Clan War Matchmaking Improvements

We just smashed another egineering clan... If I posted the lineups here like you guys do, you would say it's horrible, a terrible mismatch. But we have two max th11s at the top of our wars that typically out perform theirs.

Our last war was 10v10. We had 4 th11s and they had 7. We beat them 27-20. Smashed them.

Keep em coming... nothing gives me more pleasure then beating the snot out of them.

Still not happy with being matched with higher th then we have. Unless they really mess up war is not winnable for us. Ugh chalk up another win for engineering advantage.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by JamesHowlet

They already did #1. Since the update nearly all our wars have been competitive. Yes, we got 2 heavily engineered matchups and had no shot. But that's a dramatic improvement from before (and maybe 10-12 fair wars something like that) and my clan is able to string together decent wins (we are casual).

No shot at #2, ever. No reason to hand the keys of the game to engineers.

---

Disagree completely on 1 based on my experience and that of friends in 3 other clans. In the last 2 weeks (warring constantly), my clan has only had 1 (maybe 2 at a stretch) opponents who were not engineered. Based on achievements, many of the bases were gemmed. When we have one player with bowlers and they have 6, it is hard to keep people interested in playing.
On 2, that was to make a point, no business is giving away its trade secrets. Supercell has total control over the rules, but only hints to us players how the rules MAY work. If you like that scheme, we should play dice...I roll, you roll, then I tell you if you won. That isn't meant to be snarky, its just frustrating to get one bad match after another because we don't know what the consequences of our war team selection will be.

Keep doing that, we all benefit!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Chrris24

And super cell sits on their hands, and keeps saying they're making adjustments.. Yet I keep getting completely unwinnable wars.. Kills morale.. Because it's all about the gemming 6 th11s with at least max troops of the attack they used matched vs 10s and 9s....more eagles.. More Infernos.. Sure it's balanced

---

Amen, our last war, we had 2 dips, the other clan had 8 because they had a TH11 and 3 TH10s more than us.

us them
th11 th11
th11 th11
th11 th11
th10 th10
th9 th10
th9 th11
th9 th10
th9 th10
th9 th11
th9 th10
th9 th9
th11 th9
th9 th9
th9 th8
th9 th8
th9 th7
th7 th6
th8 th6
th9 th7
th8 th7

Our bottom 5 are even and our top 4 are fairly even, but the rest is massively out of balance. the rest of their th10s are all engineered, no infernos, upgraded point defences and ads. Looks like no progress has been made with the matching system based on this match up.

From 1-25 we are a 17 negative town hall disadvantage.. And 3 of my th10s are new th10s.. No infernos. It's a huge mismatch one of the worst in my war history, last war was very similar as well

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by AlanF13

us them
th11 th11
th11 th11
th11 th11
th10 th10
th9 th10
th9 th11
th9 th10
th9 th10
th9 th11
th9 th10
th9 th9
th11 th9
th9 th9
th9 th8
th9 th8
th9 th7
th7 th6
th8 th6
th9 th7
th8 th7

Our bottom 5 are even and our top 4 are fairly even, but the rest is massively out of balance. the rest of their th10s are all engineered, no infernos, upgraded point defences and ads. Looks like no progress has been made with the matching system based on this match up.

---

You have a th11 right in the middle of your th9s? Seems like you rolled the dice and lost, i wouldnt complain..

Wow! We just got matched up with a heavy engineered clan. We have 4 TH 11s they have 10 TH 11s In the 3 1/2 years I've been playing its the worst match-up I've ever been a part of.

Simply adding weight to offensive troops doesn't work because many engineered bases only have maxed out one or two troops. They have to add weight to the TH level.

Just my 2 cents.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by StickySword

Wow! We just got matched up with a heavy engineered clan. We have 4 TH 11s they have 10 TH 11s In the 3 1/2 years I've been playing its the worst match-up I've ever been a part of.

Simply adding weight to offensive troops doesn't work because many engineered bases only have maxed out one or two troops. They have to add weight to the TH level.

Just my 2 cents.

---

More details please...eagles, infernos, wardens etc, and full lineups would help