas may be a bit impractical or harder to implement it is one of the best suggestions I have ever seen on a game forum. It would add so much more reason to spend more time playing the game and experimenting with other troops.
This would be an amazing addition to the game, here's hoping 😸
"The Idea Guy" is most certainly an appropriate title.
As I'm sure you're probably tired of hearing by now, this thread has left me starry eyed. The amount of detail, thought and effort is just staggering. Nothing else to add other than wow, congrats on having the best thread I've seen on the forums thus far and give this man a trophy.
I sincerely hope they are working on this, the enjoyment that would come out of what you have put foward is truly something to hope for in clash!
Thanks so much everyone, love reading your responses! Really appreciate it!
Let's just say at 200 pages there might be a surprise announcement! (No it's not that I've been told this idea is coming to game). It's not really that big, but think you may like :)
I humbly think that all players should consider these things.
Honestly, I did not check all hundreds of pages, so please forgive me if this question or argument has been stated by some other users in the forum.
1) Daily/Weekly/Monthly questing will encourage people to be more active. Sure we are active. But keep in mind that other players will, too. So, less loot, especially those in their collectors / mines / drills. This will tip the balance of the whole game into more questing than raiding others. Not saying it's going to turn upside down though.
2) Holiday questing. Supercell gave events during holiday sometimes just for fun, not for us to pursue better chance at progressing our base. Why? Because it's a holiday, and we're supposed to have fun outside, not sitting duck at our home pressing the Next button.
3) Questing for profit. I get the idea of questing, but having the players to spend a specific amount of troops to complete the quest is not so nice. It may very well bring loss than profit for the players.
4) Defensive quests. I don't think players will want to get attacked just to get the quests done. People that have really tough bases for their trophy will never get attacked, and thus will never complete the quest. And people that has high trophy count will not even bother to get this quest done (i think).
5) Mine / Collector / Drill reward permanently. If the amount of is increased, it will be tougher to get to 50% (1 star) value. People will keep going for this not for the economic reason, but for trophies, or war.
6) Wheel's reward is too game breaking. 10 extra troop space and spell boost will definitely matter significantly in the game. If it's intended, then SC will have to do the experiment and calculate everything thoroughly.
Okay, pout pout pout. I keep on giving negative feedbacks to this idea. So do I have a better solution?
For the problem in #1, I'd suggest that the quests not have a timer. So the quests will pop at an interval, stacking at 5 at most. Not completing it will not make the quests fail, but instead it will just stop popping more.
For #2, I'd suggest that the quests have a longer time limit. For example, 1 week after and before the event (or the holiday ends or starts). This way the people will not only enjoy the event, but they are no longer encouraged to sit out a holiday.
For #3 and #4, I'd suggest that the reward varies, or do more number crunching, or just retweak it. For example, instead of using 75 barbarians to get 3 stars, just get 1 star. Or using 10 wizards, tone it down to 2 or 4.
For #5, it's quite simple. For production boosting, unlock a level of the mine/collector/drill. Give 1 level to just one of the structures. Looking at the TH7 being able to get Level 11 (max), I'd say give the unlockables until level 14 (1 level per TH). But then again, spending 50 quest jewels for just 1 upgrade is too much of a tedious process i think. Well, number varies, but you get the idea.
Overall? I think this feature is a great idea. And with all due respect, supercell has to do something with the gameplay instead of keep releasing new units or buildings, or new TH level. It's not that I'm saying that their gameplay is flawed, heck I think it's even perfect. This forum need more people like Mastermind. :D
Thanks for the very detailed and thorough response terra! I'll try to tackle all your points as best as I can:
1. True, however more players playing means more money for SC. On the player's side of it, more players means more potential for inactive bases (sure lots of active ones), as well as extra resources gained from the Quests themselves.
2. As a business, all SC wants is for you to play (and hopefully spend) so they WANT ways for you to spend money and reasons to play (especially with Holiday spending). They don't want to have you not play the game, they want us in as often as possible, holiday or not. As individuals, I totally agree with #2, but as a business from SC's perspective, that is the opposite of what they want.
3. If you look at the Quests, many of them will not cost you a lot. My suggestions are just examples by the way, SC could add even more resources for completing them. But you would definitely turn a profit by completing Quests, not to mention the Wheel rewards.
4. That's totally fine, Quests are optional so if they don't want to get attacked to complete a defensive Quest, they don't have to. For people that want to get Quest Jewels and resources, they can do them if they want. That's the beauty of the idea, you can do them if you want, and not be penalized if you decide not to do some or any Quest! As far as your point about people having really tough bases and never getting attacked, maybe that could be part of the Quest (like get attacked and win a defense, or without having a shield, don't get attacked). There are solutions for every potnetial problem hehe. For your last point about people at high trophy count not bothering to get this Quest done, that just isn't true as they literally wouldn't have to do anything different to hope this Quest gets done haha. I was a recent Champion so I know ;)
5. Those specific rewards are controversial and I totally get why. It was just an idea, so a better idea may be a week long boost to resource production. I don't think it would be overpowered though to add extra mines. To your point though, I actually think the OPPOSITE haha! I think due to how little of walls we have, it would HELP get 50% easier as these extra items would be placed outside walls most likely and be easier to destroy.
6. Yeah, the ideas I made, like I state in the thread, are just ideas and SC could add whatever rewards they wanted. here's my explanation though: the rewards need to be extremely good. They cannot be overpowered but they need to be worth the effort of spending a month trying to complete Quests. In addition to that, there need to be rewards for people who have maxxed bases and have no need for resources. Besides decorations, the only other thing would be boosts to help them in battle/wars/pushing. The boosts would be minor, and maybe extra time or extra troop slots could be bad especially with wars, but I like the idea of added chaos/unknown/mystery throw into the predictability of the game. The rewards would need to be balanced, but now you can see where I'm coming from.
Really good suggestions though! I like the idea of a time limit but maybe make it longer, and give the ability for when to start one. I don't think they should be so easy that every single Quest can be done by everyone no matter how casual you play. Some should be easy, some should be hard. If they are all easy, the idea would be a huge waste of potential IMO, and not nearly as fun or rewarding.
Also good suggestion about the extra level to mines, I should have added that to the OP (and I talk about it earlier in one of the comments) but if I remake this idea to update it, that's what I'll include.
Thanks for spending the time to write back, let me know if anything I've answered is confusing or wrong in your opinion :)
hye bro are you also suffering from loot shortage?
after almost 2 years, why does this not exist in the freakin game!?!?!?!?! What could be better than this!?!?!?! My own ideas pale in comparison!!!!!! I want this!!!!!!!
I have a feeling that SC is implementing this as we speak. If not, that would be depressing.
awesome idea-- hope we'll see it added soon!
Mastermind I like your ideas and I think the game would benefit massively if they put some of your ideas in action.. In the end all you do is train, raid, and war.. With some of your ideas it would keep it more interesting
Add this!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
It's rough, but I'm doing ok :)
[QUOTE=Thrystan;2911873]after almost 2 years, why does this not exist in the freakin game!?!?!?!?! What could be better than this!?!?!?! My own ideas pale in comparison!!!!!! I want this!!!!!!![/QUOTE]
Thanks everyone for the love and support! Super appreciated here :)
Dear Supercell,
Please implement this idea ASAP.
BTW, Mastermind, did you say you were going to update graphics?
Need moar posts ... Gotta get to page 200!
Is it the secret announcement of your new idea that you were talking about?
That was "soon" back in March! You're as bad as Supercell! :rolleyes::rolleyes:jks
Seems like a really fun idea!
Haha! Difference is I do them for fun and SC is for business. If I got to make ideas for money I'd have like 20 out right now lol. Unfortunately it just comes down to priorities and paid work always comes first, just been suuuuper busy the past several months :( Hopefully I get some more free time soon though.
Thanks!
Wooooow.....GREAT IDEA. If SC implemented something like this is would be amazing!
Great job with the art and ideas..must have taken a long time.
Woah, I bet supercell LOVES this! I know I do!
Bump 😄😄😄😄😄😄😄😄
Great Idea! I love it
yeah, i love it too
Thanks everyone!
And WOOT! 200 pages and just about 2,000 comments! Incredible to see how passionate you are all about this idea, it really means a lot :) Keep sharing this with your friends and let SC you you want this idea. Although it's the most viewed thread on the forum and most requested idea, if you want it you should let SC know.
As far as the announcement I had at 200 pages, nothing too spectacular but just wanted to let you know I'm in the process of starting a YouTube channel. Wish I got into the YouTube game when I first started playing 2 years ago, but better late than never! The announcement has to do with this thread because I will be making various idea videos, and this will be the first idea I'll make in video format. I'm going to be updating the photos (requested by several of you) to match the current UI in game, add some brand new ones, update the idea in general, and include ideas that weren't included in the 3 original posts, but talked about throughout the comments.
In addition to idea videos (which will hopefully be my niche and separate me from some of the other YouTubers), I'll be making a bunch of other videos like base reviews, base creations, how to attack with various strategies, war videos, and others. Give me suggestions if you would, as I'd love your input! Still getting everything sorted out and will link you guys to the channel once it's created and I get a couple videos up and running. I've been super busy lately, but hopefully in the coming weeks I'll be getting more free time to work on them so be patient!
Thanks again!
This seems pretty awesome.
Great news! Can't wait to subscribe :) SUPERCELL WE NEED THIS
After re-reading the entire thread instead of working:rolleyes: I think some of the bonuses in relation to trophy level need an increase. for example, if a TH8 was at 3000 cups, and had a daily quest of 3-starring an enemy village with 75-125 barbarians... there is just no way! Which brings me to my next point, I think the troops quests should be for 2 stars, or reduced in difficuly. When players raid villages of their own strength, the goal is to get 2 stars, with 3 stars being a rare bonus at high level gameplay. Forcing players to use mass amounts of weaker troops suh as barbarians and three starring base is incredibly difficult at TH9 and 10. Ultimately up to you as thread creator and SC if they ever decide to run with your amazing idea, but perhaps # of stars could be scaled with TH level or trophy count as well? Making these challenges exceedingly difficult (verging on impossible for all but clash gods) will entice players to lower cups. After all, the reward could be 14000 gems, if it's near impossible, players wont go for it.
TL;DR I like the trophy scaling, but asking to 3 star max TH9s and 10s with hundreds of gobs is a bit much, and higher trophy counts should be rewarded more :)
Yes, Youtube would be a good idea
A.
W.onderful
E.xtra feature
S.upercell
O.bviously
M.ust
E.mploy
I.
D.o think
E.veryone
A.dmired
Y.our
E.ffort
P.assion and time devoted to this idea
Love it wish supercell could add this
2000th comment