It's because your clan is engineered also that is why.Quote:
Originally Posted by chadsteam
People complain too much about the MM where their own clan is also engineered and asking why they also facing super/over engineered than they are.
Printable View
It's because your clan is engineered also that is why.Quote:
Originally Posted by chadsteam
People complain too much about the MM where their own clan is also engineered and asking why they also facing super/over engineered than they are.
Yeah I also would like it sooner, but I like to pretend a developer is actually reading and considering my post and really thinking about my suggestion. So, I throw it out there that they could give us a several month warning to accomplish two things. First, it allows some people to add defense to their base so they don't just have to sit out of war completely. I know some hate all engineers but I am not one of those because many people engineered simply because they felt they had to to have any chance at an even match. Additionally, it would not be good for us for lots of people to drop out of wars. A larger pool increase the chance of a good match. The second thing I think the imaginary SC developer reading my post might like is the idea that if they give people a little time to recover, many will do so with the use of gems.Quote:
Originally Posted by Lunaticfringe
I bet you're engineered while I'm grinding out my heroes with my defenses/troops maxed for my townhall.Quote:
Originally Posted by Makemewise
People like to complain because they lose a war and they need a scapegoat. Obviously it wasn't their fault. They lost because the matchmaker sucks. Unfair. But seriously, this can only truly be fixed if you had exactly even bases on each side. Then everything would come down to base building, attack skill, and overall clan strategy. But that is not what this game is.
Too happy with the update ... 😢😕😣😟
More way to today to find an opposing clan ... Super ... The problem had been corrected with the update before because at the screens my clan had Was blocked more than a year and a half without finding a clan to attack knowing that we made a request after each failure ... Disgusting ... Of course many did not like falling on non-defense clans but each his pleasure knowing That the only way to make money for this type of clan is the wars because the protective shields are poorly designed ... So please supercell, go back to the previous search system ...
i don't agree with this..Quote:
Originally Posted by GarinOregonHeavy
first , it is hard to have all even bases on each side in a mixed war. it is only possible if you have all max accounts from top to bottom, which is difficult to reach, unless you kick all those new th who are still working on their upgrades
we do have 1 engineered th11 with low def and not max heroes... understand we should draw a clan with an engineered account too
but our last war we got a clan with 12 th11 on top, 8 eagles, vs our 6 th11 and 1 th10,5
so they had 24 th11 attacks in a 20 men war to cover all the map in a mixed th war
come on, match engineered vs engineered , but not this way
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jrod55426
So since we our still matching engineers that must mean we are engineered. can someone please tell us how to fix it?Quote:
Originally Posted by Darian[Supercell]
We generally max out our bases before upgrading to the next th level except for maybe a few walls some troops and heros.
Do we now need to make sure everyone is completely maxed? Walls, heros troops as well as defenses. Do we need to have people sit out of war until they r maxed? Someone with only 2 or 3 builders may upgrade their troops faster then their defenses. Will the match maker see us as unbalanced if we work on traps and walls before infernos and xbows? Is there and way we can get supercell to add a notification to a members profile so we know if someone is out of balance and can keep them out of war until they are balanced, or at least some kind of education, maybe a class, a in-game manual, or college degree, on how to keep our bases balanced? What about our roster do we need to kick everyone lower the th9 out and only recruit th11s, 10s, and 9s? If we only run wars with the top 3 ths then no sense in having lower guys taking up space in the clan unless super cell is gonna make clan size bigger.
Sorry for the sarcasm but it very frustrating watching our war log turn red. Iv been playing clash since 2014 and have been in the same clan since then. starting out we were really bad at wars unorganized and putting everyone in no matter if they were rushed or not. We've work very hard at turning our war log from mostly red to mostly green. Makes it so much easier to recruit good players when it's mostly green.
In wars we usually do 20 vs 20 with 1 or 2 th11s at the top and include ths all the way down to th7 in various stages of upgrades in the past were usually match against double the number of th11s, sitting were they should on the line up, then we have in war which we dealt with. But in the past month we've started seeing more and more engineered clans with th11s, 10s, and 9s with heros and at least 1 maxed out army composition sitting among our th8s and 7s. Current war after update 20 vs 20 we have 1 th11 at the top they have 3 with 2 more much lower on the map our next 4 are Th 10s they have 6. They have defenseless bases and th4 and 5 to offset the top. This will be our second first was just as bad. Over the last month our war log is gradually turning red and more an more people are opting out of war.
So the update seems to have made it worse for us and it's frustrating not knowing why or how to fix it. Just want to know what we can do to make it better. We do not want to jump on the wheel and begin engineering ourselve we dont have the time or desire to do that. Wars with engineers are not much fun, cant imagine why they think it is. For us it no fun attacking defenseless base or only having 1 chance to 3 star a th 11 or 10 while they have multiple chance to do so. On their part they they usually attack 1 or 2 ths lower then their th and troop level and easily 3 star our bases and the non engineered bases dont even need to attack. Where's the fun in that.
Stormy being matched with an engineer does not mean supercell classes you as engineered. The algorithm has changed very little. Every base has a weight. The total of all the weights in the war is your clan weight. You are then matched against a clan with a similar weight score. The new algorithm just tweaked how having unlocked or upgraded certain troops will increase your weight score.
Really guys, you NEED to watch the Darian interview on clash with ash. It is on youtube.
Don't believe anyone who tells you the new algorithm is "the end of engineering". There is a lot of speculation verging on misinformation out there claiming engineers match only engineers. Supercell does NOT categorize your clan as engineered, .5, maxxed or rushed. It is just a score and any clan with the same score could be your match.
I agree. I've yet to see any evidence that the new matchmaker does anything to end engineering.Quote:
Originally Posted by PapaTroll
Thank for the reply papatroll. Iv watched ash's interview... still doesn't explain why the number of engineered clans we, and many others, seem to have been pulling in war over the last month or 2 has suddenly increased and the number of extreme engineered clans have seem to increase as well. Epecially after the update. Unless a whole lot of clans that dont engineer have decided to sit out, which we are about to do.
As many have suggested, I vote for a minimum weight thats as least as high as previous th. Think that's the only way to fix it. Im also tired of hearing how much money engineers spend, I'm gonna guess non engineers spend alot of money too. I won't say how much iv spent. But the purse is closed until war is fun again. Hope that happens before friends in my clan deside they've had enough.