You could an 80% max minimum as well. All TH 11s are minimum warnweight of 80% TH 10 etc.
Printable View
You could an 80% max minimum as well. All TH 11s are minimum warnweight of 80% TH 10 etc.
SC really needs to explain more about how they are matching. We had crazy with streaks when it was all maxed bases (because we had no rushers). Then they start changing things. It has been ok....win a few, lose a few.
It looks like if you have 1 engineered base, then they flag you as an engineered clan and make you face an clan that has all their bases engineered.
The last 2 matchups since the update are crazy favoring engineering clans. I don't think SC is distinguishing between an entire clan that engineers vs a clan that might have 1 or 2 people that engineered their second account.
Our current matchup
9 TH11s - (1 is almost max Def, 6 are mid TH11 for of and def, 2 of which are engineered...but have TH9 max defense with mid heros...they only did it to get the GW)
The rest are TH (8-10) people that are maxing at each TH level and then moving up. Most are mid way through their TH level.
The other clan
22 TH11s - (6 are max except for walls, the rest all max offense and heros, but def between th5-th8)
2 TH10 (engineered....th 8 def)
1 TH3
So in our war we have 2 engineered bases.....they have 24 engineered bases!!!!!
Ouchies, one xtreme to anova :(
You really need to watch Darian's interview with Ash.
Supercell does not categorize villages or clans as engineered, maxxed or rushed. They assign the entire clan a war weight and match it against another clan with a similar war weight.
The changes to the algorithm made incremental adjustments to how the war weight is calculated.
More adjustments will come.
The problem is adjustments to a foundation that is faulty is likely to continue to have huge problems. The entire premise of comparing the total weights is right at the start immediately a huge problem. Time to drop the minimum weight per hall level hammer SC. Just get it over with. Tell us it is coming January 1 and be done with it.Quote:
Originally Posted by PapaTroll
This is hilarious. Everything SC touches breaks. There is ZERO improvement to matchmaking. Had they fixed it years ago engineering would have never become the monster that it has. But hey at least we got clash 2.NoSkill to play. Dying... War is the only thing keeping my clan alive, if you screwed this up too well I'm sure the bottom line will show it.
Lemme guess the builder has been out learning how to build BH 7 & 8?! How predictable. Maybe slap on 5 more hero levels to compensate for the defensive buffs recently to grab another $150 off your players? Ever since SC got sold this game has been getting worse and worse, nothing more than a money grab now. Good thing I haven't spent anything since the BH released, That's $25/week I am enjoying.
agreed completely. the total weight is a flawed foundation. as the game is now not "new" anymore, experienced clashers have learned how to 3 star in war against evenly matched peers. the engineers try to manipulate the weight base by base to gain the bully advantage over an "evenly" weighted opponent that builds balanced bases. there has to be extra weight given to offensive capacity of the extra camp space, spell and more powerful troops that come at the top TH levels. who cares if a TH11 didnt max out its archers and barbs when it has maxed miners and bowlers and is hitting th9s and weak 10s.
Quote:
Originally Posted by 2222
This, this and this... (or heavy weight tax, which is essentially the same thing), but I am not sure I agree with Jan 1---need to think about that more...I'd prefer it sooner, but I understand the possible need to allow them to adjust their basesQuote:
Originally Posted by 2222
It's a joke to try and please the people who are purposely manipulating the MM. They will adjust when the MM does, no big deal.
JUST GET IT DONE, SC...
Quote:
Originally Posted by JDwestover
Precisely!
The matchmaking is worse than ever my clan is up against a MASSIVELY engineered clan. We have th 7's matched with th 11's with max air troops. This matchmaking is seriously making wars less and less fun or even worth doing
Same problem, for the past year we've held our own against evenly matched clans. Mostly th7-th10 in 25v25 matchups. Since the "fix", we've faced 2 of the most engineered clans we've ever seen.