1 great suggestion that i would think that would boost clan donations.

My Suggestion :D:

It would just be to at least refund or give double back the elixir of the troops you donated (including in the clan castle in war). I've always had the frustration that no one would donate for the war cc or request in the clan chat since in the long term it would be just way too wasting of elixir, especially if you're saving FOR THAT NEXT LVL 5 WIZARD UPGRADE OR THAT LVL 6 DRILL U JUST NEED.

It shouldn't be that stranger to Clash since if you ever played Clash Royale (like me :thumbsup:), you know you get both gold and XP when you donate cards. Why not make CoC the safe and at least refund or give double elixir back? It would make a great addition to the next update I think.:)

That's a clan perk, you don't get back all of the elixir but you get some

If you have clanmates who aren't donating troops, you need to find a new clan. There is absolutely no excuse if war ccs aren't being filled.

Now I know what the xx% refund does in clan perks. I'm stupid :thumbsup:, but they should at least increase the refund price though. And this should have been posted in new ideas too.

Edit: Btw im the leader of the clan, and most of the time they do fill them but they just sometimes complain about the amount of dark elixir and elixir used to fill them up. Not my problem though.

50% back is a fair amount.

Any more than a 100% refund would be an unlimited source of free elixir and dark elixir. Especially when you talk about a 200% refund, like in your OP. I give away a lot of bowlers and lava hounds in my clan. I'd have more dark elixir than I could spend. We'd have too much of it, it'd be worthless. Why would I ever raid if I can just get it for free without training an army?

What kind of selfish short sighted person needs to profit from donations in order to be willing to make one?

Well if they add the OP I propose removing the attack feature

Might aswell get free gems from it to

Troops don't even cost that much to make, even if you have to donate a lot, 1 raid + collectors should cover cost...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by 11111111111

Now I know what the xx% refund does in clan perks. I'm stupid :thumbsup:, but they should at least increase the refund price though. And this should have been posted in new ideas too.

Edit: Btw im the leader of the clan, and most of the time they do fill them but they just sometimes complain about the amount of dark elixir and elixir used to fill them up. Not my problem though.

---

Sorry op but I disagree, I take it your leader of a clan of many lower TH levels.
Having played this game since 2012, never once have I been in a clan where someone has complained about costs of resources to help there team and if they did the boot button would have been hit by multiple members. Saying that, I have seen many selfish players get booted for not doing there part to help the team.
% refunds on resources for donated troops never existed for a long long time, so the benifates that now exist should already be considered a privilege.
Op, you'll discover that a successful clan accually can be harder to give donations in, as someone always has faster fingers and at times your competing to donate.

Refunding 200 percent of the amount donated would break the game. Can easily see people exploiting this to gain unlimited resources.

The time used cooking the troops is the geatest loss, but since I wait for the heros anyway it doesn't really matter

Only clans without max th11 havd donation issues.
In our clan we have 5 max th11 without any need for lix or de but still people dont donate because they are not online much
Max th11 are bored and only come for war planning and war attacks.
The solution is making the game more interesting for players.

If they gave back double the donation cost, then donation clans would be the new farming clans.

Double elixir refunds aren't coming, but at clan level 9 you get 50% back.

Truthfully, if someone in my clan requests something, I give them exactly that, with no thought of the cost, regardless of how much loot I have or what I'm saving.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tiler

Any more than a 100% refund would be an unlimited source of free elixir and dark elixir. Especially when you talk about a 200% refund, like in your OP. I give away a lot of bowlers and lava hounds in my clan. I'd have more dark elixir than I could spend. We'd have too much of it, it'd be worthless. Why would I ever raid if I can just get it for free without training an army?

---

Makes sense.