Increase the consequences of your village being destroyed/looted

First off I know this is NOT going to be popular but I do feel it will improve the game and increase the challenge. I feel that the consequences for having your base destroyed are not enough right now. One side effect of this is "rushing" and "engineering"

- If a building is destroyed it should have to be rebuilt and until then cannot be used by the player. This already happens in the game but it is only a few seconds and there are no consequences. It should take say 15 minutes (after the player logs back in) for a town hall to rebuild. This adds some more pain to being raided and may add a layer of strategy for building placement.

- Get rid of the loot cart.

- Increase the amount of loot available heavily. To say 50% for anything less than a 3* and for a 3* (total destruction) make 100% of loot available (maybe minus the treasury) and don't give it back to the loser! You can now probably see how this would destroy rushers and engineers. They would not be able to retain loot without a shield.

- Remove limits on revenge. You should be able to revenge as much as you want for say up to 7 days if the person does not have a shield!

I know my ideas have a very slim chance of ever being implemented however I am putting them out there anyway. Thanks for reading. :)

Oh my... you remember what happened when SC nerfed the clock tower? Or when they took away TH sniping? If they implemented any of those suggestions, I think the forums would turn into WW3.

(BTW, I think the rebuilding of destroyed buildings was how the game originally operated, but that didn't last long. It was before my time)

There is no limit on revenge already, and why should I be punished because I had a successful defense and the attacker only took 29% of the buildings while I'm asleep?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Somethingnotalreadypicked

There is no limit on revenge already, and why should I be punished because I had a successful defense and the attacker only took 29% of the buildings while I'm asleep?

---

You can only revenge once now on a single opponent. I am saying allow it as many times as you want for the next 7 days. So attacking an opponent has more risk now because they might be crazy and revenge you 50 times in the next week! :)

You should have to wait for the rebuild time because you failed to max your defenses and/or build a good base. If you were smart you put your collectors out so that those were the buildings destroyed. But if you lost your barracks then no using it for the 15 minute rebuild time! Same for spell factory, etc. If you lose your th then you can't do *anything* until the rebuild time is over.

This would add a whole new dimension to the game and base design! T would also make the real life pain/stress of having your base destroyed a bit more realistic than what we have now.. :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by giantkiller1

You can only revenge once now on a single opponent. I am saying allow it as many times as you want for the next 7 days. So attacking an opponent has more risk now because they might be crazy and revenge you 50 times in the next week! :)

You should have to wait for the rebuild time because you failed to max your defenses and/or build a good base. If you were smart you put your collectors out so that those were the buildings destroyed. But if you lost your barracks then no using it for the 15 minute rebuild time! Same for spell factory, etc. If you lose your th then you can't do *anything* until the rebuild time is over.

This would add a whole new dimension to the game and base design! T would also make the real life pain/stress of having your base destroyed a bit more realistic than what we have now.. :)

---

So you want to discouraged people from attacking by leaving them open to all the people they attacked in the last week. Doesn't sound like the makings of a healthy game.

So if I go to bed without a shield. Someone comes ago two hours later and lava loons me unsuccessfully for 29%,but they get two ads. So now I'm without a shield, I'm down two ads and several other defenses and no cc troops. The next guy comes along and cleans house with his own lavaloon and takes 4 mil each and 100k de cause he was able to get 100% because I was already smashed for 29%

Id be better off not maxing defenses and letting the first guy hit me for 60%.

I have enough stress and pain in my life already. Why would I add to it voluntarily by playing a game?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Somethingnotalreadypicked

So you want to discouraged people from attacking by leaving them open to all the people they attacked in the last week. Doesn't sound like the makings of a healthy game.

So if I go to bed without a shield. Someone comes ago two hours later and lava loons me unsuccessfully for 29%,but they get two ads. So now I'm without a shield, I'm down two ads and several other defenses and no cc troops. The next guy comes along and cleans house with his own lavaloon and takes 4 mil each and 100k de cause he was able to get 100% because I was already smashed for 29%

Id be better off not maxing defenses and letting the first guy hit me for 60%.

I have enough stress and pain in my life already. Why would I add to it voluntarily by playing a game?

---

Perhaps after an attack the base would regenerate as it appears to other players (in regards to subsequent attacks). However for you when you come back you have to wait the regeneration time for it to be useful where you can do anything again such as train troops, brew spells, build or upgrade, etc. Also for collectors they would not gather resources again until you sign back in to see them rebuilt after being destroyed.

It's stress but not the end of the world. It is just more motivation to max your defenses and not engineer or rush!

As for risking being attacked by all the people they attacked in the last week well "war is hell" and "live by the sword, die by the sword". Better max those defenses, eh? ;)

This is a very selfish suggestion. For people that do not play continously and devote all waking hours to this game it isnt fair. Its already hard enough playing legit and not gemming everything to max and working hard to get the buildings. Supercell was nice enough to reduce the cost of many buildings which i think was very fair especially to newer games yo balance it out but this isnt a fair suggestion to other players that are trying to keep up with legacy players that have had a bigger advantage. Just my opinions

I hope you realize that there are other solutions to stop engineering and rushing. Boom beach does this well. You have to reach a certain XP level to unlock higher hq levels in boom beach. That would be more worth it compared to this triggering idea.