How long do you think until it's implemented?
And how long did it take for you to create/type this idea?
btw: nice well thought-out post!
How long do you think until it's implemented?
And how long did it take for you to create/type this idea?
btw: nice well thought-out post!
Great way to make the game more interesting i love it
i would love to see this...Good work Mastermind!
Half a year later....
Has Supercell actually talked aboit this idea, if no then we wont get it
Please tell me you have some sort of graphic design or codding skills because if so you need to ask supercell for a job...I love the pictures(I have a feeling you photo shoped the league menu for the quest menu) and your idea is so well thought out its almost insane how good this is. I hope that you read this along with all the other comments and feel proud of yourself because this is by far one of the best ideas I have seen yet
Thanks XPro! I'm not sure how long til it's implemented, if it even ever is. It took me a couple weeks to make the images and write out this post too!
Thanks so much all, means a lot!
Really appreciate it Gaolieman2001! I do not have coding skills but am learning :) I actually sent an application in at the request of several members and mods, but never heard back from them hehe. Not that I expected anything, but just figured I'd try. Although some other gaming companies saw the threads and sent some inquiries/messages, so at least there's that! I have read every comment and love them, thanks :) And yes, it was from the league screen, good eye!
Clan Wars made this game top grossing above candy crush. With this... SUPERCELL will be the wealthiest people in the app store! I would love for this stuff to come out!
omg, that's the dream.
i hope they listen to you MASTERMIND!
LOVE the idea, though I would say maybe only get ordinary gems for monthly? The whole point is out them is you needa put in a lot effort and time to get gems for free, going through loads of bushes waiting for them to grow and doing achievements.
But seriously LOVE the idea, they can't ignore this thread now can they? I love how you actually went through effort to show your full imagination of it Props to you, Your making CoC a better game to play :)
Hello Mastermind, I have an idea :I maybe if you don't like a quest, and want to get rid of it completly from your quest list, you can tap the balloon/quest and there will be a green button with 'dismiss' on it. It will cause that balloon to visually float away. It will cost gems to use these features, there is two ways you can do it though. If you want to dismiss it for 1 week only, it costs 10 gems for a daily quest, 30 gems for weekly, and 50 gems for monthly and you Cannot dismiss holiday balloons. If you try, it will say as white text "oh no! The <holiday> skeletons are refusing to leave!" And if you want to dismiss it permenantly, and never have that quest again, it will cost 100 gems for daily, 200 for weekly, and 500 for monthly. Once again you cannot dismiss holiday balloons. If you click the permenant option in chat, for daily weekly or monthly, it will say "Chief, the skeletons are leaving! They said "We will come back one day!" But I'm quite sure they wont." And for weekly nothing will happen. Thanks,
~Scoops
Thanks guys, greatly appreciated! :)
Excellent idea 2scoop! I remember someone suggesting something similar (somewhere in these 142 pages lol) but you go into way greater detail. I like the idea of it costing gems to remove a Quest to get another, as Quests should be encouraged to be completed even if they are difficult. Costing small amounts of gems is the way to encourage that IMO. Nice one :)
I believe there should be again something else like the wheel of riches, but there could be a risk penalty. The penalty could be as low as lose some gold or have troop capacity 20/50 for 30 minutes. Just to add a penalty instead of huge chance to win of gold or elixir. Btw! Awesome idea, threads like this are very interesting to see all the work and thought put through.
Interesting, and I actually thought about adding a negative but quickly decide against it because of how rare it would be to actually spin the wheel. For most people it would be once every month or 2, and for very active people it could be once every 2-3 weeks. Having a negative would be very bad IMO, which is why some rewards aren't as great as others but still great. Thanks :)
Greatest idea I found in this forums. Supercell HAS to put it in the next Update.
This idea is outstanding. I honestly believe this could make a huge positive change to the game. Awesome idea!
I just LOVE this thread, this thread is what all the Clashers want, hope SC will apply all of these, if they would, it would change clash of clans :rolleyes:
Great Idea, but you should remove the wheel prize of 20 Quest Jewels. I wouldn't want to spend 50 Jewels to spin the wheel and only get 20 back and nothing else.
Make this a sticky...hire Mastermind....and get this in the game. Been waiting forever for this...just want it to happen already!!!!;)
This would be absolutely amazing. Please please please, supercell implement this. I often get bored with grinding/attacking other bases. This would bring a new aspect to the game every day. There would always be something different you could do instead of just attacking someone for resources. This would help keep interest in the game a lot more since you would always have new and different things to do. It could also improve peoples attacking skills. Say a quest said you have to use a certain troop composition and a certain trophy range this could help people out and be fun and a learning experience at the same time.
Might be most popular fourm this needs to be added
Thanks so much guys :)
The 20 Quests Jewels o the Wheel is actually a Free Spin as well, including 20 Quest Jewels, and 5 for each of your clan members, so it's actually one of the best prizes!
Love it, thanks for the kind words :D
Appreciate the great support guys, tell your friends and clan's about it, thanks!
This idea is so good! So creative. If Supercell adds this, it could be a bigger change than Clan Wars! (In my opinion of course)
Thanks Ali! Definitely a compliment with how big and successful Clan Wars has been. The idea will help every single player, regardless if you like/participate in Wars or not. Just injecting loot/fun into the game is something every player is hoping for, CW was a great step in that direction and I truly believe Quests if implemented this way would do the same!
Hurrah Hats off to you buddy I wish I could make threads like you You are just spectacular
Epic dude, you make us extatic!
Bro this is gr8 idea! hats off to u bro! keep up the gud work....... i really would love if this happened, would make it more addictive....;):D:):cool: and also i believe this would make a gud defference
How hard is it for supercell to get such a brilliant idea and not put this in already. I know they have mentioned your idea so many times in interviews, why can't they just copy and implement! Can't be that hard. Hats off for the incredible effort you have put into this and I love your other ideas, Brilliant work!! Everytime I read this post I like it even more!:):):) Ps do you secretly work for supercell, I wouldn't be surprised! But if they don't they should employ you:):):)
@ OP 5-10 revenges would be very hard, I rarely have 2 available unshielded and offline.
Supercell please hire this guy!
1. Just an example of a Quest, they could make whatever ones they wanted
2. Then you'd simply fail the quest, or could spend a small amount of gems (like 25) to switch the Quest for another, just an idea. I like the idea of it being difficult to complete EVERY single Quest you can ever get. Makes it more special IMO.
Thanks bud! A dream for sure ;)
SUPERCELL! SHAME ON YOU! this thing should already be in game and I should be already completing quests! So hurry up and put this in game and don't waste the brilliant idea of mastermind!
I love the fact that this idea is still being talked about and its been like 8 months since this thread was started!! My threads last a few hours before being ditched :(:( Mastermind you thinking of starting any more threads?
I know the feeling, bro.
I like the saved layouts and base builder idea, but in all seriously, I don't get the hype surrounding these quests.
They seem exciting, but I think they will get boring after a while - especially Daily Quests. I think Weekly is better.
God I still don't get how SC hasn't added this yet. Probs the most viewed thread on the forums.
Thanks guys, means a lot and happy that people still want this and are talking about it after 8 months! johnny yes, whenever I get time to work on a thread, I've been focusing on a really big one I've been developing for awhile now. Unfortunately I gotta make this annoying thing called money, otherwise I'd devote a lot more time to these threads! ;) The next one should hopefully be out in a couple weeks /crosses fingers!
That's fine it's your opinion.
The reason so many people like and hype these Quests is because it would do the opposite of what you think: it would spice up the game, add more social elements, and induce more fun into the game as it can get quite monotonous currently. And they would be optional, so if you didn't want to do them, you wouldn't have to! Although not sure why people would avoid doing them for extra loot hehe.
Thanks :) The only other non-stickied thread that has more views is the Flag one that everyone posts whatever flag they want, which has been around forever hehe (and also gets merged threads a lot).
You could also find the last things in the dark barracks in this game btw I love the idea it's so good
Supercell put this idea in game!!!
I know what you're saying, but this might make the game too repetitive and boring at times
This week's quests:
Get you're TH destroyed 10 times
Get you're storages destroyed 10 times
Destroy 20 builder huts
Get 300K loot
Use 1000 barbs
This would make people go off the track of the game, constantly grinding to get these quests, blinded by loot, unbalancing the game.
You see what I mean? And how is it social? It's non-social more than anything. You'll suddenly see millions of people with very seemingly exposed bases, trying to get these achievements, making much of the challenge of the game gone and making the game less fun for people who are either more experienced or people who don't want to do these quests.
But I agree about the game becoming monotonous quickly, especially at end- gameplay.
Amazing idea you put in a lot of work and deserve serious props.also a suggestion how about unlocking the last troops in the dark barracks from the wheel
but all in all an amazing idea
Thanks all!
kyum, you do realize the Quests are optional right? ost people that have posted here would want to participate and do them, but you wouldn't have to. There would be Social Quests like donate or get donated specific troops, clan quests, and many other potential quests to add to the social game. Some Quests would change up your playstyle like at least 2 star a base using 6 Valks, or prevent your TH and builder huts from being destroyed for 1 day. It would change the way you do offense and change up defense every once in awhile, again, from the current monotony. Just like you say Clan Wars are optional, so would Quests too. Not quite sure I'm understanding the direction you are going with your post or the point about it being less fun for experience people? That's exactly who the idea is targeting lol.
And as far as your concern about changing gameplay too much, it would enhance the current gameplay, not change anything. You would still attack, still donate, still defend, it would just give you objectives to enhance those areas, and actually make them fun and dynamic, something people in this thread really want to see!
Thanks, and interesting suggestion! I like your thinking but don't think SC would do that ;)
I really enjoyed reading all of this, man. Great effort! ;)
I really hope this would be implemented by SC any time soon, but not sure... I wish though.
Oh, and one more thing only - having one more elixir pump, gold mine or dark elixir drill permanently is a bit too much, isn't it? They should be temporary, e.g. like the builder boost for three to five days etc., ya'know? :)
Other than that, once again, you've put so much time and effort into this post/idea/suggestion, I really wish you all the best with it and hope SC thinks about using this.
I truthfully think this is an amazing idea and it would take someone truly brilliant to come up with this. The only thing is, 15,000 dark elixir at town hall 8? Its a little bit over powered. That can get your barbarian king to level 3 at town hall 8, assuming you didn't gem it or Dark Elixir push. Its not insanely overpowered, but it should be lowered just a tad.
Another thing is for a new troop, should you make it so you have to earn it through the Quests? Not just troops, but possibly decorations, defenses, and things along those lines. Upgrades to those items also come with the Quests. I truthfully thing if more and more people from Supercell see this, it will get implemented.
EDIT: I just realized that someone else said the same thing! It won't be insanely overpowered, but good enough to put in the barracks and enough upgrades to make you want to clash more.
I just thought of something else that could possibly bring in more money for Supercell. Skipping the Quest. It would cost more than you would be rewarded, and the number of gems would increase for how hard the challenge is.
Thanks, CO4L
I don't know how the wheel of riches would fit into the game...
Have read 3 out of 3 post of your idea. it's Simply mind-blown thread. Excellent ;)
A bit problems
Dark Elixir = 15,000 Dark Elixir for yourself and 450 Dark Elixir for everyone in your clan. on wheel of riches sections.
quite useful, but for TH6 fellas or even TH7 that doesn't have de storages and below ? :rolleyes: i dont have a really good suggestions for this, just for troubleshooting purpose hehe
And you can add some achievements from bragging resources/anything to clanmates. for the number. i.e
Banks of gold - Brag 400k gold to clanmates.
the name of achievements and type of resources can be changed with your own imagination. if you want :rolleyes:
oh, and last. i'm also thinking, if you want to brag other clanmates resources like this, you can put them on clan castle. similiar like CW bonus loot war system.
Just it, but other things. i can't say anymore. really awesome.
Wow! What a lot of work. Would certainly add some more fun to the game.
Idk why SC doesnt like this idea... This is just brilliant :o
I wish this could be added in soon, its such a great idea!!!
Thanks Janni :) Actually, they said it's now their top big idea they would want to add, so possibly look for it in the future! As far as the extra pump, I personally don't think it would be OP to have an extra one instead of lvl 12 mines, as they would be roughly the same. But its just an idea, and they could make anything really!
Thanks for the wonderful post CO4L!
As far as the DE prize on the wheel and your concern, I don't think it is OP (and it's just an example, could change). But if you spend 1 full month doing all these Quests and finally have enough jewels to spin the wheel, there should be good prizes on there IMO. And you'd only have a chance to get that specific one.
I like the decoration idea too :) I'm making an idea that contains clan quests and upgradable decorations are some prizes, be watching out for that one! DE troop possibly, I think it's a great idea but not sure SC would do that since it would be a rare prize and they'd want people to get them right away IMO.
Just curious: is it the look or an actual wheel in game? I agree about the look, it needs to be more 2D. I don't agree about an actual wheel being a problem, I think it would fit in amazingly with the current game.
Thanks for the great post Razz!
For your first question of DE, TH6 and 7 wouldn't even have DE on their wheel prizes, and if someone won 450 for them, they simply wouldn't get anything. 2 easy solutions! I think I mention that in the OP.
Mind explaining the brag achievement feature you are suggesting? I'm curious and think I understand, but not fully, thanks!
Thanks guys! Really appreciate it :)
They actually do hehe, they've mentioned it several times in interviews and have told me they really like it!
Clash will never be fully awesome anymore until this is added!
wow this is really well thought out and in-depth!
I will stay in Mastermind's clan for 2 months! unless any of his ideas is gonna come out in next updates. Deal? And I will be member of ur clan
Such a superbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb idea!!
Please please implement this Supercell.
I appreciate your work of writing, thinking and making pics. You've made SC's work easy.
Thanks! :)
If interested, check out our clan website and forums!
Glad you appreciate the work, and thanks for your support bud!
They want to they said, but no timetable as of yet, although they seem to be referring to it as events for some reason hehe...
Excellent post, ExcellentPosts! (Sorry had to lol)
No one knows when, I sure haven't heard anything about it. If they were to add Quests, then my guess would be December.
Thanks, I think it sounds better too, Events just doesn't sound right for this idea. Maybe for a Monthly Quest, but events sounds too formal and real-life-ish, like a wedding or party IMHO.
What about quests that relates to the single player campaign? For example asking the player to 3 star certain stage.
Always felt that SC spent so much time in making the campaigns but they dont really provide much depth to the game for long.
Even I lol(ed).
Honestly, my name suits you.
Why did you guess December? IMO, it won't be December since they need to plan good surprises for December and even change many things.
IMO, it will be halloween because the 'Holiday Quests' in your post mentions 'Halloween'.
I loved this idea so much that I read it completely again and even 10 pages of comments(planning to read all by end of this week)
I found that the most popular question(after feedback) is 'Why don't you work for supercell?'
Even I do feel you should.
If you are a software/application developer by profession, they'll surely hire you if you apply for a job with SC.
I am thinking of more ideas for the thread. Will share soon when I am done.
Edit: One more thing that runs in my mind is 'Is the Quest balloons really necessary?' I think the Quests maybe implemented even without quest balloons popping by. Only a notification is enough.
OMG... This is the best idea EVER!!! (Wow, that sounded really fan-girlish xD ) I also agree, quests is a better name then events. One suggestion, and one suggestion only: It seems to me that the red gems were pretty worthless besides being able to turn the Wheel of Riches. I know how frustrating it is gradually inch your way towards a seemingly unatainable goal ( I experienced the exact same scenario with Dark Elixir at Townhall 7), so I suggest it might be better to be able to use those red gems for something else. Maybe you could use them to buy resources, like with green gems? Or you could use them to be able to boost producers and the like? I don't know really... Has Supercell confirmed they are excepting this idea?
My quest ideas:-
Clan war related.
How frequent the wars are is a main factor in the numbers.
Daily - Donate 35 troops to war bases (This quest only appears if preparation day is in progress)
Weekly - 100
Monthly - 300.
Daily - Win 3 stars in clan wars(This quest appears only if preparation day is in progress)
Weekly - 7 stars
Monthly - 21 stars
Non-clan war related.
Defender
Weekly - Defend against 3-5 attacks
Monthly - Defend against 20-25 attacks
I couldn't think of more since you included almost all of the ideas!
I will update this post if I think of more
So I think about this and I realize that thats not a really good idea.
well...not all of it.
THE Daily/Weekly sounds great - monthly too much and holiday AWESOME
but I suggesting you to think again about this wheel...
It's seems to be not necessary because we already get fun with the game just like it is now.
And when you put there this "Wheel Spin" thing you changing the game.
so maybe you can get prices like a Statue from the holidays and maybe get some money from quests (remove Month)
and the DQ can give you 20k each Mission and you get 1-2 in day? because if you will get 5 it's not balance.
Supporting your suggestion about the Quests but not all of it.
But still - Awesome job you get there! GREAT PICS, GREAT DESIGN AND GREAT MIND.
tell me what you think MasterMind.
I read it all and just want to say I love this idea :) SC should add it, it would be very nice!
Why is this not ALREADY in the game!?
Supercell, time to use those programmers...
Thanks, I hope so too!
I totally agree, the possibilities of specific Quests are really endless IMO. So many different types and combinations they can do. Look at your example for instance... Could beat a certain stage. Beat a certain stage with a specific type of troop. Beat a certain stage in a short amount of time. Beat a certain stage with under 100 troops, etc.
Thanks ExcellentPosts :)
December was just a random guess haha, because they'd want to give a great present/update and Holiday Quests would be for Christmas too, not just Halloween!
That means a lot, thanks so much! Some ideas are actually only found in the comments since there isn't any room left in the OP, like clan quests and specifics about confusing topics.
As far as working for SC, I really appreciate your support! I actually sent in an application a long time ago just to see if anyting happened, but nada ;)
Yeah please do share when you do! And as far as balloons, no they aren't necessary to the idea but I like the more visual representation of a Quest to let you know when one comes. They could possibly circle the base and then leave too. Or you could click on a balloon to see what Quest it holds maybe.
Thanks for sharing! I love the idea of getting a lot of Quests that have to do with Clan Wars and war base donations! Would encourage lower level clans to donate to war bases.
Thanks for your thoughts ;) Just curious about your opinion about the wheel, why specifically don't you like it? You never stated that hehe. It would be like once a month that you would spin it, so it would rarely happen, and it would give a greater incentive to actually do Quests, especially for high lvl players who would actually have something useful to gain in the form of battle boosts.
Thanks you 2, appreciate your support and passion!
This idea is brilliant! Every time I read it I'm shocked by the detail.
Wow clearly tons of work here I hope sc will reconsider it.
I personally believe that war can't be included in quests.
It is currently an optional thing that comes with a reward so I don't believe having quests that come from doing something optional is able to be passed.
It's different then say raiding with 3 dragons or something, because raiding is a big part of the game while wars are much less of a part and there are not too many clans that war back to back and enjoy it.
Just stating an opinion cos I wouldn't like to see quests for wars.
The best graphics cards for gaming ?
Appreciate it you guys, thanks for being awesome :)
A simple solution is that you would only get a War Quest if you are currently in a War, haven't attacked yet, etc.
You know you're thread has made it when the spammers post in it :rolleyes:
Thanks bud, glad you like it!
Recently updates have not been as great. Besides the clan wars being added the last big update in my opinion was the witch update. Would like to see this added in the next month or two they need big update to keep people playing now and this is it.
Nice idea. That would definitely make Clash the best game in the Google Play Store that I've ever played! :P
Oh wait... it already is! :rolleyes:
But seriously now, if this would be in the next "big update" they are planning I would really flip shi... no wait... a table, hahah.
Haha.
I believe you said you already have another great idea for Clash before, when are you gonna post that by the way? :D
Can't await reading more by you, always reading through your first three idea threads makes me hungry for more ;) :rolleyes:
Edit: Or did I miss it already (is it the saved base layouts idea?)?
That would be awesome! Everything about it is awesome!
I've heard about this idea on the forums for a while and finally checked it out. PHENOMENAL idea!!!! I agree that gems shouldn't be used to directly buy the quest jewels. But I have an idea on how supercell could add more gem spending with your idea(sorry if this has already been thought of, I'm not gonna search 150 pages to find out). If you have a quest that you don't think you'll be able to complete, but you don't want to waste you could spend an amount of gems to get a new one randomly generated and the old one ousted. It could be something like 15 gems to replace a daily quest, 50 to replace a weekly, and 100 to replace a monthly.
I've read some of your posts, and am surprised at the amount of effort you put into all of them ! Love every idea you have ever had, sooo much effort into each! Have you been hired yet?
love this idea!!!!
HOLY COW dude SC pleas listen to dis it is sooooooooooooooooooo awesome
Thanks trailmix, sorry I ate you earlier! Glad you read the idea so you can put the idea to the title. As for your suggestion, yes it's actually in the list for ways SC can monetize the idea, by switching out Quests for gems :) Thanks for the suggestion though! Let me know if you have any more :)
Really ppreciate it reywas, and to answer your question, no ;)
Thanks guys for your support!
Yeah, there are a few ganes doing, e.g. this "Beat the Boss" game (the third version of it only though).
That woukd be a great idea to add to this, because sometimes there's definitely gonna be a quest that a certain individual can't manage because of different reasons - maybe the person can't be on enough a day to three-star at least ten bases in one day or such...
Would be cool if Mastermind adds this to his idea and/or SC will implement it when they'll - hopefully - add this to Clash!
By the way, this should be stickied in my opinion - it's so great, it's gonna be bumped back to top every day anyways :P
:rolleyes:
Erm, how embarrassing I have never seen this until just now...
It's absolutely fantastic and should not be sticked but implemented and you sir, should get a prize!!!